Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3

View Stats:
Ellyka Companion?
I tried and tried, and could not get her to join. Anyone have any luck?

I later found her dead. I put her corpse in my chest in camp in case she can be revived later. Hopefully...
< >
Showing 16-30 of 58 comments
Grumpy Sep 16, 2023 @ 9:39pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Originally posted by Grumpy:

Well i'll you the secret : your vision of the "ideal" female is kinda screwed. So do what you can my dude but you need to own your own choices at some point.
Given the fact that Shadowhearth is the most preferred companion for romance by FAR, I’d say that every romance OTHER than shadowhearth is screwed and is threes only for potential LBGT/ feminism agendas .

And given the backlash it received , not very successful attempt to push these agendas

The backlash ? oh yeah thoses protests in the streets? my that was horrible. I mean Larian had to be terminated and all with the amount of refunds.

Alright i'll play along, i choose Shadowheart too you know.
But it was based on MY preferences. I didn't think that Karlach or Lazael was lesser than her as a woman you see?

And i didn't pull the "i guess everyone thinks like me" card because ,well the world wouldn't like that if that was the case.

Now stop trolling i'm not giving theses jesters thingy and whatever they're called.
Last edited by Grumpy; Sep 16, 2023 @ 9:39pm
Calv Sep 16, 2023 @ 9:43pm 
Have Karlach cast disguise self to become a gnome every day.
Problem solved, you can now play out your depraved "all women must be weaker than me" power fantasy.


And incase it wasn't obvious, your views of women are not "normal" and it would be healthy for you to stop viewing the world through the lens of "my opinions are normal and everyone else is weird".
Grumpy Sep 16, 2023 @ 9:45pm 
Originally posted by Calv:
Have Karlach cast disguise self to become a gnome every day.
Problem solved, you can now play out your depraved "all women must be weaker than me" power fantasy.


And incase it wasn't obvious, your views of women are not "normal" and it would be healthy for you to stop viewing the world through the lens of "my opinions are normal and everyone else is weird".

Hey i was here first, pick your own troll to bully !
victorvnv Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:05pm 
Originally posted by Grumpy:
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Given the fact that Shadowhearth is the most preferred companion for romance by FAR, I’d say that every romance OTHER than shadowhearth is screwed and is threes only for potential LBGT/ feminism agendas .

And given the backlash it received , not very successful attempt to push these agendas

The backlash ? oh yeah thoses protests in the streets? my that was horrible. I mean Larian had to be terminated and all with the amount of refunds.

Alright i'll play along, i choose Shadowheart too you know.
But it was based on MY preferences. I didn't think that Karlach or Lazael was lesser than her as a woman you see?

And i didn't pull the "i guess everyone thinks like me" card because ,well the world wouldn't like that if that was the case.

Now stop trolling i'm not giving theses jesters thingy and whatever they're called.
So you just proved my point. You too chose shadowhearth because she is the only real option for normal heterosexual men.

I never had interest in Karlach or Laezel , but I tell you that if Karlach looked like Alfira or this Elyka or whatever her name is, I’d 100% dedicate a game on romancing her , and if you chose shadowhearth , you would do so too.
Grumpy Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:08pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Originally posted by Grumpy:

The backlash ? oh yeah thoses protests in the streets? my that was horrible. I mean Larian had to be terminated and all with the amount of refunds.

Alright i'll play along, i choose Shadowheart too you know.
But it was based on MY preferences. I didn't think that Karlach or Lazael was lesser than her as a woman you see?

And i didn't pull the "i guess everyone thinks like me" card because ,well the world wouldn't like that if that was the case.

Now stop trolling i'm not giving theses jesters thingy and whatever they're called.
So you just proved my point. You too chose shadowhearth because she is the only real option for normal heterosexual men.

I never had interest in Karlach or Laezel , but I tell you that if Karlach looked like Alfira or this Elyka or whatever her name is, I’d 100% dedicate a game on romancing her , and if you chose shadowhearth , you would do so too.

No i was with Mommy Karlach first but then the dialogues with Shadowheart switched my mind. Breaking the relation with Karlach was heartbreaking though, took me a while to do that choice. Voice acting is on point.
victorvnv Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:16pm 
Originally posted by Grumpy:
Originally posted by victorvnv:
So you just proved my point. You too chose shadowhearth because she is the only real option for normal heterosexual men.

I never had interest in Karlach or Laezel , but I tell you that if Karlach looked like Alfira or this Elyka or whatever her name is, I’d 100% dedicate a game on romancing her , and if you chose shadowhearth , you would do so too.

No i was with Mommy Karlach first but then the dialogues with Shadowheart switched my mind. Breaking the relation with Karlach was heartbreaking though, took me a while to do that choice. Voice acting is on point.
Yep because Shadowhearth is strictly the superior female, both in looks , romance and personality.

At first when you meet her Karlach seems fun and exotic , but then you realize she is boring on top of being overly muscular and her sex scene from what I read on here is dumb as well, she lifts you up and does all the bonking as if she is the man and you are her ♥♥♥♥♥. Although i never seen it , not even curious but you can correct me if I am wrong about it.

Now imagine if they replaced Wyll with Alfira and had that romance scene where he dances alone and offers you to dance but it’s Alfira on his place. That would have been a great romance option and would really have made me think if I should go for Alfira or Shadowheart.

As the game is, Shadowheart has zero competition and it gets boring to play the same romance / sex scene 5 times in 5 different games .

And yet 5 times of the same with her still beats anything else they offer, showing how much they neglected is straight males in that aspect
Grumpy Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:21pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Yep because Shadowhearth is strictly the superior female, both in looks , romance and personality.

At first when you meet her Karlach seems fun and exotic , but then you realize she is boring on top of being overly muscular and her sex scene from what I read on here is dumb as well, she lifts you up and does all the bonking as if she is the man and you are her ♥♥♥♥♥. Although i never seen it , not even curious but you can correct me if I am wrong about it.

Now imagine if they replaced Wyll with Alfira and had that romance scene where he dances alone and offers you to dance but it’s Alfira on his place. That would have been a great romance option and would really have made me think if I should go for Alfira or Shadowheart.

As the game is, Shadowheart has zero competition and it gets boring to play the same romance / sex scene 5 times in 5 different games .

And yet 5 times of the same with her still beats anything else they offer, showing how much they neglected is straight males in that aspect

Well i'm sorry for that ,do you want to meet up so you could cry on my shoulder like true bros?
MakeshiftRiot Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:25pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Originally posted by Grumpy:

No i was with Mommy Karlach first but then the dialogues with Shadowheart switched my mind. Breaking the relation with Karlach was heartbreaking though, took me a while to do that choice. Voice acting is on point.
Yep because Shadowhearth is strictly the superior female, both in looks , romance and personality.

At first when you meet her Karlach seems fun and exotic , but then you realize she is boring on top of being overly muscular and her sex scene from what I read on here is dumb as well, she lifts you up and does all the bonking as if she is the man and you are her ♥♥♥♥♥. Although i never seen it , not even curious but you can correct me if I am wrong about it.

Now imagine if they replaced Wyll with Alfira and had that romance scene where he dances alone and offers you to dance but it’s Alfira on his place. That would have been a great romance option and would really have made me think if I should go for Alfira or Shadowheart.

As the game is, Shadowheart has zero competition and it gets boring to play the same romance / sex scene 5 times in 5 different games .

And yet 5 times of the same with her still beats anything else they offer, showing how much they neglected is straight males in that aspect
FWM.
She behaves like a 15 year old and I'm pretty sure she shags Halisin while in a relationship with PC. She's also dtf the drow twins.

None of which I care about, but...

I'm not really sure how she fits this weird "perfect girl" fantasy you guys have, but it is amusing to watch you defend it.
victorvnv Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:26pm 
Originally posted by Grumpy:
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Yep because Shadowhearth is strictly the superior female, both in looks , romance and personality.

At first when you meet her Karlach seems fun and exotic , but then you realize she is boring on top of being overly muscular and her sex scene from what I read on here is dumb as well, she lifts you up and does all the bonking as if she is the man and you are her ♥♥♥♥♥. Although i never seen it , not even curious but you can correct me if I am wrong about it.

Now imagine if they replaced Wyll with Alfira and had that romance scene where he dances alone and offers you to dance but it’s Alfira on his place. That would have been a great romance option and would really have made me think if I should go for Alfira or Shadowheart.

As the game is, Shadowheart has zero competition and it gets boring to play the same romance / sex scene 5 times in 5 different games .

And yet 5 times of the same with her still beats anything else they offer, showing how much they neglected is straight males in that aspect

Well i'm sorry for that ,do you want to meet up so you could cry on my shoulder like true bros?
I think I already cried all my tears and now I have no tears left to cry . But thanks for the offer
Calv Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:31pm 
Best part is, you know that this alpha bro "all women must be smaller than me" dude is some 5ft 5 wimp that needs video games in order to experience living as a "real man".
Grumpy Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:33pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Originally posted by Grumpy:

Well i'm sorry for that ,do you want to meet up so you could cry on my shoulder like true bros?
I think I already cried all my tears and now I have no tears left to cry . But thanks for the offer

Alright then let us go on our merry way in search of new adventures ! You with only 1 choice and me with 3 (+1).
Calv Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:34pm 
Originally posted by MakeshiftRiot:
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Yep because Shadowhearth is strictly the superior female, both in looks , romance and personality.

At first when you meet her Karlach seems fun and exotic , but then you realize she is boring on top of being overly muscular and her sex scene from what I read on here is dumb as well, she lifts you up and does all the bonking as if she is the man and you are her ♥♥♥♥♥. Although i never seen it , not even curious but you can correct me if I am wrong about it.

Now imagine if they replaced Wyll with Alfira and had that romance scene where he dances alone and offers you to dance but it’s Alfira on his place. That would have been a great romance option and would really have made me think if I should go for Alfira or Shadowheart.

As the game is, Shadowheart has zero competition and it gets boring to play the same romance / sex scene 5 times in 5 different games .

And yet 5 times of the same with her still beats anything else they offer, showing how much they neglected is straight males in that aspect
FWM.
She behaves like a 15 year old and I'm pretty sure she shags Halisin while in a relationship with PC. She's also dtf the drow twins.

None of which I care about, but...

I'm not really sure how she fits this weird "perfect girl" fantasy you guys have, but it is amusing to watch you defend it.

Shadowheart is very open about sex.

If you decide to jump Wylls patron whilst in a relationship with her she catches you and literally just says "I'm not mad, just don't hide it from me next time".

But I guess that feeds into this dude bro "perfect girl" fantasy where the guy can cheat as much as they want.
MakeshiftRiot Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:42pm 
Originally posted by Calv:
Originally posted by MakeshiftRiot:
FWM.
She behaves like a 15 year old and I'm pretty sure she shags Halisin while in a relationship with PC. She's also dtf the drow twins.

None of which I care about, but...

I'm not really sure how she fits this weird "perfect girl" fantasy you guys have, but it is amusing to watch you defend it.

Shadowheart is very open about sex.

If you decide to jump Wylls patron whilst in a relationship with her she catches you and literally just says "I'm not mad, just don't hide it from me next time".

But I guess that feeds into this dude bro "perfect girl" fantasy where the guy can cheat as much as they want.
I... typically kill all of them. My husband wanted to take her because of the temple. So beyond knowing about Halsin and the Drow due to this play though I don't know much about them.

That has nothing to do with character design and everything to do with not wanting camp to be a soap opera every time we rest. Lol
Last edited by MakeshiftRiot; Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:43pm
StarcraftJunkie Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:45pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Given the fact that Shadowhearth is the most preferred companion for romance by FAR, I’d say that every romance OTHER than shadowhearth is screwed and is threes only for potential LBGT/ feminism agendas .

And given the backlash it received , not very successful attempt to push these agendas

I like Shadowheart a lot, but I also find Karlach and Lae'zel attractive. It's so weird to me (since I had broad tastes in women) to find guys being all weird about "my waifu is the only TRUE waifu and everyone picking something else is WRONG!!!"

Like dude, liking aggressive or strong women (Lae'zel) or big warm encouraging muscle mommies (Karlach) is just fine and just as heterosexual for a guy as liking Shadowheart is. And it makes you seem super insecure about your choices and tastes that you've got to try to turn it into a moral/political issue for not having the same taste in women that you do.

Edit: Oh, and forgot Minthara. Have no clue what her romance is like - I killed her almost immediately since I was doing a good playthrough and I haven't started my evil playthrough yet.
Last edited by StarcraftJunkie; Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:47pm
Grumpy Sep 16, 2023 @ 10:54pm 
Originally posted by StarcraftJunkie:
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Given the fact that Shadowhearth is the most preferred companion for romance by FAR, I’d say that every romance OTHER than shadowhearth is screwed and is threes only for potential LBGT/ feminism agendas .

And given the backlash it received , not very successful attempt to push these agendas

I like Shadowheart a lot, but I also find Karlach and Lae'zel attractive. It's so weird to me (since I had broad tastes in women) to find guys being all weird about "my waifu is the only TRUE waifu and everyone picking something else is WRONG!!!"

Like dude, liking aggressive or strong women (Lae'zel) or big warm encouraging muscle mommies (Karlach) is just fine and just as heterosexual for a guy as liking Shadowheart is. And it makes you seem super insecure about your choices and tastes that you've got to try to turn it into a moral/political issue for not having the same taste in women that you do.

Edit: Oh, and forgot Minthara. Have no clue what her romance is like - I killed her almost immediately since I was doing a good playthrough and I haven't started my evil playthrough yet.

Evil mommy with a soft core from my understanding.
< >
Showing 16-30 of 58 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Sep 16, 2023 @ 1:55pm
Posts: 61