Interesting Ways to Break Oath of Vengence?

[Pamparampampamparam]

I know you can just kill the paralyzed tiefling or let the goblin go free, but that seems lame to me and lacks a good justification for why my pally would do it in the first place. Are there any more interesting ways to break the Oath of Vengeance, ideally in a way that would have the best of intentions / be a result of going too far?

[Nani!?!?]

Maybe encouraging Kagha to harm the little tiefling kid?

[Grumpy Old Guy]

I know if you let the green hag go you break the oath unless you kill her during the dialogue with another character.

[Sugarwolf]

I don't know if you doing anything bad can break it, I think the only way is to let true evil go unpunished.

[Pamparampampamparam]

Originally posted by Grumpy Old Guy:

I know if you let the green hag go you break the oath unless you kill her during the dialogue with another character.

Honestly not killing the Hag would be the best way for me to break my Oath, and you get an ability score bonus to top it off. I'm trying to RP as a stern, 'ends justify the means' Paladin who is trying to gain power to stop the Mind Flayers, so gaining power that way would work.

I just hope you can kill the hag anyways afterwards.

To that end, maybe siding with the Drow lady and revealing the location of the grove would be a justifiable way to oathbreak. You need to gain their trust anyways, and what are the Druids and Hellspawn to a Paladin? I hope you can purge the gobbos afterwards tho.

[Nani!?!?]

Originally posted by Pamparampampamparam:

Originally posted by Grumpy Old Guy:

I know if you let the green hag go you break the oath unless you kill her during the dialogue with another character.

Honestly killing the Hag would be the best way for me to break my Oath, and you get an ability score bonus to top it off. I'm trying to RP as a stern, 'ends justify the means' Paladin who is trying to gain power to stop the Mind Flayers, so gaining power that way would work.

I just hope you can kill the hag anyways afterwards.

You can but you gotta cheese it

[Pamparampampamparam]

Originally posted by Nani!?!?:

Originally posted by Pamparampampamparam:

Honestly killing the Hag would be the best way for me to break my Oath, and you get an ability score bonus to top it off. I'm trying to RP as a stern, 'ends justify the means' Paladin who is trying to gain power to stop the Mind Flayers, so gaining power that way would work.

I just hope you can kill the hag anyways afterwards.

You can but you gotta cheese it

how so?

[Grumpy Old Guy]

Originally posted by Grumpy Old Guy:

unless you kill her during the dialogue with another character.

uh, like this.