Is the brand new battle axe stronger then the well crafted one?

[deoxxys]

cant find anything about this annywhere

[mussij]

Bump and how do they compare to the other axes?

[atomechanical]

The exact details depend on the check that's being made but in general:
The brand new battle axe gives the best bonus.
The well crafted and bronze axe both give the same smaller bonus.
The simple battle axe gives no bonus.