Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3

View Stats:
This topic has been locked
White Wyll being banned from Nexus is so stupid. People can still make him white.
I really don't get it. Did Nexus fold to non existent public pressure again?
< >
Showing 46-60 of 312 comments
yahboi1988 Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:36pm 
Originally posted by Metallicus:
Originally posted by Night Foxx:

Why are you opposed to free speech? They can't express their disapproval by not platforming vile messages? Why are you pro censorship?

Because I have money in the game and you don’t.

"It's always the terms and conditions that get you"- Mizora
seeker1 Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:36pm 
He has a right to cancel his subscription. Nexus has the right not to host any mod they want to. Both are correct. Neither are censorship.

The 1st amendment only deals with government. If government told Nexus not to host mod X or Y, THAT would be censorship. Nexus making its decisions what content they will host is up to them, as is the decision of any paying subscriber to subscribe or not.

It was their call on White Wyll. For sure, I happen to think they most definitely did the right thing in taking down Ghetto Wyll. THAT was obvious racism on its face.
Last edited by seeker1; Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:37pm
The Yeen Queen Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:38pm 
Originally posted by seeker1:
He has a right to cancel his subscription. Nexus has the right not to host any mod they want to. Both are correct. Neither are censorship.

I am aware of all of that. Just turning his own logic back on him.
Metallicus Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:39pm 
Originally posted by seeker1:
He has a right to cancel his subscription. Nexus has the right not to host any mod they want to. Both are correct. Neither are censorship.

The 1st amendment only deals with government. If government told Nexus not to host mod X or Y, THAT would be censorship. Nexus making its decisions what content they will host is up to them, as is the decision of any paying subscriber to subscribe or not.

It was their call on White Wyll. For sure, I happen to think they most definitely did the right thing in taking down Ghetto Wyll.

I don’t care about ‘white Wyll’ one way or the other. I wouldn’t personally use the mod as it doesn’t add any value to my game, however, I do take issue with their position on banning mods that ‘white wash’ and not mods that replace white or hetero characters. Consistently matters. Ban all the mods or none at all.
DoubleBaconator Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:41pm 
ngl race swapping is weird no matter who does it
seeker1 Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:42pm 
Originally posted by Metallicus:
I don’t care about ‘white Wyll’ one way or the other. I wouldn’t personally use the mod as it doesn’t add any value to my game, however, I do take issue with their position on banning mods that ‘white wash’ and not mods that replace white or hetero characters. Consistently matters. Ban all the mods or none at all.

I'm curious. I DO know of a lot of gender-swap mods. Can you name mods that change white-skinned characters to Black? I ask because I'm actually not aware of many.
yahboi1988 Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:42pm 
Originally posted by Metallicus:
Originally posted by seeker1:
He has a right to cancel his subscription. Nexus has the right not to host any mod they want to. Both are correct. Neither are censorship.

The 1st amendment only deals with government. If government told Nexus not to host mod X or Y, THAT would be censorship. Nexus making its decisions what content they will host is up to them, as is the decision of any paying subscriber to subscribe or not.

It was their call on White Wyll. For sure, I happen to think they most definitely did the right thing in taking down Ghetto Wyll.

I don’t care about ‘white Wyll’ one way or the other. I wouldn’t personally use the mod as it doesn’t add any value to my game, however, I do take issue with their position on banning mods that ‘white wash’ and not mods that replace white or hetero characters. Consistently matters. Ban all the mods or none at all.
Except they don't have to because "Freedom." Are you pro-nationalizing businesses? Because that's the only way to get what you want.
Altimely Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:44pm 
Thread doesn't have anything to do with BG3. Take it to the nexus forums. Larian and Valve can't do anything about it.

These kinds of threads should result in a week ban from these forums. They're so tired and every take that's been said, has been said.

"But muh freeze peach!" "But hypocrisy!"

Yawn. You're boring.
Pyromaiden Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:45pm 
Originally posted by JoshSquatch:
ngl race swapping is weird no matter who does it
obviously, and i sincerely doubt that anyone disagrees

but when it's a minority race being swapped out for a majority race the implications alone make it far worse than the inverse

the only race swap mod i've ever used was one that turns Daniel from the New Vegas DLC Honest Hearts Asian - and that's only because the devs admitted that he was made white by accident and they explicitly intended for him to be Asian so as to not perpetrate the "White Savior" trope

in that specific context it's not only fine but, in my opinion, far more tasteful and in keeping with an intentional design
Last edited by Pyromaiden; Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:46pm
Kamuizin Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:47pm 
Originally posted by Metallicus:
Originally posted by seeker1:
He has a right to cancel his subscription. Nexus has the right not to host any mod they want to. Both are correct. Neither are censorship.

The 1st amendment only deals with government. If government told Nexus not to host mod X or Y, THAT would be censorship. Nexus making its decisions what content they will host is up to them, as is the decision of any paying subscriber to subscribe or not.

It was their call on White Wyll. For sure, I happen to think they most definitely did the right thing in taking down Ghetto Wyll.

I don’t care about ‘white Wyll’ one way or the other. I wouldn’t personally use the mod as it doesn’t add any value to my game, however, I do take issue with their position on banning mods that ‘white wash’ and not mods that replace white or hetero characters. Consistently matters. Ban all the mods or none at all.

The audacity!!!

They... a private group... taking private decisions!!! Who would imagine that? No one is stopping a racist mod to be made, just not giving it shelter in their own site.

The author(s) of the mod is free to anounce in the diverse forums of BG3 any site which domain he/she/they purchase from their own pocket, where they uploaded it.

If anyone will risk installment from a non certified mod by Nexus (that make a trial search on the files for harmful content), that's everyone else risk and option.
His Divine Shadow Jan 28, 2024 @ 3:50pm 
Originally posted by Pyromania™:
Originally posted by yahboi1988:

You can't say mean words to these people or they get triggered and report you. That's why they do this nonsense. The mods on here do not care about context at all. Only about who reported first and who said something "disrespectful."
that's how mods work everywhere

at least the ones here actually respond to ♥♥♥♥ and don't play favorites
Hahahahahahahahah
Stechhelm Jan 28, 2024 @ 4:00pm 
Originally posted by Kamuizin:
If you can, please, give me a proper and logical reason to make Wyll white, i'm all ears. If you can't, explain to me how that's not racism.

I can give you one. He is obviosly a white faced "black guy". the opposite of a zwarte Piet.
Kamuizin Jan 28, 2024 @ 4:03pm 
Originally posted by Mako Kilo:
Originally posted by Kamuizin:
If you can, please, give me a proper and logical reason to make Wyll white, i'm all ears. If you can't, explain to me how that's not racism.

I can give you one. He is obviosly a white faced "black guy". the opposite of a zwarte Piet.

Based on what?
Stechhelm Jan 28, 2024 @ 4:05pm 
Originally posted by Kamuizin:
Originally posted by Mako Kilo:

I can give you one. He is obviosly a white faced "black guy". the opposite of a zwarte Piet.

Based on what?

He is exactly that out of place like this paladin in the D&D movie.
The_Dipl0mat Jan 28, 2024 @ 4:08pm 
Originally posted by Mako Kilo:
Originally posted by Kamuizin:

Based on what?

He is exactly that out of place like this paladin in the D&D movie.

And how is he, out of place?
< >
Showing 46-60 of 312 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jan 28, 2024 @ 2:49pm
Posts: 312