Minthara missing in Moonrise tower

[MBerg]

I knock out Minthara win non leathal attack in the Goblin camp.
When I came to Moonrise tower she was not there.
Anyone else having this problem?

[MBerg]

I also went back to the goblin camp and she was not there.

[ArriLady]

I heard that you need to knock her out while she is "temporarily hostile", and if you talk to her and then get into a fight and knock her out it won't work. Can't confirm myself.

[Tax evasion]

AFAIK, she only shows up if she's "temporarily hostile" when knocked out (i.e. no goblins sounded the war drums, no kids escaped from the Halsin room)

[Captain Jebus]

Also in same boat, took the goblin girl with me and during the dialog I attacked them which I'm guessing is the wrong way to do it.

Bit stupid it's temporary hostile

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by MBerg:

Minthara missing in Moonrise tower
I knock out Minthara win non leathal attack in the Goblin camp.
When I came to Moonrise tower she was not there.
Anyone else having this problem?

Originally posted by ArriLady:

I heard that you need to knock her out while she is "temporarily hostile", and if you talk to her and then get into a fight and knock her out it won't work. Can't confirm myself.

This should help to clarify it
https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3110543554

[Xan]

The temporary hostile bit is probably an unintentional limitation, they deliberately made the change to allow good-aligned characters the opportunity to recruit her, after all.

The perm hostile + knocked out = "considered dead by the game" bit is kind of a core game mechanic in bg3, and I suspect something they forgot about when they made the change.

[Sir Rozar 93]

Same problem i have today in my game, I stunned Minthar. No one raised the alarm at that moment. Then i go kills other leaders. After i arrived at the Moonrise Towers after a long journey, there Minthara dont be here.

[HrkSCL]

I have not killed her 2 times even talking with her, in the first She appeared (not talk) , in the second too (talk with her) . But the third one she did not, I think is bugged or an error. I like this play that I am, so meh, sorry Minthara. I was hoping to see her without all next to Ketheric in Moonrise just for fun ashh.

[seeker1]

I think this is being caused by mods. Unfortunately, while I found what may be the mods causing one problem (no epilogue) and a fix for it (at least on Windows) nobody yet seems to be sure what's the cause for this issue.