have you killed or left a party member and why?

[боби через мом]

my first run i am playing the hero type so i didnt want the head ace of Lae’zel crying over my choices. so when i heard her after the crash i walked the other way lol. also had to kill Astarion because he tried takeing something from me i knew he would want more or try to take it from another party member. i dont want to much drama in my team on my first run. i dont save scum my character has a time travel spell lol

[Ackranome]

The gith - she is annoying - stay in a cage.

I let Wyll kill Karlach.

Oh yeah Minth - didn't even know she was a character. LOL.

[101Asa]

I haven't killed anyone at all. No one's left. Though on my playthrough of Shadowheart, I did convince the tielfings to kill Lae'zel with me because in-character reasons.

[victorvnv]

4 play throughs and never killed or even though of killing a party member .

I get less content in quests, less options for diversity in team comps, while getting no benefits from not having them.

Even the ones that I dislike like Gale or Halsin I still keep in camp in limbo just so that my camp feels more alive

[Kamiyama]

Left Gale in the teleport stone
Told Wyll to go fly a kite
Killed Astarion. For some reason he didn't drop a brain worm.
Will kill Minthara when I see her.

All I need is Shadowheart, Lae'zel, and Karlach. Once I get Minsc he's going to replace one of them.

[Calculus]

I dont know... so far it doesn't seem like a hero, abandoning 1 companiond, killing the 2nd without giving them a chance for explanation...
Anti hero maybe... or hero wannabe

I left no one behind

[Orion Invictus]

Astarion tried to bite me while I slept. Shouldn't have done that to my Dark Urge character. It's the Urge's fault, not mine.

[боби через мом]

Originally posted by Calculus:

I dont know... so far it doesn't seem like a hero, abandoning 1 companiond, killing the 2nd without giving them a chance for explanation...
Anti hero maybe... or hero wannabe

I left no one behind

well has my cliric time travels if you dont kill him and make one of the choices you will wake up and find he had done something. so had to nip that in the bud. has for Lae'zel odds are she should have been put in prison years ago. i am just helping it along

[Coffee Addict]

on my normal run iam not BFFs with all my companions but i havent killed nor abandoned any of them yet either

when i do my dark urge playthrough none shall live except me and minthara

[Kamiyama]

Originally posted by Calculus:

I dont know... so far it doesn't seem like a hero, abandoning 1 companiond, killing the 2nd without giving them a chance for explanation...
Anti hero maybe... or hero wannabe

I left no one behind

You want to save a sexual harasser with his own nuclear bomb?

Or an outright murderer vampire?

Heroes kill the bad guys. My companions aren't perfect but they're not outright evil.

Except maybe Shadowheart. But I'm thinking she's more chaotic than evil. Her spiel about Shar worship suggets they target governments and authority figures, rather than prey on the common people.

[Calculus]

Originally posted by davidwhistler:

Originally posted by Calculus:

I dont know... so far it doesn't seem like a hero, abandoning 1 companiond, killing the 2nd without giving them a chance for explanation...
Anti hero maybe... or hero wannabe

I left no one behind

well has my cliric time travels if you dont kill him and make one of the choices you will wake up and find he had done something. so had to nip that in the bud. has for Lae'zel odds are she should have been put in prison years ago. i am just helping it along

So far astarion killed only animals at the point, after the events at the camp you can tell him what to do
Laezel is a githyanki, they put her in a cage only because of that...

You sound like a semi villain, semi anti hero... depends how the story goes.

[Calculus]

Originally posted by Kamiyama:

Originally posted by Calculus:

I dont know... so far it doesn't seem like a hero, abandoning 1 companiond, killing the 2nd without giving them a chance for explanation...
Anti hero maybe... or hero wannabe

I left no one behind

You want to save a sexual harasser with his own nuclear bomb?

Or an outright murderer vampire?

Heroes kill the bad guys. My companions aren't perfect but they're not outright evil.

Except maybe Shadowheart. But I'm thinking she's more chaotic than evil. Her spiel about Shar worship suggets they target governments and authority figures, rather than prey on the common people.

Sexual harasser? If you are an inept at interpersonal communication and suggest you are into him.

As above, at this point he didn't kill anyone for food and for the rest... well, there are worse companions.

Shadowheart... she is actyally the worst of the bunch... shar worshippers do prey on common people, they are in short a cult that wants a destruction of the world. She is neutral evil, close to true neutral at the start... you can turn her into neutral good.

[VladK02]

killing astarion is not reccomended from min-max perspective. His buffs are significant, esp. once he ascends. Nobody else has +1 to all, super bite heal, and 1-10 damage to attacks.

[Hex: Oni's Plaything]

I've only killed Shadowheart but that is because she attacked me after me doing what I normally do... try to help people rather than kill them...She had to be put down and honestly, I don't really care. I got myself a new cleric, a better one (life domain)

[боби через мом]

Originally posted by VladK02:

killing astarion is not reccomended from min-max perspective. His buffs are significant, esp. once he ascends. Nobody else has +1 to all, super bite heal, and 1-10 damage to attacks.

well while waiting on my ps5 early access i watched a bunch of videos in case i felt i needed to kill or leave a party member behind so i looked up builds and i am making a Tempest Cleric Build . so i can solo if need be

[Rex is back, baby!]

I killed karlach, for RP reasons but some meta reasons, as she was broken back then and prevented some shadowheart romancing to trigger.

But also i'm a paladin and couldn't trust a DEMON.