Wyll is good?

[Chaosolous]

I'm doing a good playthrough my first time and I need to replace Asterion, he's being obnoxious about my helpful decisions.

I have Karlach, who seems Chaotic Good, or Neutral.
Gale, who seems Lawful Good?
then Asterion who's obviously not jiving with my paragon of the meek thing I have going on.

Wyll can replace him and will be a "good" character, right?

[ChalkStorm]

Wyll is Lawful Good. Karlach is Chaotic Good. Gale is, generously, Neutral Good, but I would say that he's probably Neutral-something. He doesn't like pointlessly evil ♥♥♥♥, but he's pretty bad in other ways. Astarion is Chaotic Evil. Lae'zel is Lawful Evil. Shadowheart is Chaotic Good LARPing as Lawful Evil.

[Nadine]

My Wyll was always a very good boy, but I don't know if it is only because of my decisions.

[Metallicus]

Respec Wyll to a rogue or bard and kick Astarion to the curb.

[orthostatic]

Originally posted by Metallicus:

Respec Wyll to a rogue or bard and kick Astarion to the curb.

Yeah Wyll is a great sub for Astarion, but I try to separate that role from Wyll because Warlock's ability to generate force damage with free abilities is pretty unique, and there are some times that force damage is required above all others.

[cfehunter]

Spoliers
You can get pretty much every character to align with you if you talk with them enough and they end up liking you. Even Astarion isn't beyond saving.

[PocketYoda]

Originally posted by ChalkStorm:

Wyll is Lawful Good. Karlach is Chaotic Good. Gale is, generously, Neutral Good, but I would say that he's probably Neutral-something. He doesn't like pointlessly evil ♥♥♥♥, but he's pretty bad in other ways. Astarion is Chaotic Evil. Lae'zel is Lawful Evil. Shadowheart is Chaotic Good LARPing as Lawful Evil.

Gale might be Lawful Neutral.. He has bad traits as well.

[j725t]

Yeah Wyll likes selfless decisions shadowheart actually approves of most nice choices as well and she can pick locks without a class change (though I personally like changing her to war cleric so she can keep up better when out of spells)