i knocked out minthara

[TortafritaNinja]

Can i do a long rest? because i didn't talk to halsing yet and i need to go to the caves and and didn't killed the hag neither, but idk if i can make a long rest, cuz idk if she is going to wake up.

[Mad]

(As far as I understand) if she is knocked out she will remain that way unless you cause her model to spawn into the game again by going near her. So if you don't go back there it should be fine.

I remember the first time I knocked her out (dealt with her first before Ragzlin and Gut) I went and did a bunch of other stuff away from the camp, including a long rest, and when I came back she was standing back up with full health - but in her underwear, since I had taken everything off her lol. So we just knocked her out again. She still showed up later, in this case.

[TortafritaNinja]

Originally posted by Mad:

(As far as I understand) if she is knocked out she will remain that way unless you cause her model to spawn into the game again by going near her. So if you don't go back there it should be fine.

I remember the first time I knocked her out (dealt with her first before Ragzlin and Gut) I went and did a bunch of other stuff away from the camp, including a long rest, and when I came back she was standing back up with full health - but in her underwear, since I had taken everything off her lol. So we just knocked her out again. She still showed up later, in this case.

she disappeared for me, and she wasn't dead, so idk what will happen.

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by TortafritaNinja:

i knocked out minthara
Can i do a long rest? because i didn't talk to halsing yet and i need to go to the caves and and didn't killed the hag neither, but idk if i can make a long rest, cuz idk if she is going to wake up.

This has been thoroughly tested
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3110543554
check if you did it exactly as described

[Mad]

Well if she was definitely 'knocked out' and nothing happened like her getting knocked into a chasm, then I would guess the game probably considers her as still existing - but who knows. I hope they make her companion process a bit more streamlined in future.

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by Mad:

Well if she was definitely 'knocked out' and nothing happened like her getting knocked into a chasm, then I would guess the game probably considers her as still existing - but who knows. I hope they make her companion process a bit more streamlined in future.

It is streamlined.

[Mad]

Originally posted by アンジェル:

Originally posted by Mad:

Well if she was definitely 'knocked out' and nothing happened like her getting knocked into a chasm, then I would guess the game probably considers her as still existing - but who knows. I hope they make her companion process a bit more streamlined in future.

It is streamlined.

Doesn't she still share the same camp spot with Halsin?

I don't feel like manually knocking someone out (which is not explained or hinted at within the game itself) is streamlined. It feels like an after thought. The only way someone knows how to do this is because of the community, not because the game tells you it's an option.

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by Mad:

Originally posted by アンジェル:

It is streamlined.

Doesn't she still share the same camp spot with Halsin?

I don't feel like manually knocking someone out (which is not explained or hinted at within the game itself) is streamlined. It feels like an after thought. The only way someone knows how to do this is because of the community, not because the game tells you it's an option.

What you describe is not an option. It is a loophole. She is not meant to be recruited that way. The way she is meant to be recruited is without making use of a bug, and therefore streamlined/straightforward.

[Sonrangeri]

For me she appeared at Tower at "end" of chapter 2

[Beast of War]

If you knocked her out while being VERY sure she was temporarily hostile ( killing someone next to her while she was still friendly will make her temporarily hostile ) she will disappear and you won't see her returning there until Moonrise Towers.

But for example if you take her out after killing Razlin or a floating orb sounded the alarm and the whole Goblin camp is on alert and she will be permanently hostile.

Knocking her out while permanently hostile will remove her from the game.

[Amplifier]

Ever since the latest patch, it's very easy to get her. A lot of the Minthara guides are unfortunately outdated so the things they tell you to do will be restrictive.

You do NOT need to avoid long rests. You do NOT need her to be temp hostile (i didnt do this in my playthru but rmb reading it was patched).

She will disappear after you long rest but it will still be fine.

[Mike Garrison]

Originally posted by Mad:

Originally posted by アンジェル:

It is streamlined.

Doesn't she still share the same camp spot with Halsin?

No. As of recent patches, Halsin just kind of hangs out in the middle of camp.

Strangely enough, Thaniel still hangs out at Halsin's old tent, so he's now spending time with Minthara.

[Sleeper]

I so wanted Minthara after seeing portrait of her, then she opened her mouth sounding like 70+ old woman with way too many cigarettes. Reloaded an earlier save to killed her off and continue with my adventure.

[Amplifier]

Originally posted by Mike Garrison:

Originally posted by Mad:

Doesn't she still share the same camp spot with Halsin?

No. As of recent patches, Halsin just kind of hangs out in the middle of camp.

Strangely enough, Thaniel still hangs out at Halsin's old tent, so he's now spending time with Minthara.

It depends on location. Some camp locations still have Halsin at the same tent as Minthara

[Amplifier]

Originally posted by Sleeper:

I so wanted Minthara after seeing portrait of her, then she opened her mouth sounding like 70+ old woman with way too many cigarettes. Reloaded an earlier save to killed her off and continue with my adventure.

Yeah I didnt like the voice at first but overtime it grew on me.

I also modified her to look more her age with some facial wrinkles and it helped

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3198982741

[mike_hanna211]

Originally posted by Mad:

Originally posted by アンジェル:

It is streamlined.

Doesn't she still share the same camp spot with Halsin?

I don't feel like manually knocking someone out (which is not explained or hinted at within the game itself) is streamlined. It feels like an after thought. The only way someone knows how to do this is because of the community, not because the game tells you it's an option.

Knocking her out is done because players doing a "good" playthrough want her in the party, even though she's evil. If you do an "evil" playthrough, you can easily side with the goblin leaders for the raid, and she can join your party afterwards.

It's basically players meta-gaming and power-gaming a situation. In no real RP-sense would good players side with an evil Drow elf in the Forgotten Realms.