so i just killed a paladin of tyr cause a devil told me the paladins were evil

[peacesFGC twitch.tv]

was she telling the truth?

[Beartous]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von peacesFGC twitch.tv:

was she telling the truth?

Why would you ever believe a devil though? Glad it worked out. Currently loving the speak with the dead necklace from the crypt, and the zombie that brings the party back to life!

[DeathStroke]

i think the fact that he offers to give away his sword as reward ought to be enough of a red flag if you think about it. what kind of paladin would give away his blessed holy sword ?! i still killed her and took the reward anyway , im playing a wizard and am mostly just interested in looking after myself and gaining power .... so as long as he gave the reward he promised then it doesnt make any difference to me if he was telling the truth or not.

[Enigmatory]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von peacesFGC twitch.tv:

was she telling the truth?

They are former paladins of Tyr and nope they not evil. No right decision here. Only you can choose who will die.

[provokastoras]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von peacesFGC twitch.tv:

i didnt kill her because she may be an ally in baldur's gate city later on

Tsk tsk tsk and here i was thinking you did not kill her so you could bed her. Sorry, sincere apologies please forgive this prevert.

[Sujinova]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Infidel:

did you go back and talk to the tiefling again? that will answer your question

Yes of course. But I had another look on this matter. The quest doesn't finish properly. Every time I talk to Karlach (thats her name I think) it triggers the same conversation again and again. I could even turn against her though I already killed the fake paladins... This quest is indeed buggy.

[Longear]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Sujinova:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Infidel:

did you go back and talk to the tiefling again? that will answer your question

Yes of course. But I had another look on this matter. The quest doesn't finish properly. Every time I talk to Karlach (thats her name I think) it triggers the same conversation again and again. I could even turn against her though I already killed the fake paladins... This quest is indeed buggy.

Same thing if you kill her. You're supposed to bring back her head but i cant find anything on her corpse. So i just pickpocketed sword from pally and left without killing anyone.
p.s. Sell everything you dont need to mage trader girl before you murder them all. You can loot your staff from her corpse.

[peacesFGC twitch.tv]

not all tieflings are bad

[Martin]

Ursprünglich geschrieben von peacesFGC twitch.tv:

was she telling the truth?

That is actually an interesting question.. considering that in the basement of their hotel/shop there's a dead tax man.

[Edstyles]

I noticed she had some weird markings on her body. No reasonal human being does that. + She pretty much taunted me to attack her. So well , She got a bolt in the head :D

[Martin]

I killed her as well, for the paladins.. who then vanished after I stole everything from their vault.

[jffrspuk]

My god told me the Paladin was lying (currently playing as a Cleric of Tyr)

[teksuo]

they looked more like fake paladins than anything else.

in my book they are simple truants who high-jacked some paladin's gear and are playing the role now. (probably just to be able to loot/control the toll house.)

there was nothing paladin-y about those guys.

*or is that what i came up with to convince myself it was okay to kill them? /shrug*

[talemore]

5 edition Paladins can be whatever you want, evil, tyrants and heartless. As long they're lawful

[Boink]

The quest needs a fix: everyone refers to the NPC having a single horn, her head (when you cut it off) says it has a single horn, the NPC .... has two horns. Also, you can't use speak to dead on the toll keeper (dead body is by the ladder down) and there's multiple dead gnolls around giving weight to their story.

This lead me to kill her. But as intended, the Humans are the evil ones.

[ayrtep]

Yes, kill the Paladin or whatever he is.

Anders reeks of deception, while Karlach comes across of telling the truth.

It's actually a great quest.