Does reading and complete Necromancy of Thay breaks any paladin oaths?

[TK]

Just want to make sure.

[lordmilier]

Not that I am aware of but I have never been Oath of Devotion so can not speak for that oath. In general different things break the oaths for different reasons.

[Woldy]

Originally posted by TK:

Just want to make sure.

i dont think so. but you only have to read it like... twice in a playthrough if you want its full effect. and by then breaking your oath shouldnt be a problem moneywise.

[kingonads]

Its pretty useless to most Paladins, just give it to Asterion or use Gale to read it.

[lordmilier]

Originally posted by kingonads:

Its pretty useless to most Paladins, just give it to Asterion or use Gale to read it.

This actually depends if you want to skip RNG with the Mirror of Loss you should give it to the character that will be your carry for the run.

[Dizzy Ladybug]

i don't think so, i did read and complete it with an Oath of Devotion Tav in Honour mode and it never did break my oath. the only time I broke my oath that run was accepting Bhaal.

[AokiYakumo]

Originally posted by TK:

Just want to make sure.

Did the research on the bg3wiki.

Apparently (unless the information is out-of-date, but I trust it over FExtralife), Necromancy of Thay will - in no way - break your Oath.

Which is wierd as f*ck.

Because I feel like Oath of the Ancients should ABSOLUTELY get an oathbreak from it, if they get an oathbreak from sparing Cazador's spawn.

[Jaeleth]

Originally posted by TK:

Just want to make sure.

I would bet all my GP's that there is NOTHING you can do that breaks the Paladin Oath. Remember you can respec your character as many times as you want so... What point would there be in saying you can be a Paladin no more when you can just pay 100gp to Withers and you'll design a brand new paladin with a different Oath in 5 minutes or so?

[Willow Rivers]

Originally posted by Jaeleth:

Originally posted by TK:

Just want to make sure.

I would bet all my gold GP's that there is NOTHING you can do that breaks the Paladin Oath. Remember you can respec your character as many times as you want so... What point would there be in saying you can be a Paladin no more when you can just pay 100gp to Withers and you'll design a brand new paladin with a different Oath in 5 minutes or so?

Won't work. If you break your oath then you cannot use withers to respec until you resolve your broken oath.

[Orion Invictus]

Originally posted by Jaeleth:

Originally posted by TK:

Just want to make sure.

I would bet all my gold GP's that there is NOTHING you can do that breaks the Paladin Oath. Remember you can respec your character as many times as you want so... What point would there be in saying you can be a Paladin no more when you can just pay 100gp to Withers and you'll design a brand new paladin with a different Oath in 5 minutes or so?

Oathbreaker is literally a type of Paladin in the game. People keep coming here to complain that they broke their Paladin Oath because they play it as a "kill everyone you don't like" class instead of the ACTUAL class it is.

[AokiYakumo]

Originally posted by Orion Invictus:

Originally posted by Jaeleth:

I would bet all my gold GP's that there is NOTHING you can do that breaks the Paladin Oath. Remember you can respec your character as many times as you want so... What point would there be in saying you can be a Paladin no more when you can just pay 100gp to Withers and you'll design a brand new paladin with a different Oath in 5 minutes or so?

Oathbreaker is literally a type of Paladin in the game. People keep coming here to complain that they broke their Paladin Oath because they play it as a "kill everyone you don't like" class instead of the ACTUAL class it is.

Yeah, honestly the whole "Powderkeg of Justice" stereotype kinda mars the PLD as a whole, unjustifiably so since PoJ is a PoS that would break your oath in tabletop anyways unless you're a Conquest or Vengeance PLD - and even then that is a 50 Shades of Gray Area right there.