Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3

View Stats:
This topic has been locked
Belegar Aug 13, 2023 @ 1:33am
2
6
5
7
Why this game deserved a negative review.
The game is a mess, and unfortunately nowhere close to being the almost perfect masterpiece that DOS2 is.

Act 1 is great, act 2 starts of interesting, but it soon becomes a place that i just want to escape from. Act 3 i haven't played but from what i hear it's very poorly optimized and not that good.

The Combat is great at first but it starts to become apparant that the ruleset is very shallow, and i haven't played a crpg where character builds has less depth.

For the lack of a better term i will say that the level of "wokeness" in this game is absurd i have never seen anything quite like it. When you are this focused on including you own political views in a project like a movie or game, it usually comes at the cost of good writing, interesting characters, believable relationships and worldbuilding, and i still can't think of a project where that sacrifice was worth it.

I like gay people, trans people, women, in general i just like good people, and it doesn't matter who they choose to have consensual sex with. But i do not enjoy when other men are flirting with me, and i don't think that is wrong, in fact it feels like a natural thing that is hardcoded into my dna. In real life this is not a problem because gay people are just as intelligent as everyone else and generally possess the social skills to not make any unwanted advances, but in this game the companions have the social skills of a brick wall, and they just can't help themselves to not make me feel uncomfortable. In the end this is either a result of incompetence or a political agenda, i don't know which it is, i just know that it's bad.

I give this a negative review, because the combat while great as first becomes a bit repetitive, and this is a major problem when the character builds have very limited depth. When playing a game i just want to have fun and for a moment escape my stressful life, i don't want to be reminded of a stupid and pointless culture war, so ultimately i didn't get the kind of product that i wanted.

At the end of act 2 i have seen enough to know that i don't want to play this anymore, instead it gave me a great desire to reinstall and play Pathfinder WoTR, a game that is just superior in all the aspects that i find important in a crpg.
Last edited by Belegar; Aug 13, 2023 @ 6:28am
< >
Showing 46-60 of 104 comments
Nordil(Hun) Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:39pm 
Originally posted by Kalil:
ngl this game does give me a strong urge to give wotr another go.

Same, because i have a lot more choices there. The story is more interesting, and Eyeless Mistress(Minagho) is one of the best and quite well written evil character i have ever seen.
I also enjoy how you start to learn things about one of your possible companions, and can have your suspicions because....her allignement is hidden.
I actually wish to purchase the second season pass and then it is go time, and this time i intend to finish it:D
Mania Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:42pm 
So this is how the Ironhammer of Clan Angrund spends his time when he’s not trying to reclaim Karak Eight Peaks.
RKade83 Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:43pm 
Originally posted by Syynx:
Divinity "The ground is on fire" Original "everywhere all the time" Sin
That they got rid of that ♥♥♥♥ is worth a positive review alone for my poor eye if nothing else. I can finally PLAY one of their damn games... with a font mod because CHRIST FORBID they add UI scaling for us blind folk.
Husbando Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:43pm 
imagine rushing though this game rotflol

what a waste
Last edited by Husbando; Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:44pm
Originally posted by Shintai:
Game is very rushed and act 2 and 3 are half baked at best. But we all know why some defend the game all they can.

The game itself was moved a month forward in desperation. Any other game would get bad reviews.

We already had 4 hotfixes if you count 2.1 that was fixing the destruction of your save games. Multiple game stopping bugs depending on your paths are still there. Situations where you have to save/reload to try progress and so on.

It honestly feels like the same excuse making that a happened for CP2077.

Never has it been more apparent that gaming is an addiction, as so many gamers choose not to see how rushed this game is.
Last edited by The Seraph of Tomorrow; Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:45pm
Belegar Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:48pm 
Originally posted by husbando:
imagine rushing though this game rotflol

what a waste

I didn't.
Husbando Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:51pm 
Originally posted by Belegar:
Originally posted by husbando:
imagine rushing though this game rotflol

what a waste

I didn't.


sorry yes you did
Belegar Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:54pm 
Originally posted by husbando:
Originally posted by Belegar:

I didn't.


sorry yes you did

How would you know? I spent almost 50 hours in the game, and i am still in act 2.
Squidfest Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:59pm 
By the time a review mentions the word "Woke", you can safely assume the Illithid tadpole won.
ChalkStorm Aug 13, 2023 @ 9:59pm 
act 3 is good but act 2 is really bad, ngl
Belegar Aug 13, 2023 @ 10:02pm 
Originally posted by Seal Team Six:
By the time a review mentions the word "Woke", you can safely assume the Illithid tadpole won.

I don't like the word "woke" but most people know what it implies, and i can't find more suitable alternative.
Syynx Aug 13, 2023 @ 10:04pm 
Originally posted by Belegar:
Originally posted by Seal Team Six:
By the time a review mentions the word "Woke", you can safely assume the Illithid tadpole won.

I don't like the word "woke" but most people know what it implies, and i can't find more suitable alternative.
"Liberal" comes to mind
Skoffin Aug 13, 2023 @ 10:11pm 
Originally posted by Belegar:
But i do not enjoy when other men are flirting with me, and i don't think that is wrong,

Welcome to experiencing what it is like being a woman lol Except you can say no and it means no.
Also no one will tell you that you should just be flattered, take a compliment, and give the dudes a chance.
plasmafogking Aug 13, 2023 @ 10:16pm 
*Openly woke company makes openly woke game*
*You buy openly woke game*
*You dislike the wokeness in the game*
*Another openly woke company makes another openly woke game*
*You buy openly woke game*
*You dislike the wokeness in the game*
*Another openly woke company makes another openly woke game*
*You buy openly woke game*
*You dislike the wokeness in the game*

At some point you need to learn your lesson, dude...
Cosgar Aug 13, 2023 @ 10:23pm 
Originally posted by Belegar:
Originally posted by Seal Team Six:
By the time a review mentions the word "Woke", you can safely assume the Illithid tadpole won.

I don't like the word "woke" but most people know what it implies, and i can't find more suitable alternative.
What does woke even mean?
< >
Showing 46-60 of 104 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Aug 13, 2023 @ 1:33am
Posts: 104