Minthara Missing (Moonrise Towers)

[Aer3]

I aided her with the druid grove and when I reached the shadow cursed lands, I freed the nightsong for Shadowheart's quest and I destroyed last light inn and killed Isobel before she was carried away. I had to fight my way through Thorm's guards at the entrance, but no sign of Minthara anywhere, even after beating phase 1 of Thorm in the throne room. Where is she?

[Gunburned]

I did some testing a few days ago to see what is causing this issue.
I did some trial an error , saving before the Minthara fight and runing to moonrise towers afterwards.

This is what I discovered.

- You MUST knock Minthara out in the Goblin Fortress
- You CANNOT knock her out after temporary hostile flag is gone.
- The Goblins CANNOT hit the war drums to sound the alarm, both before and or after she is knocked out. I believe this causes the temporary hostile flag to be removed.
- You will know this is done correctly if you long rest and Minthara Respawns.

I really hope this is an oversight in the fix and this process is made clearer/better.
Please fix this LARIAN we love you!
:HEART

[Gunburned]

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3110543554
Also the comunity has made this realy good guide wish I saw this earlier

[Silverbuu]

I started a new game on honor mode just to see what her story was as I've never had her as a companion. I'm really not keen to restart my game just to get her in a non-borked state. So I'll just try again later.

[Crimsomrider]

If you freed Nightsong before ever going to Moonrise then Minthara is dead because Nightsong starts the final phase of ACT 2.

So Minthara has to be saved before getting to Nightsong. Though if she wasn't in Moonrise even before that then I have no idea why she wouldn't spawn after siding with her.

[Silverbuu]

Originally posted by Crimsomrider:

If you freed Nightsong before ever going to Moonrise then Minthara is dead because Nightsong starts the final phase of ACT 2.

So Minthara has to be saved before getting to Nightsong. Though if she wasn't in Moonrise even before that then I have no idea why she wouldn't spawn after siding with her.

I didn't even make it that far. I walked into the tower and just had the goblins who said take it up with Minthara. I assumed that meant she was around somewhere, so I took a look around the towers and didn't see her anywhere. I'm fairly positive the issue is the borked condition of her needing to be 'temporarily hostile' when you knock her out. Most people will end up making her permanently hostile by declining her demands, or getting into combat and one of the drums gets hit, making everyone hostile. This seems like a bug to me.

[Crimsomrider]

The OP is talking about siding with Minthara and attacking the Grove, so knocking out Minthara has nothing to do with OP's topic ^^