Should i kill KARLACH or keep her?

[BlackViper]

Right now i play with to many casters i think.. so i could need a barbarian..
but i saw on youtube that you get a cool rare robe if you kill her. is it better to save her or is that armor you get if you kill her game changing? i use shadowheart whyll and gale while me myself is a sorcerer.. was thinking bout changing out whyll for the theifling of you people consider the armor that whyll gets be crappy.

[Jolly Devil]

Originally posted by xposethedarkside:

Originally posted by Jolly Devil:

Don't get me wrong, I can't stand Laezel. I never play with her and I find her mean and annoying. But I couldn't imagine killing her off bc of that. I still wanna know her story and I do put her in at certain times of the story just to get some more lore, but overall she stays at the camps 99% of the time.

Perfectly understandable. I'm by no means saying she deserves to die for everyone, just for me.
I just can't even stomach her being around. If she was always at my camp, I'd look for a new camp.

NGL, I have thought about killing her a couple of times. The way she talks to you makes me so annoyed. Plus she's tried to kill me 3 times now so that's a red flag. TBH I think I just don't like the Githyanki, as I can't stand any of them so far. I might off her in my next playthrough just of the laughs

[xposethedarkside]

Originally posted by Jolly Devil:

Originally posted by xposethedarkside:

Perfectly understandable. I'm by no means saying she deserves to die for everyone, just for me.
I just can't even stomach her being around. If she was always at my camp, I'd look for a new camp.

NGL, I have thought about killing her a couple of times. The way she talks to you makes me so annoyed. Plus she's tried to kill me 3 times now so that's a red flag. TBH I think I just don't like the Githyanki, as I can't stand any of them so far. I might off her in my next playthrough just of the laughs

Not gonna lie. It was really satisfying when I finally shut her up for good.
God that sounds so horrible lol.
I promise I would never do anything like that for real, no matter how irritating someone may be.
But in a video game, be nice to me or else.

[miniroot]

Dont speak with blade of ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ until you sacrifice karlah in the underdeep for baool buff, cut her head, then take blade of ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ and complete his quest for killing her. Now you have OP buff, and got rid of kanrah nonsence

[|--EasyPeasy--|]

Originally posted by xposethedarkside:

I would ditch Gale. He's a pain in the ass with his feed me magical items BS. You're also already a sorcerer, so you can take his spot as the caster.

Definitely take Karlach. I know she looks like a demon, but she's actually a beautiful person on the inside. She's kind and caring, and the simplest things we all take for granted are important to her. She also dishes out amazing frontline melee damage.

She and Wyll have an interesting dynamic between them as well that's worth playing out, so I'd keep Wyll.

He only ate 3 pitiful items, which i have stolen from traders.

[kingsims]

Gale item feeding is fixed in release. You can pretty much nearly give him any 3 magic items in Act 1 and he will be happy it no longer has to be a unique item like Necromancy of Thay or the Zhantarim chest etc.

Hes no longer a liability. Total cost of items was around 400 GP in Act 1. Thats nothing to keep him happy/need a wizard in party.

[Punished Jeremy]

Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:

Keep her. There is no material item worth someone's life..

It’s a video game

[|--EasyPeasy--|]

Originally posted by kingsims:

Gale item feeding is fixed in release. You can pretty much nearly give him any 3 magic items in Act 1 and he will be happy it no longer has to be a unique item like Necromancy of Thay or the Zhantarim chest etc.

Or crown of intelligence. If not, i will kick him away at the start of the game.

[RikaMasayume]

Originally posted by acanis87:

Keep her! She is so strong, I even prefer her over my MC... lol And her story and the interactions are by far the best of all origin chars... Karlach#1!!!

lol best Questlinea, her Questline breaks easy as hell, 2 quest in Act1 and 2 Quest in Act2. can easy kill her Qest-Npc, and one of the quest in Acz2 in a part of Shadowhearts Questline.

[MJ]

Karlash is the only one worth keeping... the rest can go suck eggs for all I care.

[LArc7thHeaven]

Gameplay wise, barbarian is OP support tank with b1tch slapping ability thanks to wolf primal rage and high strength, better tank than fighter so it's my go to tank but you can always respec anyone to fill her role. Give barbarian enlarge person then you got super tank, extra using suttur greatsword to shut those spellcaster mouth.

For gale problem it's kinda complicated at first but your light-handed character can always robbing vendor's magic items.

[[TG] zac]

Originally posted by UK Mikeyboy:

Tempted to kill her when we first met. Then I kept her around as a barbarian buddy for my party (my composition is me: Barbarian, her (Barbarian), Githy (Fighter), and Mr Rogue). Since then I've not had to change my party up at all.

You are losing so much potential not having a caster.

I'm guessing you are playing on story because on harder difficulty not having someone to do aoe crowd control or blasting would punish you hard.

[kingsims]

Haste is hella OP on Sorc. Sorc Level 5 twinned haste just breaks battles. Cast twinned haste, then quicken fireball. Run way and watch your fighters mop the entire battlefield. (Whatever is left alive after your fireball) or take haste potion and cast scroll of invisbility and duck out the corner and watch the AI lead itself to slaughter

[Volk]

Originally posted by BlackViper:

Right now i play with to many casters i think.. so i could need a barbarian..
but i saw on youtube that you get a cool rare robe if you kill her. is it better to save her or is that armor you get if you kill her game changing? i use shadowheart whyll and gale while me myself is a sorcerer.. was thinking bout changing out whyll for the theifling of you people consider the armor that whyll gets be crappy.

psa you can respec companions with withers

[Snake Bit]

Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:

Keep her. There is no material item worth someone's life. (Now if they are deliberately trying to end yours or someone elses. Well then by all means.

As far as I know, unless provoked, Karlach doesn't fit in that catagory.

I really don't agree with that. Now, that said Karlach is probably the only character I enjoyed having in my party to the degree that she's just a trash talking murder machine.

[teksuo]

she's great. i love throwing blue/pink weapons at enemies once said weapons are obsolete to wear. dmg+prone? that's a W.

she aint too bad at slapping things with a big weapon as well.