Who Should I Give the Noblestalk to?

[Exoarchaeolo]

I'm planning on doing my first ever Dark Urge playthrough, and on all my previous runs I have always made sure to give the noblestalk mushroom to Shadowheart. As a Durge, is it more important for me to take it, or should I give it to Shadowheart like I normally do?

[Skaraok]

Might as well take it yourself, since you're playing Durge and you can only get that option by playing Durge again.

If you give the Noblestalk to Derryth, you can buy more from her in Act 3. They're very useful for healing.

[Exoarchaeolo]

If I give it to Derryth so I can buy more in Act 3, can I buy one for myself and one for Shadowheart to take then? Or am I only able to use the one you get from the Underdark?

[Skaraok]

Originally posted by Driving:

If I give it to Derryth so I can buy more in Act 3, can I buy one for myself and one for Shadowheart to take then? Or am I only able to use the one you get from the Underdark?

The Noblestalk acquired in Act 3 will only heal you to full HP. No restored memories.

Little bit contrived, but they're considered a different item by the game. I suppose the RP reason for that is by the time you arrive in the Lower City, Durge and Shadowheart have already "reacquired" their most important memories.

There's a way to give the Act 1 Noblestalk to two people, but it requires an exploit:
Talk to Shadowheart and ask her to eat the Noblestalk until you reach the [Persuade] screen. Switch characters and send the Noblestalk to camp. Eat the (fake) Noblestalk and get Shadowheart's memory. Go back to camp and retrieve the Noblestalk from chest.

[♠.brT]

Originally posted by Skaraok:

Originally posted by Driving:

If I give it to Derryth so I can buy more in Act 3, can I buy one for myself and one for Shadowheart to take then? Or am I only able to use the one you get from the Underdark?

The Noblestalk acquired in Act 3 will only heal you to full HP. No restored memories

You can actually recover one memory when consuming the noblestalk in act 3. At least i had it happen in my current durge run. I purchase the noblestalk from Derryth, consumed it, and got the memory of the Durge doing some unspeakable things to one of their victims while shouting insults, or killing their butler.

[Mike Garrison]

IMO, once have given it to Shadowheart once, you have seen the bonus content. I see no reason to do it over and over.

Typically I just give it to Derryth so that I can get more in Act 3 (and so her shop is more prosperous and a better merchant for me to use).

[Chaosolous]

I'd Durge it if you are the Durge.

I legit always forget to not blow that field up and have never once gotten noblestalk.

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by Chaosolous:

I'd Durge it if you are the Durge.

I legit always forget to not blow that field up and have never once gotten noblestalk.

Ice/water spell can help alongside with turn-based mode. You just need to put out the fire first.

[Dethlane]

Originally posted by Skaraok:

Talk to Shadowheart and ask her to eat the Noblestalk until you reach the [Persuade] screen. Switch characters and send the Noblestalk to camp. Eat the (fake) Noblestalk and get Shadowheart's memory. Go back to camp and retrieve the Noblestalk from chest.

No need to send it to camp, you can just drop it to the ground and pick it up later.