Jill

[Broken Piece]

I was doing a Jill playtrough, and i decided took care of Sage.
Choosing her over Jill ruined my playtrough becouse in Episode 8, she rejected and humilliated him in front of Tybalt and all the people in the restaurant, after my MC help her in the concert and thats the way she return the favor, thats bullsh*t.
She could easily talk to him alone in another place, ther was no need to do that.
Do you guys think depending what happens in the next seasons, she will accept him or she will reconsider her choice ?

[Gh0st Harambe]

Автор сообщения: ZiffyHead

I'm even more confused now, I don't see how the OP is even possible, unless I 'm just being really dense...

According to the OP, they got the Restaurant Smackdown because they did not go on the picnic date.

But if you are neutral or chick and don't do the picnic, you basically just stop dating Jill, so you would never get the optionYeah if Sage is choosen, MC wont be able to pursuit Jill further to go to the restaurant to get smacked down.

If you are D1K and you have to go on the picnic to get the scene, then just "How do you get the scene, when you don't go on the picnic date as described in the OP?", it doesn't seem possible to me.

There is no way to have Jill as an option in Episode 8 breakfast if MC took care of Sage in Episode 6. If you choose Sage, you basicly close Jill´s path,

I dont know how she/he have Jill´s restaurant scene if she/he choosed Sage earlier.

[ZiffyHead]

Exactly how I see it as well, Eyez...

I followed this thread for 26 pages, before I even realized that what the OP described isn't even possible and poor Jill is getting a bum rap. LOL

[!Green!]

Автор сообщения: Jacowboy

I ain't gonna read 28 pages... I reckon the scenario described by the OP ain't even possible, so not worth discussing it...

That said, yeah Jill is overrated, sorry but not sorry =P

She is not overrated she just isn't your type. I said before the game offer us many choices with different girl and different personalities. I just appreciate the work DRPC put in this game.

[sylow_p]

Автор сообщения: Jacowboy

Nope... overrated.

You're not alone. Jill's fetishization reminds me of yellow fever.

[ZiffyHead]

Jill's story is just over the top romantic, so people who like romance will find her story highly appealing (as well as Quinn's, which can at first seem ironic) plus (some) people are drawn to Jill's sweet, innocent personality.

[lepom]

Автор сообщения: ZiffyHead

Jill's story is just over the top romantic, so people who like romance will find her story highly appealing (as well as Quinn's, which can at first seem ironic) plus (some) people are drawn to Jill's sweet, innocent personality.

Yes, this.
Jill just ticks all the right boxes for me. She's just so kind and sweet. And the build-up of her story through the episodes, I can imagine, is a bit slower than many of the other girls (I could be wrong) and I really like that. I doesn't just go straight to seexy-time, like with some of the other girls, but the intimacy between her and the MC seems slower and more methodical....I don't know....but I know that I appreciate it very much.

I don't know about Quinn, tho:P
I instantly got put of by her behavior, but as I understand it there is more than meets the eye when it comes to her:). So I can understand the people that like Quinn as well:)

[PlayerH]

Автор сообщения: Jacowboy

JIll is literally the "fairy tale" path... and sure, if you're into that kind of thing, go for it... Personally, I'm kind of too old for that Disney ♥♥♥♥.

More than Jill herself though, my problem with pursuing Jill is that the game becomes a lot more boring because of it... Kind of the same with MJ unfortunately.

But as for Jill herself, I could go on and on about why Jill is not the perfect princess everyone claims she is... but I've done it already, so I won't =P

However, I am most drawn to Jill not because she is perfect but because she is the most broken. (Apart from Quinn who is not really a choice right now) she is the most mentally unstable, easily scared, and possessive MG there is. Which is why I like Jill the most out of them all (due to the fantastic character building), I like Bella least as her path doesnt make much sense to me....

[Jamison]

Автор сообщения: PlayerH

Автор сообщения: Jacowboy

JIll is literally the "fairy tale" path... and sure, if you're into that kind of thing, go for it... Personally, I'm kind of too old for that Disney ♥♥♥♥.

More than Jill herself though, my problem with pursuing Jill is that the game becomes a lot more boring because of it... Kind of the same with MJ unfortunately.

But as for Jill herself, I could go on and on about why Jill is not the perfect princess everyone claims she is... but I've done it already, so I won't =P

However, I am most drawn to Jill not because she is perfect but because she is the most broken. (Apart from Quinn who is not really a choice right now) she is the most mentally unstable, easily scared, and possessive MG there is. Which is why I like Jill the most out of them all (due to the fantastic character building), I like Bella least as her path doesnt make much sense to me....

I like/liked Jill for different reasons. Jill is proper and classy. The more I go down Jill's path, the more I get an uneasy feeling that she will be completely domineering. I can see her upbringing taking control of her personality, and leading the MC to a "ball and chain".

I think Josy is becoming more to my liking.

Bella, I like Bella, but the whole James thing feels off. I know it's the 21st century and all, but the whole adultery thing just bugs me. Call me old-fashioned or naive...whatever. Bella's personality is like mine, so I do have a sweet spot for Bella. I don't particularly dig the Bella taking care of MC, feels to "mommy" like. Much more into equal reciprocal relationships.

[PlayerH]

Автор сообщения: Jamison

Автор сообщения: PlayerH

However, I am most drawn to Jill not because she is perfect but because she is the most broken. (Apart from Quinn who is not really a choice right now) she is the most mentally unstable, easily scared, and possessive MG there is. Which is why I like Jill the most out of them all (due to the fantastic character building), I like Bella least as her path doesnt make much sense to me....

I like/liked Jill for different reasons. Jill is proper and classy. The more I go down Jill's path, the more I get an uneasy feeling that she will be completely domineering. I can see her upbringing taking control of her personality, and leading the MC to a "ball and chain".

I think Josy is becoming more to my liking.

Bella, I like Bella, but the whole James thing feels off. I know it's the 21st century and all, but the whole adultery thing just bugs me. Call me old-fashioned or naive...whatever. Bella's personality is like mine, so I do have a sweet spot for Bella. I don't particularly dig the Bella taking care of MC, feels to "mommy" like. Much more into equal reciprocal relationships.

The reason I dont "get" Bella is because the whole pushing Jill to MC but in the same time keep having a sexual relationship with MC even she knows her best friend will be devastated by the news. I will think different if she stopped Jill pursuing MC when she and MC are having a thing, like how a normal friend would (like you pursue Bellas path, Jill path will auto shut off from very early where Bella confronts Jill that MC and her are having a thing which will stop Jill in her tracks). The path that you can literally pursue Jill until the last scene while screwing with Bella on every opportunity just let me think Bella's character is inherently flawed where she cares so much about her best friend (can see how she is overly protective of Jill) but is ok with having sex with her best friends romantic interest knowing full well this will break Jill. This just leaves a bad taste when I go Bellas path

[ZiffyHead]

I think the entire reason Bella pushed Jill to date the MC to begin with is because Bella is too attracted to him, which directly conflicts with her "loyally awaiting" her husband's return and I believe that she hoped hooking Jill up with MC would solve that issue and get him out of her head.

But to Bella's surprise, she is still falling for the MC and just can't say no to him even if he is dating Jill, her best friend and the last person on earth that Bella would ever willingly hurt.

Bella has basically lost all of her self control when it comes to the MC and if anything, she is becoming too obsessed with him, even though she really is desperately trying to push him onto Jill, so that she won't "cheat" on her husband.

[Jamison]

Автор сообщения: ZiffyHead

I think the entire reason Bella pushed Jill to date the MC to begin with is because Bella is too attracted to him, which directly conflicts with her "loyally awaiting" her husband's return and I believe that she hoped hooking Jill up with MC would solve that issue and get him out of her head.

But to Bella's surprise, she is still falling for the MC and just can't say no to him even if he is dating Jill, her best friend and the last person on earth that Bella would ever willingly hurt.

Bella has basically lost all of her self control when it comes to the MC and if anything, she is becoming too obsessed with him, even though she really is desperately trying to push him onto Jill, so that she won't "cheat" on her husband.

That only works if you got a 0+ opinion from Bella. If Bella doesn't like you, then she doesn't recommend Jill date you, and you don't get the option to visit Bella at the end of Episode 3 (thus kicking off the Bella path). If you don't go to Bella, then pretty much everything dealing with her is fairly straightforward. She does laugh at the MC's "not getting caught masturbating" reference in the sauna, but Bella is a lot less "direct".

Since it's been about three years since James left, Bella is hungry and her "tough as nails" facade is crumbling. When/if she sees the MC as a "good person", then her own instincts kick in. Which does say something about how she'd do that to her friend (Jill).

[nicholas.lin]

Is it just me thinking that Bella and Jill had lesbian sex in Bella's matrimonial bed and her husband James caught them in the act when he came home early from his then current deployment? And that is why Bella feels so guilty yet still very close to Jill? This would explain why he went MIA from Bella's life for so long and Bella's current personality.

[Tempest]

Автор сообщения: nicholas.lin

Is it just me thinking that Bella and Jill had lesbian sex in Bella's matrimonial bed and her husband James caught them in the act when he came home early from his then current deployment? And that is why Bella feels so guilty yet still very close to Jill? This would explain why he went MIA from Bella's life for so long and Bella's current personality.

I'd suggest you're letting the fluff extra renders influence your thinking.

[nicholas.lin]

Автор сообщения: Tempest

Автор сообщения: nicholas.lin

Is it just me thinking that Bella and Jill had lesbian sex in Bella's matrimonial bed and her husband James caught them in the act when he came home early from his then current deployment? And that is why Bella feels so guilty yet still very close to Jill? This would explain why he went MIA from Bella's life for so long and Bella's current personality.

I'd suggest you're letting the fluff extra renders influence your thinking.

No I am referring to the conversation between Bella and Jill. Where the MC came to console Cathy, drove her home and came back. They then had the "OMG" - story-time session. After which... Jill again initially slept in Bella's bed and they hinted at a past experience...

[willjoy2012]

More likely Jill sleep humped Bella like she does to MC