Being a DIK
This Community Hub is marked as 'Adult Only'. You are seeing this hub because you have set your preferences to allow this content.

Being a DIK

View Stats:
anti678 Feb 16, 2024 @ 12:58pm
Some questionable choices..
Hey guys so I'm trying to replay my major ♥♥♥ pt and I'm curious about a few decisions.

Do you think it's the "wrong" choice to tell Heather that Tommy is cheating on her or the right thing to do?

Do you think it's the wrong choice to sleep with Josy knowing that she's in a relationship with somebody or no?

Do you think telling Josy and Sage about Chad's secret is the "good" decision or not?

Do you think being Sage's F-Buddy, knowing that Chad is cheating on her, is a bad decision or not?

If there's anything I missed that you guys can think of feel free to add them to the list.
Last edited by anti678; Feb 16, 2024 @ 12:59pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 17 comments
anti678 Feb 16, 2024 @ 1:02pm 
Oh and also, do you think it's ok to sleep around and date others while you're in the throuple with Josy and Maya in season 2?
Chaotic_Human Feb 16, 2024 @ 1:19pm 
1) If you look in the guide, there it says you get 1 ♥♥♥ point for telling Heather, but honestly, I think it's the right choice to tell her besides, it's in her right to know.

2) Yes, same thing if you sleep with Maya already knowing she has a "complicated relationship" with someone.

3) It's extremely important to tell them, cuz it will have a good impact on EP 10 and that's all I'm gonna say without spoiling too much 😂 (Otherwise, you might get a "bad consequence" on EP 10, but it will mostly depend on some choices from previous chapters)

4) That's ultimately up to the player, but since Chad is already cheating on her, I think it's only fair if she cheat on him as well.

5) Again, without spoiling too much, it's not a "good" choice to make, cuz it will have a slightly "bad" consequence. But then again, it's up to the player to decide.
Last edited by Chaotic_Human; Feb 16, 2024 @ 1:26pm
anti678 Feb 16, 2024 @ 1:32pm 
Originally posted by Chaotic_Human:
2) Yes, same thing if you sleep with Maya already knowing she has a "complicated relationship" with someone.

I don't think you find out Maya is in a relationship until the big reveal at the end of episode 3. There are some hints that we, the player, get especially from one of her conversations with Derek. But right after, MC asks Derek, "What's the big deal? She's single. I'm single. Things happen." And Derek kind of sidelines the conversation to something else rather than correcting the MC.

The player is left with the suspicion that Maya is hiding her possible relationship from us, but the MC seems totally clueless.
Last edited by anti678; Feb 16, 2024 @ 1:33pm
Moonblade Feb 16, 2024 @ 1:59pm 
Originally posted by anti678:
Hey guys so I'm trying to replay my major ♥♥♥ pt and I'm curious about a few decisions.

Do you think it's the "wrong" choice to tell Heather that Tommy is cheating on her or the right thing to do?

I think that it depends of the PT. My main PT is a dedicated Maya/Josy and my MC is not in too friendly terms with Tommy, I see it as meddling, their relationship is actually in shambles, and is better for them to break up already in my opinion.

Originally posted by anti678:
Do you think it's the wrong choice to sleep with Josy knowing that she's in a relationship with somebody or no?

Again, it depends of the PT, if the MC is considering pursuing another girl, sleeping with Josy only for the sex (assuming that as the reason to sleep with her at that time) then is wrong.
In my MJ PT the MC is still not over her, she at that moment is hell bent in leaving everything behind (including her "boyfriend" and the MC), and they had that talk about what happened with Pete and how he is happier with Monica now. The MC saw it as the last chance to have a memorable moment with her before losing her forever.

Originally posted by anti678:
Do you think telling Josy and Sage about Chad's secret is the "good" decision or not?

Again, if you're in a relationship with them, you should trust her, otherwise is not her business.

Originally posted by anti678:
Do you think being Sage's F-Buddy, knowing that Chad is cheating on her, is a bad decision or not?

It's not as bad as being her ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ knowing that Chad IS NOT cheating on her
Mr. Tact Feb 16, 2024 @ 2:09pm 
Originally posted by anti678:
Originally posted by Chaotic_Human:
2) Yes, same thing if you sleep with Maya already knowing she has a "complicated relationship" with someone.

I don't think you find out Maya is in a relationship until the big reveal at the end of episode 3.
Ow! You are making my brain hurt. I was thinking you do know Maya was in a relationship, but as I sit here thinking about it... I'm not sure I'm remembering correctly. I remember the MC saying something like, "yeah you tried to tell like two minutes ago" and Maya saying "no, before that..." so maybe you are right. I'd have to run through the first three episodes to be sure.
Doxon Feb 16, 2024 @ 2:48pm 
Originally posted by Mr. Tact:
Originally posted by anti678:

I don't think you find out Maya is in a relationship until the big reveal at the end of episode 3.
Ow! You are making my brain hurt. I was thinking you do know Maya was in a relationship, but as I sit here thinking about it... I'm not sure I'm remembering correctly. I remember the MC saying something like, "yeah you tried to tell like two minutes ago" and Maya saying "no, before that..." so maybe you are right. I'd have to run through the first three episodes to be sure.

I'm pretty sure Anti is right on this one. The MC certainly does not know, he might suspect something... she sometimes says she shouldn't do things, but when the MC tries to find out why she won't say. It might be reasonable to think that he should have figured it out, but there really isn't any indication he did.
Doxon Feb 16, 2024 @ 2:56pm 
Originally posted by Chaotic_Human:

3) It's extremely important to tell them, cuz it will have a good impact on EP 10 and that's all I'm gonna say without spoiling too much 😂 (Otherwise, you might get a "bad consequence" on EP 10, but it will mostly depend on some choices from previous chapters)

It has an impact, yes.... good, bad, or just different... I'm not sure... it just changes things. Unfortunately there is no way for us to discuss it spoiler free so we'll leave it at that.
anti678 Feb 16, 2024 @ 2:59pm 
Originally posted by Mr. Tact:
Originally posted by anti678:

I don't think you find out Maya is in a relationship until the big reveal at the end of episode 3.
Ow! You are making my brain hurt. I was thinking you do know Maya was in a relationship, but as I sit here thinking about it... I'm not sure I'm remembering correctly. I remember the MC saying something like, "yeah you tried to tell like two minutes ago" and Maya saying "no, before that..." so maybe you are right. I'd have to run through the first three episodes to be sure.

Yeah he does tell her that he didn’t find out until two minutes ago. We the player suspected she was in a relationship. MC did not have any idea.

The only thing MC knew was that Maya told him she had a boyfriend and later admitted that she didn’t and only says that so guys don’t catch feelings for her. she never admits she’s in a relationship however until Josy arrives. MC is just left with the assumption that’s she’s single and doesn’t really know what she’s hiding because she doesn’t trust him enough to tell him yet.
Last edited by anti678; Feb 16, 2024 @ 3:03pm
Doxon Feb 16, 2024 @ 3:26pm 
Originally posted by anti678:
Hey guys so I'm trying to replay my major ♥♥♥ pt and I'm curious about a few decisions.

Do you think it's the "wrong" choice to tell Heather that Tommy is cheating on her or the right thing to do?

Do you think it's the wrong choice to sleep with Josy knowing that she's in a relationship with somebody or no?

Do you think telling Josy and Sage about Chad's secret is the "good" decision or not?

Do you think being Sage's F-Buddy, knowing that Chad is cheating on her, is a bad decision or not?

If there's anything I missed that you guys can think of feel free to add them to the list.

If you want an MC who is a true ♥♥♥ IMHO (note: Not my opinions, just what I think a Major ♥♥♥ would do) you should....

Not tell heather - It's not his business, just stay out of it, why would the MC care at all about Heather's feelings?

Sleep with Josy - The MC isn't doing anything wrong... he's single, she's cheating, not him... it's her decision and she clearly wants to Bone, so go for it!

Tell Josy and Sage - Why would you want to protect Chad's secret? he's been nothing but a thorn in the MC's side.

Be Sage's F-Buddy - again... she's cheating, not him, and Chad deserves it. plus she's smoking hot and fun to hang with.

Another questionable decision.... Defend Chad when talking to the counselors? I can see reasons to go wither way on this one. The MC might want to defend Chad just to try and take some of the heat off... or ♥♥♥♥ Chad. He's a rival and seeing him booted from the Alphas has got to feel good.
anti678 Feb 16, 2024 @ 4:35pm 
Originally posted by Doxon:
Originally posted by anti678:
Hey guys so I'm trying to replay my major ♥♥♥ pt and I'm curious about a few decisions.

Do you think it's the "wrong" choice to tell Heather that Tommy is cheating on her or the right thing to do?

Do you think it's the wrong choice to sleep with Josy knowing that she's in a relationship with somebody or no?

Do you think telling Josy and Sage about Chad's secret is the "good" decision or not?

Do you think being Sage's F-Buddy, knowing that Chad is cheating on her, is a bad decision or not?

If there's anything I missed that you guys can think of feel free to add them to the list.

If you want an MC who is a true ♥♥♥ IMHO (note: Not my opinions, just what I think a Major ♥♥♥ would do) you should....

Not tell heather - It's not his business, just stay out of it, why would the MC care at all about Heather's feelings?

Sleep with Josy - The MC isn't doing anything wrong... he's single, she's cheating, not him... it's her decision and she clearly wants to Bone, so go for it!

Tell Josy and Sage - Why would you want to protect Chad's secret? he's been nothing but a thorn in the MC's side.

Be Sage's F-Buddy - again... she's cheating, not him, and Chad deserves it. plus she's smoking hot and fun to hang with.

Another questionable decision.... Defend Chad when talking to the counselors? I can see reasons to go wither way on this one. The MC might want to defend Chad just to try and take some of the heat off... or ♥♥♥♥ Chad. He's a rival and seeing him booted from the Alphas has got to feel good.

OK you can't say "IMHO" and then follow with (not my opinion) :P lol but I get what you mean.

I agree that not telling heather is probably the major ♥♥♥ choice. Honestly, I think supporting Tommy in any of his endeavors is the major ♥♥♥ choice lol.

I'm still up in the air about Josy. Someone mentioned before that, if your MC really does have feelings for Josy, at this point it's neither here nor there. He thinks she's cutting all ties and moving on and this is his last moment to be with her and explore their feelings for each other further I guess? I suppose this kinda depends on how DPC would interpret that decision or maybe that decision doesn't really matter that much as we think it does.

I'm starting to wonder if none of these decisions I've mentioned really matter all that much. There are plausible arguments on both sides of the aisle. But we also, or at least I don't, know how things will turn out. I don't know what will happen between Heather and Tommy if I tell her the truth because I never have before. Bros before Ho's! And idk what will happen with MC and Tommy when Tommy finds out you're fooling around with his sister.
Last edited by anti678; Feb 16, 2024 @ 4:37pm
Doxon Feb 16, 2024 @ 5:17pm 
Originally posted by anti678:
I'm starting to wonder if none of these decisions I've mentioned really matter all that much. There are plausible arguments on both sides of the aisle. But we also, or at least I don't, know how things will turn out. I don't know what will happen between Heather and Tommy if I tell her the truth because I never have before. Bros before Ho's! And idk what will happen with MC and Tommy when Tommy finds out you're fooling around with his sister.

It's worth Telling Heather about Tommy just once to see how it plays out. You get to see at least some effects of it in Season 2. I didn't do it for a long time, but now that I have, I have mixed feelings about whether you should or not. Not morally, it's clearly the right thing to do... but the way it changes the story in the short term is... interesting, and I'm curious to see how it changes things later (if at all).
76561198968230007 Feb 16, 2024 @ 5:33pm 
For me, it isn't what is right or what is wrong. For me, it's have two PTs each with a choice and see what happens. At the end of the day, when you get to the end of the game, you can decide which chain of decisions leads to the outcome you want to see.

Until the game is finished, you don't even know if a choice in ep1 might not reappear at the end to haunt you or not.
anti678 Feb 16, 2024 @ 5:46pm 
Originally posted by JadenVox:
For me, it isn't what is right or what is wrong. For me, it's have two PTs each with a choice and see what happens. At the end of the day, when you get to the end of the game, you can decide which chain of decisions leads to the outcome you want to see.

Until the game is finished, you don't even know if a choice in ep1 might not reappear at the end to haunt you or not.

Yeah, that's why i mentioned that I feel a lot of these choices are dependent on how DPC views them. Since it's his/her story. And like you said, we have no idea how the story will end. But there's a lot of blurry lines in this game as well.

Like for example Sage and Chad. One could reasonably argue that it's ok to cheat with Sage because Chad is cheating and (you later find out) he's probably just using her. But it could also be argued that two wrongs don't make a right and Sage should break up with him. But how does DPC want to punish you for it or does DPC even want to punish you for it?
Last edited by anti678; Feb 16, 2024 @ 5:55pm
Mr. Tact Feb 16, 2024 @ 5:51pm 
Originally posted by Doxon:
Another questionable decision.... Defend Chad when talking to the counselors?
I have always defended Chad in that scene. It just seems to "fit" to me -- whether you are doing a D*K or Chick PT.
Mr. Tact Feb 16, 2024 @ 5:56pm 
Originally posted by anti678:
An affair with Jade seems wrong to me but... based on how things have turned out so far, I'm curious how big of a deal it will be.
Yeah, I have wondered about this... assume you have not pursued Sage and you have gone all-in on Jade (as much as is allowed in the first two seasons) is that going to help or hurt in the pending cliffhanger at the end of season 2? I mean, it could go either way, right? Or even if you have "selected" Sage and went all-in with Jade? Will they both be looking to help you leading to a positive outcome, at least in the short run? Rhetorical questions. Only time will tell...
< >
Showing 1-15 of 17 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Feb 16, 2024 @ 12:58pm
Posts: 17