Having trouble with Joy?

[peculiarfauna]

So I'm working on getting everyone's standard ending before secret ones. I've been working on joy ALL night an still haven't managed to get her. I've gotten her evil exes secret ending, but I just can't get her normal one
At first I thought her needed stats were smarts and charm, but I saw some threads online talking about it being creativity. I went for it, and literally all of my stats aside from bold were 12+, I sat with her at each campfire picking her choice, and I'm pretty sure I got 1 or 2 scenarios wrong at max. Am I doing something wrong or is this a glitch?

[LaChouette]

Have you unlocked the tutorial in the meta-shop? It says Joy like people who will make plans to fight evil and dare to act on them, and she has a weakness for sexy people.
My conclusion was that she likes smarts, boldness and charm, and that has not failed me yet.

Also, if you get the stat smoothie, you're pretty much set unless you fail too many events. Just go with her once or twice at the campfire for hearts, and to the gossip log on other campfires to gain even more stats.