Should i kill KARLACH or keep her?

[BlackViper]

Right now i play with to many casters i think.. so i could need a barbarian..
but i saw on youtube that you get a cool rare robe if you kill her. is it better to save her or is that armor you get if you kill her game changing? i use shadowheart whyll and gale while me myself is a sorcerer.. was thinking bout changing out whyll for the theifling of you people consider the armor that whyll gets be crappy.

[Xenomorph Kitty]

Karlach is best girl, she is adorable. Mainly as she takes simple things as super important as due to her back story she's pretty much been isolated from the world for many years including touch. So, something as basic as a hug is super special to her.

Also as to the complaints about Gale's thing, is that still happening with people exaggerating about how bad it is? My god..

It's nothing. He takes a grand total of three items, by the point he starts asking for them you should have plenty anyway and they can be any quality from green upwards. After he's had three he doesn't ask for more. It's really not a big deal.

[ocamiac]

Keep her! She is so strong, I even prefer her over my MC... lol And her story and the interactions are by far the best of all origin chars... Karlach#1!!!

[BlackViper]

Origineel geplaatst door ACS36:

Stop meta gaming and start role playing.

What kind of character are you? What are your motives? What values do you have? If you're running around killing people because you heard you could get special items if you did, you're not actually playing the game.

Try seeing where the game can take you if you embody your character as if they were a real living thing.

its not only about killing .. you get Mithra if you Kill the devil thingy And the grove aswell..
and im trying to figure out wich one of them to go for cause mithra is sexy as ♥♥♥♥..

[LeftPaw]

Deffo keep Karlach, she has to be the most useful warrior of the bunch and she's not up her own bum like the others, Dump wyll while your at it, he's a wittle wuss along with that creep Gale. What you left with?

[BlackViper]

Origineel geplaatst door Seri:

Karlach is best girl, she is adorable. Mainly as she takes simple things as super important as due to her back story she's pretty much been isolated from the world for many years including touch. So, something as basic as a hug is super special to her.

Also as to the complaints about Gale's thing, is that still happening with people exaggerating about how bad it is? My god..

It's nothing. He takes a grand total of three items, by the point he starts asking for them you should have plenty anyway and they can be any quality from green upwards. After he's had three he doesn't ask for more. It's really not a big deal.

what about mithra? the paladin? ive read i cant have her and karlash at the same time..
i dont know if a paladin is better then a barbarian.. and if mithra is fun to engage with in the game.

[Yagger]

Origineel geplaatst door xposethedarkside:

I would ditch Gale. He's a pain in the ass with his feed me magical items BS.

its 3 items nothing to cry over

[Xenomorph Kitty]

Origineel geplaatst door BlackViper:

Origineel geplaatst door Seri:

Karlach is best girl, she is adorable. Mainly as she takes simple things as super important as due to her back story she's pretty much been isolated from the world for many years including touch. So, something as basic as a hug is super special to her.

Also as to the complaints about Gale's thing, is that still happening with people exaggerating about how bad it is? My god..

It's nothing. He takes a grand total of three items, by the point he starts asking for them you should have plenty anyway and they can be any quality from green upwards. After he's had three he doesn't ask for more. It's really not a big deal.

what about mithra? the paladin? ive read i cant have her and karlash at the same time..
i dont know if a paladin is better then a barbarian.. and if mithra is fun to engage with in the game.

I can't speak to if she's fun or not, I killed her.

If you recruit Minthara that pretty much means you butcher the druids and tieflings in the grove which means Wyll and Karlach should leave you although I've heard that they stick around for some people?

Might be a persuasion check or something if your relationship score was high enough with them, idk.

Paladin is a melee/support hybrid that has lots of upfront damage with their smites. And support stuff along with it.

Barbarian is tanky melee damage. I prefer barbarians, but then I've not actually used a paladin yet so i'm likely biased.

[Myr Superion]

Origineel geplaatst door BlackViper:

its not only about killing .. you get Mithra if you Kill the devil thingy And the grove aswell.. and im trying to figure out wich one of them to go for cause mithra is sexy as ♥♥♥♥..

You can have both. You just have to avoid the final confrontation of the grove and leave early. This cuts you out of fun content though obviously.

[BlackViper]

Origineel geplaatst door LeftPaw:

Deffo keep Karlach, she has to be the most useful warrior of the bunch and she's not up her own bum like the others, Dump wyll while your at it, he's a wittle wuss along with that creep Gale. What you left with?

what about Minthara ? heard i cant have Karlach at the same time..
yea gale to me seems like a pedofile i dont know i dont like him but i need the powers he posesses.. specialy if i will kick whyll wich will be replaced with karlach . cause whyll posesses the same skill i want to keep as gale does.. but i prefare gale over whyll anytime.

[Xenomorph Kitty]

Origineel geplaatst door BlackViper:

Origineel geplaatst door LeftPaw:

Deffo keep Karlach, she has to be the most useful warrior of the bunch and she's not up her own bum like the others, Dump wyll while your at it, he's a wittle wuss along with that creep Gale. What you left with?

what about Minthara ? heard i cant have Karlach at the same time..
yea gale to me seems like a pedofile i dont know i dont like him but i need the powers he posesses.. specialy if i will kick whyll wich will be replaced with karlach . cause whyll posesses the same skill i want to keep as gale does.. but i prefare gale over whyll anytime.

Just a note, it's really not a good look for you to throw around pedo accusations even if it's about a fictional character. I don't know why people find Gale creepy, he's really not. And his story is really cool I think.

[Frank Reynolds]

It's your game, why don't you make a decision and deal with the repercussion of said actions?

[terror923]

keep her she does amazing damage

[BlackViper]

Origineel geplaatst door Brent McKowski:

It's your game, why don't you make a decision and deal with the repercussion of said actions?

true words.

[Gabu Mcgoober]

She's one of the best to have on team. Keep her kill the paladin posers.

[xposethedarkside]

Origineel geplaatst door BlackViper:

Origineel geplaatst door LeftPaw:

Deffo keep Karlach, she has to be the most useful warrior of the bunch and she's not up her own bum like the others, Dump wyll while your at it, he's a wittle wuss along with that creep Gale. What you left with?

what about Minthara ? heard i cant have Karlach at the same time..
yea gale to me seems like a pedofile i dont know i dont like him but i need the powers he posesses.. specialy if i will kick whyll wich will be replaced with karlach . cause whyll posesses the same skill i want to keep as gale does.. but i prefare gale over whyll anytime.

I don't know if you can have them both, even if you could I don't imagine it would last long. To make ones approval go up, you invariably would make the others go down. But you said you were doing a good playthrough, so I don't see how you could choose Minthara over Karlach. Yes, Minthara is easy on the eyes, but she's evil to the core.