Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3

View Stats:
Forblaze Aug 24, 2023 @ 5:11pm
Society of Brilliance Act 3
What happens in Act 3 if you refuse to give Lady Esther the Gith'yanki egg in act 1? Is there a follow up or does just nothing happen?

Are there any vendors lost by giving the egg?
Last edited by Forblaze; Aug 24, 2023 @ 5:12pm
< >
Showing 1-9 of 9 comments
Jack the Roamer Aug 24, 2023 @ 5:14pm 
If yo ugive her owlbear egg or githyank egg... bad things happen yes.. very bad. BUT! you can give her the egg, and when she turns around, sneak, hold person, and knock her out. remove the egg (or just steal it if you can, but knocking her out is safer). leave, she'll wake up like nothing happened. Profit

If you refuse, she attacks you
Last edited by Jack the Roamer; Aug 24, 2023 @ 5:14pm
Forblaze Aug 24, 2023 @ 5:15pm 
Originally posted by Jack the Roamer:
If yo ugive her owlbear egg or githyank egg... bad things happen yes.. very bad. BUT! you can give her the egg, and when she turns around, sneak, hold person, and knock her out. remove the egg (or just steal it if you can, but knocking her out is safer). leave, she'll wake up like nothing happened. Profit

Yes, I know they're all murdered if you give them the egg. What I want to know is if anything is lost when those NPCs are killed.
Jack the Roamer Aug 24, 2023 @ 5:20pm 
Originally posted by Forblaze:
Originally posted by Jack the Roamer:
If yo ugive her owlbear egg or githyank egg... bad things happen yes.. very bad. BUT! you can give her the egg, and when she turns around, sneak, hold person, and knock her out. remove the egg (or just steal it if you can, but knocking her out is safer). leave, she'll wake up like nothing happened. Profit

Yes, I know they're all murdered if you give them the egg. What I want to know is if anything is lost when those NPCs are killed.

You lose out on a quest if all the lodge members die.
Drakmour Sep 6, 2023 @ 5:25pm 
So if I want to cooperate with the Society of Brilliance in Act 3 I should not give her any egg or steal the egg after completing the quest and the Society will live in Act 3? Is stealing the egg after the quest complition is considered that she has no egg? Or when I finish the quest by giving the egg it will trigger the outcome in Act 3 no matter if she has the egg or I still it?
Doomvora Sep 6, 2023 @ 5:31pm 
IIRC, the only major change if you don't give the eggs is omeluum is no longer in the iron throne and obviously the society is alive.
Last edited by Doomvora; Sep 6, 2023 @ 5:31pm
Drakmour Sep 6, 2023 @ 5:36pm 
Originally posted by Doomvora:
IIRC, the only major change if you don't give the eggs is omeluum is no longer in the iron throne and obviously the society is alive.
Ok. So several questions.
1) Omelluum in iron thing is in which act? Two towers in Act 2 or in Act 3?
2) Is his absence in iron thing is a good thing or I will loose a quest about retrieving him?
3) It happens if I don't give eggs or either if I steal an egg after giving it to Esther?
Comburo Sep 6, 2023 @ 5:39pm 
Originally posted by Doomvora:
IIRC, the only major change if you don't give the eggs is omeluum is no longer in the iron throne and obviously the society is alive.

I did not give the egg (I still have it), but Omeluum was still in the Iron Throne for me.
victorvnv Sep 6, 2023 @ 5:40pm 
It’s a minimum consequences .

The quest from the iron throne is just a side quest and doesn’t reap much rewards , the NPCs from the society that dies don’t have any special vendors with powerful items and that entire plot is a very small side quest so if you just give her the egg it’s ok.

You will end up meeting the now grown up gyth and talk to him. Just play your game the way you want . It’s not a major angle
Doomvora Sep 6, 2023 @ 5:43pm 
Originally posted by Comburo:

I did not give the egg (I still have it), but Omeluum was still in the Iron Throne for me.

Interesting, must've been a different trigger since he wasn't there in a few of my playthroughs, Blurg can't exactly give the quest if he's dead so I believed it was that which caused it.

Originally posted by Drakmour:
Ok. So several questions.
1) Omelluum in iron thing is in which act? Two towers in Act 2 or in Act 3?
2) Is his absence in iron thing is a good thing or I will loose a quest about retrieving him?
3) It happens if I don't give eggs or either if I steal an egg after giving it to Esther?

1. Act 3
2. You lose the quest regarding his retrieval, but if he's there then I guess you might still get it? I'm actually unsure.
3. If you give Esther the egg the society in act 3 is killed by the grown child
< >
Showing 1-9 of 9 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Aug 24, 2023 @ 5:11pm
Posts: 9