Shadowheart approves that you rob the fishermen

[Shampoo]

I hope that is added back in the full game.

That made me laugh.

[katzenkrimis]

That is strange. She hates most of my decisions.

She won't survive this adventure.

I'll bet my shield on it.

[wtiger27]

She also approves if you use deception at times. Like in getting the soul coin from the Triefling lady. If one is wanting to romance her, they need to learn what she will approve of and how to avoid too much disapproval. She can be tricky with approval. This is where EA can be beneficial.

[Ghost]

Likes pragmatism and looking out for her own (the party and other urchins)

[boo_guy]

The only thing I've got nailed down on her is that she dislikes me telling random people about the tadpoles.

Agreeing to help people sometimes gets disapproval.

I roared at a crazy guy once, she found that amusing.

[dolby]

what fishermen, lol? how on earth did i miss that..

[wtiger27]

Originally posted by boo_guy:

The only thing I've got nailed down on her is that she dislikes me telling random people about the tadpoles.

I roared at a crazy guy once, she found that amusing.

She also dislikes it if you bring on unnecessary combat. Like breaking up the two having sex in the shed.

[boo_guy]

Originally posted by wtiger27:

Originally posted by boo_guy:

The only thing I've got nailed down on her is that she dislikes me telling random people about the tadpoles.

I roared at a crazy guy once, she found that amusing.

She also dislikes it if you bring on unnecessary combat. Like breaking up the two having sex in the shed.

I figured that was more for having to see those two going at it than the actual combat lol.

[A Disembodied Intelligence]

Originally posted by Ghost:

Likes pragmatism and looking out for her own (the party and other urchins)

Has a soft spot for kids though, unlike Lae'zel I think, lol.

[wtiger27]

Originally posted by boo_guy:

Originally posted by wtiger27:

She also dislikes it if you bring on unnecessary combat. Like breaking up the two having sex in the shed.

I figured that was more for having to see those two going at it than the actual combat lol.

Could be. But she also does not like it when you expose Aunt Ethel for who she really is. A witch. Not a helpless old lady. :P Shadowheart is one of the hardest to get high approval from my experience in EA.

[.Master Jiren, The Strongest]

Originally posted by wtiger27:

She also approves if you use deception at times. Like in getting the soul coin from the Triefling lady. If one is wanting to romance her, they need to learn what she will approve of and how to avoid too much disapproval. She can be tricky with approval. This is where EA can be beneficial.

oh yeah. shes just like a real woman. its kinda ridiculous.
oh she wants you to approve of her and care but dont you dare ask her any actual questions or expect her to explain herself.

jesus. never seen a game before where every dialogue option is the wrong choice.
the best thing to do is when she shows that she isnt interested in sharing, the game actually means it, dont press her on -anything-. and anytime the game gives you the option to just be silent, take it, theres a reason its an option.

game too realistic

[boo_guy]

Originally posted by wtiger27:

Originally posted by boo_guy:

I figured that was more for having to see those two going at it than the actual combat lol.

Could be. But she also does not like it when you expose Aunt Ethel for who she really is. A witch. Not a helpless old lady. :P Shadowheart is one of the hardest to get high approval from my experience in EA.

I find it a bit odd that she has so many soft spots since she seems to be respected enough in her Church to be given important missions.

It doesn't seem to fit together quite right.

[Ghost]

Originally posted by Maronchan:

Does no one notice that Shadowheart is essentially brainwashed? Wow...

Not essentially, but actually.

[wtiger27]

Originally posted by boo_guy:

Originally posted by wtiger27:

Could be. But she also does not like it when you expose Aunt Ethel for who she really is. A witch. Not a helpless old lady. :P Shadowheart is one of the hardest to get high approval from my experience in EA.

I find it a bit odd that she has some many soft spots since she seems to be respected enough in her Church to be given important missions.

It doesn't seem to fit together quite right.

Yeah. I think it will be possible to change her mind in the future and redeem her from her crazy religion. That is what I gathered from the PFH event. That it can be good to not always get their approval, but to challenge why they feel the way they do.

[jennireneex]

Originally posted by boo_guy:

Originally posted by wtiger27:

Could be. But she also does not like it when you expose Aunt Ethel for who she really is. A witch. Not a helpless old lady. :P Shadowheart is one of the hardest to get high approval from my experience in EA.

I find it a bit odd that she has so many soft spots since she seems to be respected enough in her Church to be given important missions.

It doesn't seem to fit together quite right.

I seem to recall she mentioned there were others that came along as well. Maybe she was just the trainee that came along with other more skilled members. Guess will see as the story progresses.