to kill nightsong or not

[heime2003]

should i let shadowheart to kill nightsong or keep her from killing nightsong and whats repercussion from either decisions. fyi i want shadowheart to become more bright happy person in the end

[Dizzy Ladybug]

killing Nightsong is the evil choice ; sparing her is morally good

there is also little new content for killing her. so letting her live is probably the better choice for you.

[JamesF0790]

If you want to help Shadowheart become brighter then Nightsong needs to survive.

[Crimsomrider]

If you want Shadowheart to be a positive and decent person, then sparing Nightsong should be the obvious choice here.

Otherwise you will fulfill her indoctrination as a Dark Justiciar, at which point she will be the exact opposite of what a decent person is.

[heime2003]

Originally posted by JamesF0790:

If you want to help Shadowheart become brighter then Nightsong needs to survive.

if i dont let her to kill Nightsong, she will get pissed at me? and relationship will deteriorate?

[sethmage]

Originally posted by heime2003:

Originally posted by JamesF0790:

If you want to help Shadowheart become brighter then Nightsong needs to survive.

if i dont let her to kill Nightsong, she will get pissed at me? and relationship will deteriorate?

if you kill her there won't be any relationship to speak of

[heime2003]

Originally posted by sethmage:

Originally posted by heime2003:

if i dont let her to kill Nightsong, she will get pissed at me? and relationship will deteriorate?

if you kill her there won't be any relationship to speak of

? i want to romance her and dont want her to leave my party

[Dizzy Ladybug]

Originally posted by heime2003:

Originally posted by JamesF0790:

If you want to help Shadowheart become brighter then Nightsong needs to survive.

if i dont let her to kill Nightsong, she will get pissed at me? and relationship will deteriorate?

she won't be upset, it's a different path in her story. she won't leave you either and the romance is a little different than if you let her kill nightsong

[heime2003]

Originally posted by dizzy ladybug:

Originally posted by heime2003:

if i dont let her to kill Nightsong, she will get pissed at me? and relationship will deteriorate?

she won't be upset, it's a different path in her story. she won't leave you either and the romance is a little different than if you let her kill nightsong

kk thanks

[Dragonirian]

Originally posted by heime2003:

should i let shadowheart to kill nightsong or keep her from killing nightsong and whats repercussion from either decisions. fyi i want shadowheart to become more bright happy person in the end

Kill her if you don't want to sit trough her rambling about how turbolesbian she is

[SarkMan]

Originally posted by Dragonirian:

Originally posted by heime2003:

should i let shadowheart to kill nightsong or keep her from killing nightsong and whats repercussion from either decisions. fyi i want shadowheart to become more bright happy person in the end

Kill her if you don't want to sit trough her rambling about how turbolesbian she is

You got this all wrong you see. You have to save her, that way you go swim with Shadowheart. Then you just turn over to Lorrorakan and watch Isobel get murderballed for wearing that hideous eye shadow. Now you never have to listen to Dame A-Hole revel in the idolatry of herself at camp, and you still get Shadowheart. Big win, much happy.

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by heime2003:

to kill nightsong or not
should i let shadowheart to kill nightsong or keep her from killing nightsong and whats repercussion from either decisions. fyi i want shadowheart to become more bright happy person in the end

Both works. Killing the nightsong gives her some awesome gear, turning her into a badass War cleric/Paladin.

[Stiven]

Originally posted by heime2003:

should i let shadowheart to kill nightsong or keep her from killing nightsong and whats repercussion from either decisions. fyi i want shadowheart to become more bright happy person in the end

Killing the Nightsong is obviously a good choice, she is crazed zealot who suck on Selune Kool-Aid, hard. I made this mistake on first playtrought. The only suck part about it, is that this game is suck at branching narratives, it would be good if you could actually fight her in shadowfell instead of butchering her a pig she is, on orders from another soul parasite - Shar. But also, it really changes nothing. I killed her last time, and still lifted shadowcurse. She might help you in the last fight.

[Pan Darius Cassandra]

If she kills the Nightsong she gets to be Dark Justiciar and wield the Spear of Night. If she doesn't, then she gets a new haircut and some other kind of spear, which is basically the same, but has slightly different spell or something.

Also, romance ends if she becomes Dark Juicier.

[Juszyr]

Hi, so I let her kill Nightsong to become the Dark Juicer.

However, halfway through Act 3, I convinced her to spare her parents and abandon Shar.
I didn't have a "swimming scene" or any other scene of this type.

[Fourth2Infinity]

Originally posted by heime2003:

Originally posted by JamesF0790:

If you want to help Shadowheart become brighter then Nightsong needs to survive.

if i dont let her to kill Nightsong, she will get pissed at me? and relationship will deteriorate?

she doesnt want to kill her. simply "trust shadowheart" and once nightsong says "stuff" shell throw down the spear without the hit to approval. im so sorry if thats spoilery.