Which is sadder valiant hero or revenged

[M.C]

let me know

[Adamant Agent]

I'd say Valiant Hero.

Revenged provides the satisfaction of serving justice, even at the cost of Henry's own life. It was also to be expected as a natural continuation to The Betrayed.
On the other hand, with Valiant Hero, no foreshadowing of Charles's death was provided in the previous chapters. It also hits the heart harder, due to the fact Henry is the embodiment of failure.

In conclusion, Charles is a gud boi.

[LazyKirby]

Unpopular opinion: Revenged. It was just a long streak of bad luck for henry. According to most toppats Henry was a good leader, and in an ending (toppat king?) he was willing to put his life on the line for the clan.And the day Henry woke up from almost being dead, not even half a day passes and he dies. Maybe im being bias here because Henry is the main character we root for but I can't help but feel so bad for him. Revenged is my least favorite ending.

[denzo]

Charles in vh lol

[Xilin23]

vh is the most sad.

[Banafrit™]

Valiant Hero. Its one of the best endings IMO, since its a sad ending done right which actually gets an emotional reaction out of a player, since Charles is a very beloved character, especially for those who've played the old flash games a ton.

Revenged isn't as sad, since yeah, Henry DOES die, but you get the satisfaction of taking down his worst enemy in the entire series, even if it was at the cost of his own life.

[ThatMushroomGuy]

valiant hero... *sniff*

[Andrewbh2003]

honestly VH but for different reasons

its not that the revenged is not sad "there both VERY messed up endings" its just that...henry dying would arguibly be worse than charles

BUUUT the context matters

charles dies a literal hero as he saves henry also as pointed out above the no warning or hint prior makes the "shock" value of charles death even worse

but the revenged...i would say its karma

now i am biassed as i dislike all the RPE endings "yes even TK" as i think henry not only joining but BECOMING the toppat clan is...wrong

the toppats are pretty much the main antagonists of the series even as far back as BTB as winston davis "or whatever his name is" is a toppat and even STD as the diamond was gonna be stolen by the toppats but henry got to it first


so you could argue that the toppats have been the main enemy since the very start of it all and henry joining them especially in the context just does not sit well with me

i think if you want henry to be "evil" then PBT provides the much more thematic henry aproach

so think about it henry not only betrays the government but also forcefully takes control of the toppat clan through blackmail "by not arresting copperbottom" and copperbottom is not too happy about that "as seen by his initial hostility to henry in TK and his willingness to betray henry is TCW and TB"

henry betraying and then getting betrayed was just karma in that regard and then on top of that he ruthlessly kills every single toppat "including probably our beloved dave panpa who is locked up in that cell off screen presumably" all for what? revenge?

so henry dying in that timeline is not as sad cause yes henry dies but...its karma in a way

if henry died by like sacrifing himself to save ellie at the end of say TT then yeah it would be much more upseting and probably be worse than VH but given the context in place i would say VH

or to summarize henry dying would under normal circumstances be worse but given the context in place its not as sad

[Coolguy]

VH
did i stutter?

[rad_knight]

charles died.
'nuff said.

[M.C]

yeah honestly i agree i was just curious what others thought

[Hank-alt]

<3 charles valiant hero the most sadest ending charles is sacrifices himself for the henry
always when i watch or do valiant hero i just want to cry ;-;
CHARLES!!!!!!!!!! (RIP CHARLES

• 2019-2020)

[Hank-alt]

sad but is too endings where charles live and it always funny
special BROvert oberation TRiple Threat Paradonned pals= SBO TT PP
(maybe i bad write first ending)?

[M.C]

agreed i was bawling my eyes out seeing that he was always my favourite character

[Hank-alt]

HEY henry is dont die in revenged (R) it just sit msaybe he still alive after R ending
?

[OpenRoadRacer | Flame of Liberty]

Originally posted by Andrewbh2003:

*SNIP*

RE: Winston Davis: He wasn't a Toppat until Infiltrating the Airship, at least to my knowledge. It had something to do with the events of Breaking the Bank, which in a way subtly implies that "Lawyered Up" was the canon ending to Escaping the Prison; I don't think Winston would've had the impetus to join the Toppats otherwise.

And RE: "Evil" Henry: Honestly, I feel like "Relentless Bounty Hunter" + "Ghost Inmate", "Free Man", feels more "evil". It basically has him as a violent, selfish thug; and while he's restricting himself to the Toppats, it's clear he's willing to kill everyone he meets if it means getting back to Earth with his freedom.

EDIT: RE: Actual topic: Honestly, yeah. "Revenged" feels like karma coming around and biting everyone in the @$$. Henry betrays the Government in ItA, Reginald betrays Henry in Fleeing the Complex, Henry betrays the Toppats and Reggie in CtM. At least it all ends with all the belligerents dead.

"Valiant Hero" hits harder because Henry and Charlie have done nothing but be absolute bros to each other and fight to bring down the Toppats. You don't see Charlie's death coming, which is why "VH" hits harder.