Volo eye surgery companion disapprovements

[Erke]

So Atarion is not my main character... But I chose him to speak with volo at the camp for the eye surgery....

Everyone disapproved the action that Astarion made... does the dissaprovement effect their affection towards me or Astarion?

Since I don't assume there are affection points between companions themselves, I assume those disapprovements were towards my main...

In that case, can somebody explain the logic of this?! Is this an overseen bug?
How would they keep me responsible for the actions that Astarion took?

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by Erke:

Volo eye surgery companion disapprovements
So Atarion is not my main character... But I chose him to speak with volo at the camp for the eye surgery....

Everyone disapproved the action that Astarion made... does the dissaprovement effect their affection towards me or Astarion?

Since I don't assume there are affection points between companions themselves, I assume those disapprovements were towards my main...

In that case, can somebody explain the logic of this?! Is this an overseen bug?
How would they keep me responsible for the actions that Astarion took?

Dissapprovement should be correctly towards Astarion. Even if he is an NPC he can be controlled like an origin character or any other companion character. You can easily check it by those who gave him disapproval - his avatar should be seen there in the approval bar.

[Xiwang]

Originally posted by Erke:

So Atarion is not my main character... But I chose him to speak with volo at the camp for the eye surgery....

Everyone disapproved the action that Astarion made... does the dissaprovement effect their affection towards me or Astarion?

Since I don't assume there are affection points between companions themselves, I assume those disapprovements were towards my main...

In that case, can somebody explain the logic of this?! Is this an overseen bug?
How would they keep me responsible for the actions that Astarion took?

the game take it like you forced astarion to lose his eye for you. for what i know karlach dissaproves it, you can solve this if you dont have everyone in the camp, by taking them all out of the camp and keeping astarion alone there, gale and wyll dont care about the eye. but karlach does, idk if another of them do, so take them out of the camp.

[hannibal_pjv]

You made him to do it…
:)
Not sure, but that is my ques

[Diomedes]

Originally posted by Erke:

So Atarion is not my main character... But I chose him to speak with volo at the camp for the eye surgery....

Everyone disapproved the action that Astarion made... does the dissaprovement effect their affection towards me or Astarion?

Since I don't assume there are affection points between companions themselves, I assume those disapprovements were towards my main...

In that case, can somebody explain the logic of this?! Is this an overseen bug?
How would they keep me responsible for the actions that Astarion took?

I wouldn't worry to much about it, you can easily max out your companions approval with the ones you group with.. Regardless of taking Volo's eye.

[Erke]

Originally posted by アンジェル:

Dissapprovement should be correctly towards Astarion. Even if he is an NPC he can be controlled like an origin character or any other companion character. You can easily check it by those who gave him disapproval - his avatar should be seen there in the approval bar.

I really hope that this is the case which makes total sense and quality in detail but I couldnt understand your suggestion on how to check it. Does the approval bars change accordingly depending on which char is selected? I never noticed that?

Originally posted by Xiwang:

the game take it like you forced astarion to lose his eye for you. for what i know karlach dissaproves it, you can solve this if you dont have everyone in the camp, by taking them all out of the camp and keeping astarion alone there, gale and wyll dont care about the eye. but karlach does, idk if another of them do, so take them out of the camp.

Yes I was planning to take Gale and Karlach out of the camp for this.
But the game really shouldnt take it as I forced it, it is Astarion who does it, its not like Im convincing him to go with the surgery.

Originally posted by hannibal_pjv:

You made him to do it…
:)
Not sure, but that is my ques

The dialogue options are not out of my mouth but Astarion's.
When it says "Clamp your fists and bare with the surgery" it's not my main but Astarion.
So as far as companions concerned it should be Astarion.