Knocking Minthara off in a Goblin Camp question

[genesiset]

My first playthrough. I'm in a goblin camp. I acidentally heard before that you can miss Minthara as a companion. So I googled and I'm confused. Some people said you have to choose to either recruit a Minthara or Halsin. Then there were comments saying you can 'now' recruit both, but it's ridiculosly specific: you need to kill Gut Priestess, then rescue Halsin from the cell, do not let him join you immediately, go steal something from Minthara to make her temporary hostile, use non-lethal attacks to knock her out, then go kill the other goblin boss, and then you'll be able to rescue Minthara in ACT2 and have Halsin as a companion, too.
And then there are another comments saying they, AGAIN, changed something.

I don't understand what is the relevant thing today, can anyone explain?
And why does it look so hard to recruit her? And what exactly does it mean 'to knock her out with non-lethal attacks' - do I slap her a thousand times to reduce her HP to 0 or how exactly does it work? And won't the entire goblin camp become hostile if I attack her? There's someone else near her, plus the eye.
I want to get both her and Halsin in my team.

[Dorian Gray]

Автор сообщения: shadow's embrace

Автор сообщения: genesiset

My first playthrough. I'm in a goblin camp. I acidentally heard before that you can miss Minthara as a companion. So I googled and I'm confused. Some people said you have to choose to either recruit a Minthara or Halsin. Then there were comments saying you can 'now' recruit both, but it's ridiculosly specific: you need to kill Gut Priestess, then rescue Halsin from the cell, do not let him join you immediately, go steal something from Minthara to make her temporary hostile, use non-lethal attacks to knock her out, then go kill the other goblin boss, and then you'll be able to rescue Minthara in ACT2 and have Halsin as a companion, too.
And then there are another comments saying they, AGAIN, changed something.

I don't understand what is the relevant thing today, can anyone explain?
And why does it look so hard to recruit her? And what exactly does it mean 'to knock her out with non-lethal attacks' - do I slap her a thousand times to reduce her HP to 0 or how exactly does it work? And won't the entire goblin camp become hostile if I attack her? There's someone else near her, plus the eye.
I want to get both her and Halsin in my team.

this is what you do

1 find minthara in the temple/goblin camp in act 1
2 go to your passives tab and turn on non-lethal attacks
3 attack minthara and get temporary hostile, proceed to knock her out with melee attacks, DO NOT ATTACK HER WITH RANGE OR MAGIC
4 once minthara is unconscious, loot the spider lyre
5 turn off non-lethal and proceed to kill the other 2 leaders
6 proceed to act 2 and head to moonrise towers, minthara should be there
7 go to the prison (she is in a separate room with 2 goblins) and recruit minthara

I can confirm this is all it takes...

[Mike Garrison]

Автор сообщения: shadow's embrace

Автор сообщения: Mike Garrison

8) You can loot anything you want, including her lyre if you want to use it in Act 2.

Step 8 is a joke considering you need the spider lyre to summon the dryder in act 2.

So? I never bother with that.

If you go to Last Light and join the Harper Ambush, the Drider and his group will come to you. You don't need the lyre. It's completely optional.