Killing Karlach for the robe and then resurrecting her no longer works

[Staryu]

SADGE, now I have to choose!

[Metallicus]

The robe is way better than Karlach anyway. She is cringe AF.

[jayman760]

In before the nerf!

[Etragorn]

Huh. I don't remember this being mentioned in the latest hotfix. Was this a stealth fix on Larian's part?

[DragonMaster]

NO it is not unless they fixed it in the latest patch because I've got both Wyll and Karlach in my party and wyll does NOT have horns. He even got the useless robe which i dumped in the travelers chest.

@Metallicus You can't be serious? Wyll had the robe on till the cut scene ended and then into the travelers chest it went. Karlach I'm enjoying her as a member of the party.

[PK_Thunder]

Fire shield at level 2 is 1000% worth killing her anyway.

[WildOrchid]

Originally posted by DragonMaster:

NO it is not unless they fixed it in the latest patch because I've got both Wyll and Karlach in my party and wyll does NOT have horns. He even got the useless robe which i dumped in the travelers chest.

@Metallicus You can't be serious? Wyll had the robe on till the cut scene ended and then into the travelers chest it went. Karlach I'm enjoying her as a member of the party.

They fixed it as it's not possible anymore if you start from scratch. From now on when you start, you will either have Wyll as devil or kill Karlach.

[Staryu]

Originally posted by DragonMaster:

NO it is not unless they fixed it in the latest patch because I've got both Wyll and Karlach in my party and wyll does NOT have horns.

I meant when starting a new playthrough, not for existing ones where this was already done.

[Staryu]

Originally posted by PK_Thunder:

Fire shield at level 2 is 1000% worth killing her anyway.

I am starting to think you are right, it's such an OP piece of equipment at a low level.

[Quacksalber]

Really? I did this two days ago. Is it after the patch?

[Quacksalber]

PS - I think it is sad if they removed this, as opposed to integrating it as a way the player can give a middle finger to Mizora. Oddly when I picked up Karlach afterwards I did not get the usual scene where she's on fire and she said something like "nice to see a friendly face, someone tried to off me before".

Why not roll with the crazy stuff the players come up with instead of always making it impossible?

[GloriousZote]

Originally posted by Staryu:

SADGE, now I have to choose!

Just kill Isobel come the end of act 2.

[PK_Thunder]

Originally posted by Staryu:

Originally posted by PK_Thunder:

Fire shield at level 2 is 1000% worth killing her anyway.

I am starting to think you are right, it's such an OP piece of equipment at a low level.

For real. Very little in Act 1 can handle Armor of Agathys plus Fire Shield. It can carry you to level 8 with relative ease. Only the crossbow spam Githyanki can really deal with it.

[Orion Invictus]

Originally posted by EH!:

PS - I think it is sad if they removed this, as opposed to integrating it as a way the player can give a middle finger to Mizora. Oddly when I picked up Karlach afterwards I did not get the usual scene where she's on fire and she said something like "nice to see a friendly face, someone tried to off me before".

Why not roll with the crazy stuff the players come up with instead of always making it impossible?

Bugs and glitches would be my guess. If the game is not programmed to take this "crazy stuff" into account, then the behavior is undetermined. It might be fine, or it might cause save data corruption or a progress block.

[Quacksalber]

Originally posted by Orion Invictus:

Originally posted by EH!:

PS - I think it is sad if they removed this, as opposed to integrating it as a way the player can give a middle finger to Mizora. Oddly when I picked up Karlach afterwards I did not get the usual scene where she's on fire and she said something like "nice to see a friendly face, someone tried to off me before".

Why not roll with the crazy stuff the players come up with instead of always making it impossible?

Bugs and glitches would be my guess. If the game is not programmed to take this "crazy stuff" into account, then the behavior is undetermined. It might be fine, or it might cause save data corruption or a progress block.

Doesn't the game just act like Wyll has horns if you do this and otherwise ignore it?

[Orion Invictus]

Originally posted by EH!:

Originally posted by Orion Invictus:

Bugs and glitches would be my guess. If the game is not programmed to take this "crazy stuff" into account, then the behavior is undetermined. It might be fine, or it might cause save data corruption or a progress block.

Doesn't the game just act like Wyll has horns if you do this and otherwise ignore it?

No idea, I've never attempted it.