Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3

View Stats:
victorvnv Sep 26, 2023 @ 2:24pm
2
2
3
Playing evil Dark Urge is homophobic by design.
And it’s great.

First you cut off gales hand thus removing his gay advances before they start

Then you side with Minthara , thus Halsin and his degenerate beastly sex advances dies with him before they start

By doing so Wyll who is also gay leaves so you never get to see him offer you “an intimate private dance”

Then in Underdark siding with Nere means you kill the gay gnome couple

Going further in Act 2 , going the evil path Shadowhearth kills Nightsong and with that everyone in last night inn dies including Isobel and Barcus who are also gay , with Isobel and Ailyn being the signature gay couple

And in act 3 by siding with Bhaal you end up murdering the emperor who is of course also gay on your way to world domination.

So besides Astarion who you could also betray on several occasions, going dark urge seems like you by default end up killing every gay character by default.

So all in all the moral of this story is being evil= being homophobic

Agree or disagree?
< >
Showing 16-30 of 57 comments
victorvnv Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:33pm 
Originally posted by Calculus:
I wouldn't call him homophobic based on who he kills because he kills basically anyone
Except his quest and special interactions specifically target gay / bi NPCs.

You get to cut Gales hand who is gay/ bi
You are forced to kill Alfira even if you don’t want to who is a lesbian
Your next quest is to target and kill Isobel who even the butler says that she’s done nothing to deserve it (except being a lesbian of course)

Then final act your father tasks you to dominate the brain which you do by slaughtering the emperor who is also gay

And while being evil you kill many NPCs but you literally end up killing every single gay npc in the game
AmesNFire Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:34pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Then final act your father tasks you to dominate the brain which you do by slaughtering the emperor who is also gay

Do ilithids even care about gender or sexualty?
id795078477 Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:36pm 
Originally posted by Don_Salvatore:
Originally posted by id795078477:

Because I want it to be an option. Don't push your opinion onto me. Don't push what you think is right onto me. I should have an option to choose how to play my game. Whatever choice I made will not affect your game in the slightest.

See - it only works one way when it comes to options. Those same people who demand options like attaching female genitals onto male bodies won't tolerate if someone asks for an option to have the MC orientation defined as what they don't agree with. Isn't it hilarious how the strictest censorship always comes from those who claim to be the most censored?

You do you. You prefer what you prefer. If it's fine by you - don't decide what's fine by me. I want to have that option. I don't ask and will never ask that everybody else if forced to play the game as I want to play it - something that you are doing here. You are not happy by yourself. It is not enough for you to be able to play the game the way you like. You also want everybody else to play it that way. That's the problem with modern political agendas in a nutshell.

I haven't said anything about what is right or wrong.
You have a choice. Don't pick the romance options.

Why do bigots think that developers need to cater to their sensibilities.
Don't play the game if it is so damaging to your sensibilities or self worth.

I do not have a choice. If I am unprepared - I will have to deal with advances of 100% of male companions. Multiple times. You are quick to call out on bigotry while exercising it yourself full throttle. You don't have a patience nor acceptance to someone else's opinion. You shame and name things you disagree with. Your messaging is done in a patronizing fashion that shows you thinking your opinion is right and that everything else is to be disregarded. Nothing new to see here - this is media today 24/7

And you still did not provide a valid reason as to why I should not have this option apart from "not catering to bigots" (a label attached by you since you disregard opinions misaligned with yours). You still didn't explain how me having this option makes your game worse. You still didn't explain why are you against this option and why are you entitled to police how I want to have it.
Last edited by id795078477; Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:40pm
JennyTheGhoul Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:36pm 
Originally posted by id795078477:
Originally posted by Don_Salvatore:


Why should orientation be an option? Because of your sensibilities? It's not like people walk around with their sexual orientation on their forehead.
I greatly prefer to have the choice to romance companions no matter what you choose as your starting gender or race. It's a game, not real life.

I do think you can argue for the opposite but it is a game. Judy could only be romanced by a female character in Cyberpunk, but I am sure that one of the most downloaded mods was to change that.

Because I want it to be an option. Don't push your opinion onto me. Don't push what you think is right onto me. I should have an option to choose how to play my game. Whatever choice I made will not affect your game in the slightest.

See - it only works one way when it comes to options. Those same people who demand options like attaching female genitals onto male bodies won't tolerate if someone asks for an option to have the MC orientation defined as what they don't agree with. Isn't it hilarious how the strictest censorship always comes from those who claim to be the most censored?

You do you. You prefer what you prefer. If it's fine by you - don't decide what's fine by me. I want to have that option. I don't ask and will never ask that everybody else is forced to play the game as I want to play it - something that you are doing here. You are not happy by yourself. It is not enough for you to be able to play the game the way you like. You also want everybody else to play it that way. That's the problem with modern political agendas in a nutshell.

You're perfectly okay with pushing YOUR opinion on others. It goes both ways.

When you guys talk about political agendas, that also goes both ways.
Grumpy Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:39pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Originally posted by Calculus:
I wouldn't call him homophobic based on who he kills because he kills basically anyone
Except his quest and special interactions specifically target gay / bi NPCs.

You get to cut Gales hand who is gay/ bi
You are forced to kill Alfira even if you don’t want to who is a lesbian
Your next quest is to target and kill Isobel who even the butler says that she’s done nothing to deserve it (except being a lesbian of course)

Then final act your father tasks you to dominate the brain which you do by slaughtering the emperor who is also gay

And while being evil you kill many NPCs but you literally end up killing every single gay npc in the game

I love your act, you're consistent with it. For me you're in the top 10 of the trolls around here, you never break character.

How's the wife? Is she enjoying your playthrough or she's doing a more reasonnable approach ?
AmesNFire Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:40pm 
Originally posted by Don_Salvatore:
Originally posted by id795078477:

Because I want it to be an option. Don't push your opinion onto me. Don't push what you think is right onto me. I should have an option to choose how to play my game. Whatever choice I made will not affect your game in the slightest.

See - it only works one way when it comes to options. Those same people who demand options like attaching female genitals onto male bodies won't tolerate if someone asks for an option to have the MC orientation defined as what they don't agree with. Isn't it hilarious how the strictest censorship always comes from those who claim to be the most censored?

You do you. You prefer what you prefer. If it's fine by you - don't decide what's fine by me. I want to have that option. I don't ask and will never ask that everybody else if forced to play the game as I want to play it - something that you are doing here. You are not happy by yourself. It is not enough for you to be able to play the game the way you like. You also want everybody else to play it that way. That's the problem with modern political agendas in a nutshell.

I haven't said anything about what is right or wrong.
You have a choice. Don't pick the romance options.

Why do bigots think that developers need to cater to their sensibilities.
Don't play the game if it is so damaging to your sensibilities or self worth.

There's something to be said about the devs making the companions MC-sexual rather than having actual preferences; but otherwise I agree they just shouldn't play the game (or ever interact with reality again) if gays existing bothers them so much.
Don_Salvatore Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:42pm 
Originally posted by id795078477:
I do not have a choice. If I am unprepared - I will have to deal with advances of 100% of male companions. Multiple times. You are quick to call out on bigotry while exercising it yourself full throttle. You don't have a patience nor acceptance to someone else's opinion. You shame and name things you disagree with. Your messaging is done in a patronizing fashion that shows you thinking your opinion is right and that everything else is to be disregarded. Nothing new to see here - this is media today 24/7

I haven't said anything that could be seen as bigoted.
What are you? 12? You're just trying to use the arguments I make against me without making the slightest sense.

I empathize with you. Hopefully you will grow out of it in time and with more exposure to the real world.
Grumpy Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:43pm 
Originally posted by AmesNFire:
Originally posted by Don_Salvatore:

I haven't said anything about what is right or wrong.
You have a choice. Don't pick the romance options.

Why do bigots think that developers need to cater to their sensibilities.
Don't play the game if it is so damaging to your sensibilities or self worth.

There's something to be said about the devs making the companions MC-sexual rather than having actual preferences; but otherwise I agree they just shouldn't play the game (or ever interact with reality again) if gays existing bothers them so much.

MY take is that it was just easier that way. You just concentrate your focus on the cinematics and the dialogue is basically the same for both genders. Done.
id795078477 Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:43pm 
Originally posted by JennyTheGhoul:
Originally posted by id795078477:

Because I want it to be an option. Don't push your opinion onto me. Don't push what you think is right onto me. I should have an option to choose how to play my game. Whatever choice I made will not affect your game in the slightest.

See - it only works one way when it comes to options. Those same people who demand options like attaching female genitals onto male bodies won't tolerate if someone asks for an option to have the MC orientation defined as what they don't agree with. Isn't it hilarious how the strictest censorship always comes from those who claim to be the most censored?

You do you. You prefer what you prefer. If it's fine by you - don't decide what's fine by me. I want to have that option. I don't ask and will never ask that everybody else is forced to play the game as I want to play it - something that you are doing here. You are not happy by yourself. It is not enough for you to be able to play the game the way you like. You also want everybody else to play it that way. That's the problem with modern political agendas in a nutshell.

You're perfectly okay with pushing YOUR opinion on others. It goes both ways.

When you guys talk about political agendas, that also goes both ways.

Yes. I asked for an option. I guess that's too threatening to those who are against it? Because of... what, exactly? Again, if someone in this thread explains to me:

-- How is me having this option makes their gaming experience worse
-- Or changes anything in their experience altogether
and yes, without gaslighting or "muh, gay people are this and that"

I will at least have something to think about and consider. All I see now is classic labeling, naming and shaming with no substance. Simply because I dare to speak an opinion that's not aligned with the narrative transmitted from all the media outlets these days. Why are you against me having that option? Why are you feeling entitled to deny me that option? Why do you want to police the way I play?

Originally posted by Don_Salvatore:
Originally posted by id795078477:
I do not have a choice. If I am unprepared - I will have to deal with advances of 100% of male companions. Multiple times. You are quick to call out on bigotry while exercising it yourself full throttle. You don't have a patience nor acceptance to someone else's opinion. You shame and name things you disagree with. Your messaging is done in a patronizing fashion that shows you thinking your opinion is right and that everything else is to be disregarded. Nothing new to see here - this is media today 24/7

I haven't said anything that could be seen as bigoted.
What are you? 12? You're just trying to use the arguments I make against me without making the slightest sense.

I empathize with you. Hopefully you will grow out of it in time and with more exposure to the real world.
You did. You just called out all people who want to have their MC as defined orientation bigots. Let's be honest - the majority of those people will be straight since they are not thrilled about 100% of male companions being gay. So you did what you tried to shame me for, exactly - attacking people who want to have this option. That's what I say is bigotry.

And yes - it's not only"my post" - it's a group of people since the threads about orientation options are appearing frequently and garner support. So you casually shamed a group of folks and now you tell me you didn't do it. Okay, fine - but that's even worse - you are so high up there on the horse of "correct political thinking" that you don't even notice when you do the very same thing you're so quick to accuse your opponents of doing.
Last edited by id795078477; Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:53pm
victorvnv Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:45pm 
Originally posted by AmesNFire:
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Then final act your father tasks you to dominate the brain which you do by slaughtering the emperor who is also gay

Do ilithids even care about gender or sexualty?
Yes apparently they do and The emperor have specified that in his life before he was a man. So him coming at you sexually def confirms he is gay
Don_Salvatore Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:46pm 
Originally posted by AmesNFire:

There's something to be said about the devs making the companions MC-sexual rather than having actual preferences; but otherwise I agree they just shouldn't play the game (or ever interact with reality again) if gays existing bothers them so much.

Indeed and I also did point out that it is a point you can argue. Should they have a fixed sexuality to make characters more fleshed out or realistic or make them whatever to facilitate the person playing.

I do think that BG3 could have gone the Cyberpunk route and made their sexuality fixed since the game has a lot of replayability, but I imagine a lot of people would hate that.
victorvnv Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:47pm 
Originally posted by Grumpy:
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Except his quest and special interactions specifically target gay / bi NPCs.

You get to cut Gales hand who is gay/ bi
You are forced to kill Alfira even if you don’t want to who is a lesbian
Your next quest is to target and kill Isobel who even the butler says that she’s done nothing to deserve it (except being a lesbian of course)

Then final act your father tasks you to dominate the brain which you do by slaughtering the emperor who is also gay

And while being evil you kill many NPCs but you literally end up killing every single gay npc in the game

I love your act, you're consistent with it. For me you're in the top 10 of the trolls around here, you never break character.

How's the wife? Is she enjoying your playthrough or she's doing a more reasonnable approach ?
Thanks ! You can succeed in anything in life as long as you are consistent.

And I don’t have a wife lol, marriage is for possessive people
AmesNFire Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:51pm 
Originally posted by id795078477:
Simply because I dare to speak an opinion that's not aligned with the narrative transmitted from all the media outlets these days. ?

You mean the "trans people don't exist!", "Lesbians are just confused!", and "The commies are turning our STRONG MASCULINE MEN gay!" narratives that are widespread right now?
Those particular narratives that you just so happen to be reinforcing with this 'whaaa look at me' attitude by acting as if you're a victim due to a single game's development's team decision to make the AI companions automatically attracted to the main character?

That narrative?

Originally posted by id795078477:

Wake up and boot up any of the recent Hollywood movies. Or any of them shows on netflix. Or for Christ's sake, watch any commercial. Like - you know, get up to speed, would you?

Case in point, ignoring current reality and claiming victimhood from actual victims.
Last edited by AmesNFire; Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:57pm
Psychopath Banana Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:54pm 
Originally posted by victorvnv:
Originally posted by Grumpy:

I love your act, you're consistent with it. For me you're in the top 10 of the trolls around here, you never break character.

How's the wife? Is she enjoying your playthrough or she's doing a more reasonnable approach ?
Thanks ! You can succeed in anything in life as long as you are consistent.

And I don’t have a wife lol, marriage is for possessive people

How your husband feel about that?
id795078477 Sep 26, 2023 @ 3:55pm 
Originally posted by AmesNFire:
Originally posted by id795078477:
Simply because I dare to speak an opinion that's not aligned with the narrative transmitted from all the media outlets these days. ?

You mean the "trans people don't exist!", "Lesbians are just confused!", and "The commies are turning our STRONG MASCULINE MEN gay!" narratives that are widespread right now?
Those particular narratives that you just so happen to be reinforcing with this 'whaaa look at me' attitude by acting as if you're a victim due to a single game's development's team decision to make the AI companions automatically attracted to the main character?

That narrative?

Wake up and boot up any of the recent Hollywood movies. Or any of them shows on netflix. Or for Christ's sake, watch any commercial. Like - you know, get up to speed, would you?
< >
Showing 16-30 of 57 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Sep 26, 2023 @ 2:24pm
Posts: 57