Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3

檢視統計資料:
此主題已被鎖定
The KittyMac. 2024 年 2 月 24 日 上午 6:29
Should i get BG3 or Cyberpunk2077?
Should i get BG3 or Cyberpunk2077? I like both so actually idk what to select... i need only one.
Edited : if i could i will take both but rn i can take only one
Final 2: Cuz i dont know what to pick ill just pick cyberpunk 2077 first and after week ill try bg3. From now im unsub from here. Thanks everyone for help!
最後修改者:The KittyMac.; 2024 年 3 月 2 日 上午 9:14
引用自 Occasum_Solis:

引用自 kittymacbook
Should i get BG3 or Cyberpunk2077? I like both so actually idk what to select... i need only one.
Edited : if i could i will take both but rn i can take only one.

I was checking out your gaming library so my recommendation is based on that: I would recommend you CP2077 ... most of the games you have in your library are about the gameplay - gameplay is fine and you should have a fun time.

I think BG3 will be too slow for you, even tho BG3 excels in every other part compared to CP2077 - and BG3 is also not the pinnacle of writing as well but thats just my opinion.
< >
目前顯示第 46-57 則留言,共 57
Erylaria 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 12:13 
Cyberpunk is GTA with a Cyberpunk skin. It's not a true RPG, it's more of a "explore this city, drive cars, do crime, sometimes distribute skillpoints". If you're into that - fast paced, action focused, shooter mechanics, etc. then go for Cyberpunk.

BG3 is a classical CRPG with some quality of life upgrades, very pretty graphics, and a focus on slow, deliberate storytelling in a fantasy setting. If you're into slow-paced story heavy games without a lot of action, where it's more about strategy than about who can blow who's car up first, then pick BG3.
Awaken 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 2:59 
BG3 is the better game by a long shot and its not even close. This game is an anomaly as a lot of game developers stated. You just cant put it on the same shelf.
Pan Darius Cassandra 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 3:04 
Neither.
seeker1 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 3:10 
"Better game" is a hard call, because then it gets into issues of what kinds of games you like, or prefer, and of course I'm sure many people are enjoying it.

But ... yes, as stated above, BG3 is a true CRPG, and Cyberpunk isn't, and I would argue is just barely an ARPG. Yeah, you can distribute V's skill points into three skill trees of techie stuff, software hacking, and combat. There are cyber-ware enhancements you can purchase. You can have some "Deus Ex" level interactions with NPCs, but they don't seem very deep. Bearing in mind, I haven't played it, but this is what I saw from the gameplay trailer.
最後修改者:seeker1; 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 3:11
Vixziค็็็็็n 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 3:42 
引用自 seeker1
"Better game" is a hard call, because then it gets into issues of what kinds of games you like, or prefer, and of course I'm sure many people are enjoying it.

But ... yes, as stated above, BG3 is a true CRPG, and Cyberpunk isn't, and I would argue is just barely an ARPG. Yeah, you can distribute V's skill points into three skill trees of techie stuff, software hacking, and combat. There are cyber-ware enhancements you can purchase. You can have some "Deus Ex" level interactions with NPCs, but they don't seem very deep. Bearing in mind, I haven't played it, but this is what I saw from the gameplay trailer.

Was the OP arguing that Cyberpunk is an RPG? Their question is which is the better game.

My opinion as someone whose first love in games is ALWAYS RPGs... Cyberpunk is the better game. It just is. Now are they comparable? No. But as games if you were to break down the individual characteristics that make a good game in general yes Cyberpunk is the better game.

lol it's like the people who called Death Stranding a walking simulator. For those people I feel sorry for you but that's a "You" problem and I feel bad for you. That was one of the few games that actually moved me emotionally when I finished it (FFVI from back in the day is another that comes to mind).... and I am not an emotional person.
最後修改者:Vixziค็็็็็n; 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 3:52
seeker1 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 3:49 
OP was asking a question; the kind of question that really is best answered by the followup question; "so what kind of games do you like?"

And as we discussed earlier, once we get into the genre question of "what makes a good RPG" - bearing in mind for me this is my personal preference - "ARPGs" are the kind of RPG I like less. This is why I wasn't crazy about Mass Effect, or Witcher, or now CP2077. I don't hate action games, I will play them, and I find some ARPGs to my taste - only reason I haven't played Diablo 4 yet is ... "reasons" but I liked Diablo 3 ... just those didn't click for me.

In reality, I suspect I might like CP2077 once I stop trying to fit it into a genre I prefer, but again, I just haven't gotten it yet. I LOVE vehicles in games and I gotta tell you Unreal Tournament letting me fly around in spaceships or ride around in tanks strafing the enemy ... tasty. Another thing holding me back is people saying it wasn't "ready for prime time" until, well, now, due to bugs and other problems. I see people here saying still to avoid it UNLESS you get the Phantom Liberty DLC.

Sort of reminds me of folks who say ... "Play Solasta. But ONLY IF you get Palace of Ice DLC and Unfinished Business Mod."

On one last point, I think BG3 has a lot of emotional moments that hit me in the feels, and what I like about that "You're Not in This Alone"/"See" youtube video I posted from Lorphic Studios earlier, is that it captures a lot of those moments.
最後修改者:seeker1; 2024 年 2 月 24 日 下午 4:05
Belegar 2024 年 2 月 25 日 上午 12:35 
引用自 Awaken
BG3 is the better game by a long shot and its not even close. This game is an anomaly as a lot of game developers stated. You just cant put it on the same shelf.
Completely wrong and biased opinion. Both games are top tier and which one you like the most is all about preference.

Personally i really love the freedom and encouraged creativity in BG3's gameplay, but as an experience Cyberpunk is just something else and the world and it's characters are on a level that only The Witcher 3 and Red Dead Redemption 2 have managed to reach.
Wallenstein 2024 年 7 月 16 日 下午 11:22 
Cyberpunk base game(didn't buy DLC) is filled with half baked ideas. The combat is way to easy and repetitive imo. Use hacks on people, run and gun, heal at will. Story was ok in retrospect.

If you like turn based combat, real choice(both story and rpg leveling, equipment), and dialog get BG3. Its a much better game and delivers on what it said it would do.

Buy Cyberpunk if you want to use ray tracing and see pretty lights. Outside of that better stories and combat exist in other FPS games. I would highly recommend playing Prey over Cyberpunk.

Edit: Prey is 30$ right now but always goes on sale for less than 5$. Wishlist and pick up next sale.


Lmao friend, you know nothing about Cyberpunk 2077. The story is great, unlike in Baldurs Gate i genuinely shed a tear more than one time, the side characters are just amazing and the story is dramatic, also a bit more original than just saving the world. Baldurs Gate 3 has a good story, but i find some companions half-baked (Minthara for example) and its just not as emotional, Cyberpunk simply has a better one. People just diminish Cyberpunk because of bugs at the start.
hermit0wl 2024 年 7 月 16 日 下午 11:31 
引用自 Wallenstein
Cyberpunk base game(didn't buy DLC) is filled with half baked ideas. The combat is way to easy and repetitive imo. Use hacks on people, run and gun, heal at will. Story was ok in retrospect.

If you like turn based combat, real choice(both story and rpg leveling, equipment), and dialog get BG3. Its a much better game and delivers on what it said it would do.

Buy Cyberpunk if you want to use ray tracing and see pretty lights. Outside of that better stories and combat exist in other FPS games. I would highly recommend playing Prey over Cyberpunk.

Edit: Prey is 30$ right now but always goes on sale for less than 5$. Wishlist and pick up next sale.


Lmao friend, you know nothing about Cyberpunk 2077. The story is great, unlike in Baldurs Gate i genuinely shed a tear more than one time, the side characters are just amazing and the story is dramatic, also a bit more original than just saving the world. Baldurs Gate 3 has a good story, but i find some companions half-baked (Minthara for example) and its just not as emotional, Cyberpunk simply has a better one. People just diminish Cyberpunk because of bugs at the start.
Did you really necro a post from half a year ago because someone didn't like a game as much as you?
Яeplicant 2024 年 7 月 16 日 下午 11:38 
引用自 hermit0wl
引用自 Wallenstein


Lmao friend, you know nothing about Cyberpunk 2077. The story is great, unlike in Baldurs Gate i genuinely shed a tear more than one time, the side characters are just amazing and the story is dramatic, also a bit more original than just saving the world. Baldurs Gate 3 has a good story, but i find some companions half-baked (Minthara for example) and its just not as emotional, Cyberpunk simply has a better one. People just diminish Cyberpunk because of bugs at the start.
Did you really necro a post from half a year ago because someone didn't like a game as much as you?

I especially liked the part where he considers the story of 2077 "more than original". Perhaps I'm just old but thats one of those stories I've seen a couple of times in my lifetime.

Old man yelling at cloud moment.
Q 2024 年 7 月 17 日 上午 12:35 
Cyberpunk 2077 no doubt
Adam 2024 年 7 月 17 日 上午 1:24 
This thread was quite old before the recent post, so we're locking it to prevent confusion.
< >
目前顯示第 46-57 則留言,共 57
每頁顯示: 1530 50

張貼日期: 2024 年 2 月 24 日 上午 6:29
回覆: 57