Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3

查看统计:
Elrodeus 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 5:06
So what's *Your Take* on the game so far?
What's your mid-game review? Try to keep it short, sweet and to the point to the best of your ability. Try to discuss what's on offer rather than what could be. Hit me with it.

I'm only about 20 hours in but I play these games very slowly, so I'm probably not as far as other people that are 20 hours in.

The game is very immersive and so far it feels like every little choice I make is adding up to something. The environments make me want to explore every nook and area since I know there's a chance I can get a good perception check and find a chest buried in the ground, or a loose boulder revealing an item. The game really rewards you for exploration. The characters have been... interesting up to this point. I mean that in a good way. The combat literally feels like my 5E campaign that I'm playing with my friends on Sundays. I'm loving it honestly. A step above the more rushed experience of RPG's that have been coming out recently.

What's your take?
最后由 Elrodeus 编辑于; 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 5:24
< >
正在显示第 31 - 45 条,共 193 条留言
Pan Darius Cassandra 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:30 
99.9/100
Calan 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:33 
引用自 Elrodeus
引用自 Salazan
Been playing a friend's copy, love the gameplay, despise the borderlands humor and absolutely terrible companions. And I hate I cant make a fully custom party without a workaround

I've avoided leaving one for dead, but I just killed another tonight. I'm not going to say much about the companions yet because I think it's sometimes good to hate on characters. Like Joffrey from Game of Thrones. The character itself is characterized as a (debatably) bad character and I can hate on them for that and still enjoy the game because of it.

It adds to the story is what I mean.

when its one or two sure, 90% of them are awful though, and not in the so bad its good or loveable antihero sort of way
最后由 Calan 编辑于; 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:36
raubrey 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:33 
Having a 6/10 experience and haven't (and hope not to) run into the bad porn yet. The combat is lacklustre and the characters are boring. There is still plenty of time to change this around though. Lae'zel is growing on me and may be part of the saving grace in the game. The game is beautiful though, there is that.

This comes from someone with way too many hours loving their other games, as well as other crpgs. Pathfinder WoTR is FAR superior so far. So is SunHaven if it doesn't improve, soon.
最后由 raubrey 编辑于; 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:35
Space Dandy 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:35 
-I think the game would be MUCH better off not being constrained to the DnD ruleset. I don't understand why they felt they had to stick to this. It's a videogame. Make things play the best for the medium. DnD does not mesh as well in a digital format when there are better ways to resolve combat and dialogue.

-Characters flirt way too much. It's ridiculous.

The quality of the motion capture and the VA is very, very high though.
Still undecided if it's a great game. But it's definitely a good (albeit flawed) one so far.
G.I. Robot 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:41 
I want to use WASD
Baked Hotdog 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 8:46 
Multiplayer experience honestly killed my excitement for this game. Not being able to swap player characters out when you have other people that aren't in the campaign that want to play is game breaking imo. No one wants to completely start over on a fresh campaign and lose 8-10+ hours of progression just to be able to play with folks that aren't in the campaign. A simple solution to this would be to give a custom character dialogue to tell another to stay at the camp, and they 'leave' the party but remain within the campaign and story. That way you can easily swap who you're playing with without losing hours and hours of progression.

Character models are wonky and look like they're on the verge collapsing and having a stroke with how much they sway side to side. Combat is meh, but it's turn-based.
Menu wise, it's a carbon copy of Divinty 2. the main menu buttons are exactly the same. The map is exactly the same, the UI while having an extra row of action bars, is the same. The quest journal is also ripped right out of Divinty 2 from the lay out, to the text font they used. Combat animations are almost identical to DV2. The voice acting is a hit or a miss for some story characters.

I give a 6/10, but the multiplayer experience is really what ruins this game for me.
Elrodeus 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:25 
引用自 🍧
I want to use WASD

I mean, you can use WASD. WASD is what controls the camera though. CRPG's typically are point and click adventures. The clicking is what controls character movement. WASD controls your camera. This allows you to explore the map ahead of your character so you can better plan out strategies before and during battle.

WASD as character movement doesn't really fit the genre with the way camera exploration works in these games.
Ancient Toaster 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:29 
Story, characters, dialogue: Great
Exploration, quests, reactivity: Great
Combat: Overly difficult, frustrating and tiresome, just like DOS2. Fire/Acid all over the floor once again
Performance: Not very good.

This game needs some patches for performance but the game has DOS2 syndrome where every fight is a fight to the death. Even the most experienced DM running a game of 5E knows that nobody wants to sit at a table and play D&D where every single combat encounter is "Deadly" and requires the players to use every single spell slot and ability they have. Stringing together long rests is not a fun way to play.
heh 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:30 
I think they gave up on ever being able to release this game in a polished state and just shoved it out the door to get lots more people to buy it for the "release". So much of the content is EA-tier still, really ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ awkward "cinematics" (meeting the harper patrol after the underdark was a great one, if I didn't know what was SUPPOSED to be happening there's no way I'd be able to understand what was happening in the cinematic), and it's full of obtrusive bugs.
sonofthunder73 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:33 
It's pretty damn awesome. I'm working my way through the Shadow Cursed Lands now and I'm engrossed in the story. I played about 480 hours of early access and am 503 hours now into full release. Loving it!
sarang 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:35 
Best story driven RPG since The Witcher 3. Which is saying a lot tbh.

The choices, the different ways to tackle fights to even the games world from combat to story progression are ridiculously well done.

There are things I just don't know about yet in terms of what ramfications are for my choices.

Such as if we let the old hag steal our eye - what does she do with that later on? What if we let the old hag live? What happens to the couple once they reach baldurs gate? Stuff like that, there are so many possibilities etc.

After this encounter- I promised not to save scum because: I want my next playthrough to be a fresh experience of choices and decisions I had never seen before.

The characters having their own story - flaws, makes them feel like real people. They dive DEEP with their motivations and nuances. The Witcher 3, you hardly spent any time getting to know Yen or Triss or even Ciri, but here there are cutscenes upon cutscenes, upon dialogue choices, upon flavor text voice chat with other members....

Game of the year for me. Zelda, Diablo 4 are experiences we have seen before quite recently, but an RPG of this level hasn't been done since TW3. Does it surpass TW3? Hard to say for me at least since its been so long since my first playthrough. That being said, to even be compared to the greatness of that RPG tells me that BG3 is my game of the year, maybe even game of the past 5+ years.
最后由 sarang 编辑于; 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:39
Elrodeus 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:37 
引用自 AncientToaster

... Even the most experienced DM running a game of 5E knows that nobody wants to sit at a table and play D&D where every single combat encounter is "Deadly" and requires the players to use every single spell slot and ability they have. Stringing together long rests is not a fun way to play.

I think the team definitely bent some rules around stuff like that because of the aspect of video game play. The combat feels more dynamic the more abilities you can do per turn and the more skill checks you can pull off. In order to keep the combat feeling as fresh as possible they really push the fights to make you spend spells, which will lead to you needing a long rest.

I personally think it's a fair trade for them to set up the combat loop like that. I think it's the same reason they added in the Weapon Skills. It's just additional abilities you can pull off in combat to help combat flow.
Omnitek 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:37 
It's cool and great. Modern games are generally terrible so BG3 is very refreshing.
heh 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:38 
Best story driven RPG since The Witcher 3. Which is saying a lot tbh.
is it? there have been others?
TheShadowHatter 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 9:39 
Everything I wanted and then some, though I do wish they added official Steam Workshop support so people could create their own questlines and such. Definitely gonna check out Nexus mods after finishing a campaign or two to add even more replayability to the game
< >
正在显示第 31 - 45 条,共 193 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2023 年 8 月 5 日 下午 5:06
回复数: 193