Is SHADOWHEART evil?

[Drimon]

She is hot and i want to play a Evil motherfker so she could be my Waifu.
But i play only Female Chars... is she Evil and Gay?

Or is she crying if i just kill everyone that is Male or ugly?

[Ghiron]

She worships an evil deity, so at best she is neutral.

[Dionysos]

There is a rumor bout her ... that you will not like if it turns out true ...

she is a selunite (good hearted) cleric brainwashed by shar.
It seems to be very likely. Also she aproves more likely to good stuff at the end. Like saving the refugees. The other way around she drinks herself to coma ... because she obviously is not in a state of inner- peace after teaming up with the goblins.
So ... I wouldnt count on her.
Your Tav should date Minthara or Lae´zel for the better. Minthara is most evil companion you can get, so far we know today.

[Drimon]

Okey this is sad... lets hope i can put some Alien Worms into her Head so that she stay evil all the time.

Minthara or Laezel are not Hot enough to be real.
I hope i can also make a deal with the Devil and get a hot Succubus like Wyll have.
Or i hope i can just kill him and make a deal with her

[Yorumaru]

She is not evil, she is rather selfish. She doesn't really like getting into other people's problems, but she certainly doesn't enjoy hurting others or taking the violent route without a good reason, unlike Lae'zel.

[✙205🍉🐆→]

Neutral Evil

[AsianGirlLover]

The beautiful thing about BG3 is that you can nudge your companions in certain moral directions and change their perspectives entirely depending on how good of a friend you are to them, or how much of a silver tongue you have (being a manipulative ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥).

Gale can begrudgingly accept being evil, Lae’zel can begrudgingly accept being good - both of them do so in favor of putting the importance of the main quest over morality.

I have no doubt that you can mold Shadowheart into the evil waifu you want, but I don’t think she’ll be happy if you do so.

[Drimon]

Originally posted by AsianGirlLover:

The beautiful thing about BG3 is that you can nudge your companions in certain moral directions and change their perspectives entirely depending on how good of a friend you are to them, or how much of a silver tongue you have (being a manipulative ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥).

Gale can begrudgingly accept being evil, Lae’zel can begrudgingly accept being good - both of them do so in favor of putting the importance of the main quest over morality.

I have no doubt that you can mold Shadowheart into the evil waifu you want, but I don’t think she’ll be happy if you do so.

Yea no this will give me some sad Ending for her that i dont want.
I need her Happy even if i manipulate her into it.
Just cant handle any Bad Endings for my Evil Crew.

I will be Evil but i care about my Evil Friends.

[LinkToReality.ttv]

You can very likely turn most of the origin characters to whatever side you wanna play. Just coax them to commit vile acts until they start to enjoy it :D

[✙205🍉🐆→]

Originally posted by AsianGirlLover:

The beautiful thing about BG3 is that you can nudge your companions in certain moral directions and change their perspectives entirely depending on how good of a friend you are to them, or how much of a silver tongue you have (being a manipulative ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥).

Gale can begrudgingly accept being evil, Lae’zel can begrudgingly accept being good - both of them do so in favor of putting the importance of the main quest over morality.

I have no doubt that you can mold Shadowheart into the evil waifu you want, but I don’t think she’ll be happy if you do so.

then the deity will abandon them, I hope so

[FallenSnowie]

Choices are hard, but at the end of the day your going to have to press one of those dialogue options!

[AdahnGorion]

No she is not, most likely she is grey.
All things seems to point to her having her memory wiped and maybe be one of Selûne´s.. not Shar.. I reckon we can "decide" what she ends up

[FallenSnowie]

Think she also says something about Shadows not always being evil when your traveling with her.

[PrinceOfRohan]

Apparently it was very hard to get her to trust and like you originally, and it was only when EA realized this and was worried people wouldn't choose her as a companion that they allowed for good actions to find approval for her. Their motivation was that since she was the most fleshed out, they didnt want people to miss out on the content. That makes sence, as to why she is a worshiper of evil but approves of good things like diplomatic routes to solve problems.

Obviously though anyone who knows anything about Shar and her symbols would spot right away that Shadowheart is a follower of the darkness goddess. In that case no one "good" with any understanding would have saved her because Shar wants to end reality. So that would end her questline then and their, loosing out on great content. Also Shadowheart is rather closed and a little gaurded to say the least at first, and so this can put players off even if they did save her in ignorance or if their evil and want evil compaions.. Still regardless if she becomes good if i can persuade her or not laster on, allot of good characters would prob leave he to die if they understood who she worships. Or as like me, as soon as she is found out for worshiping Shar, i made her leave to the camps, and only just stopped myself from killing her on the spot.

So i think thats why her character is a little confusing, because she was changed in the process to be more accessible to people, though i find it jarring, maybe i could role play in another "good" campaign that my character is a little lacking in religion so doesnt know who Shar is, thus giving shadow heart more of a chance, but my life cleric absolutely wouldn't pair up with her, not a chance. I cant even dismiss her enjoyment of diplomacy as good, because it could just be a stratgeic way to reduce danger until she fullfil whatever evil her Godess wants. I cant trust the devil, and i wonmt trust a cleric of Shar.

[DrZann]

This necro is approved by the School of Necromantic Arts and Shadowheart's biggest fan. Carry on.

[Dank Sidious]

Evil is a point of view Drimon.