MI AN OR ELSIE ?

[Saito Asuka]

im stress thinking of this XD. almost a week in real life i cant decide which is better to marry

[chrisbamb]

Check which gives you the better perks for your Character build.

[Saito Asuka]

i dont care with the perk. i just want to know from others people opinion which is better and why and maybe some answer can help me to decide to romance one of them

[Professor Hardknocks]

Elsie is not an option at the beginning of the game as she's a kid. Once she grows up a little with a few in-game events, she's very very good - except her crush on Logan. Mi-an has no dude she hot for other than you.

Also - use the mods on Nexus and you can marry all of them if you want.

[Archaick]

I'd probably go for Mi-an over Elsie...simply because as I played I came to think of her as like a little sister figure. Even after her glow up, that feeling didnt change.

[Professor Hardknocks]

Her glow-up fixes almost all of the issues for me - but I can't unsee her unhealthy crush toward Logan. Logan is what, 28? Even if she is 18, it's yucky to promote 18 and 28 year olds getting together or having romantic or flirty dialogues. I also dislike that even if you marry her, she spends the rest of the game fawning over Logan. If part of her growing up had her overcome this crush and see him as "just a friend" (and act like it), she would have one of the absolute best stories in the game.

[Saito Asuka]

Yea i got same issue with elsie and logan XD. even if i got married with elsie. I know its part of story but still make me little jealous. I have back up file for elsie in case i didnt happy when i marry mi an or didnt fill my expectation so i can load when i still married with elsie. I know there is mod but i didnt like using a mod for game like this. I want to feel the original of the game.

[uglyface2]

Mi-an has events tied to some paid DLC, if you're interested in that.

[February]

Originally posted by Professor Hardknocks:

Her glow-up fixes almost all of the issues for me - but I can't unsee her unhealthy crush toward Logan. Logan is what, 28? Even if she is 18, it's yucky to promote 18 and 28 year olds getting together or having romantic or flirty dialogues. I also dislike that even if you marry her, she spends the rest of the game fawning over Logan. If part of her growing up had her overcome this crush and see him as "just a friend" (and act like it), she would have one of the absolute best stories in the game.

Is it a given that she does have a crush on Logan? She gets mad if you ask her as much, says he's like her older brother. I perceived it as more of a sibling relationship, with a heap of hero worship on her end...but I guess even that much would be awkward if your builder is dating her since she's preoccupied with him for almost her entire storyline, and the fact is that they aren't actually siblings.

[404]

Originally posted by February:

Is it a given that she does have a crush on Logan?

No.

[Merlonlock2727]

Originally posted by Professor Hardknocks:

Elsie is not an option at the beginning of the game as she's a kid. Once she grows up a little with a few in-game events, she's very very good - except her crush on Logan. Mi-an has no dude she hot for other than you.

Also - use the mods on Nexus and you can marry all of them if you want.

She is an adult i thought tho?

[Professor Hardknocks]

She starts as a clearly under aged person then grows into adulthood. I think the way they did her storyline in that regard is really nice. She is doubted by everyone who treats her like a kid that just wants to pull pranks and do kid stuff (her words) and dresses like a kid and has a childish voice - then when she grows up her lines all seem an inch vocally deeper and some of her lines come off more naturally and mature.

Even if Pathea won't say she has a crush on Logan, it's impossible to complete the game without that conclusion unless you just skip all of her dialogues about him or when they're together - or if you're just committed to "she doesn't" and proof won't tell you otherwise.

I don't mind "child" her having this crush - but when she ages up if the player marries her, that her dialogue should be adjusted to reflect platonic feelings and statements without the vibe of having a crush. Something she grows out of, part of her maturing into adulthood.

[404]

Elsie's canon age is 18.

Go Out After Dark[mytimeatsandrock.fandom.com] event with Elsie
Builder option: You have a crush on him [Logan], don't you?
Elsie: What!? Ain't you listenin'! I'm sayin' he's like a big brother to me... Argh, you thought I was like, secretly in love with him or some junk? Aw dang, who do you think I am!?


The Outpost[mytimeatsandrock.fandom.com] mission with Logan
Logan: At least Else’s around to help. She’s really grown up, huh? Ain’t like the kid I used to know.
Builder option: She’s cute, she’s like your number one fan.
Logan: Haha, I know people think it, but it ain’t like that. We jus’ grew up together, that’s all.
Logan: Still, she really impressed me when we were clearin’ that tunnel. She seems real focused now, wasn’t like that before.

[Professor Hardknocks]

1. Of course she would say that - it's what someone with a crush who otherwise talks about that crush says in denial of the truth. This is half the romance plot.
2. Logan seems ethical enough, yet another point for Logan. Easily one of the best characters in the My Time history.

[404]

To my knowledge, those are the only times you can specifically ask them about each other. However, I am not familiar with Elsie's romance as it's never been required for tests I've participated in, which is the only reason I know anything about Mi-an's or Nia's. All 3 of them are too young to be of interest to me. Elsie in particular remains a child the entire game; dressing differently doesn't cut it. I really wish Grace or Heidi or Jane had been core bachelorettes and gotten more personal story content.

[chrisbamb]

Originally posted by Saito Asuka:

i dont care with the perk. i just want to know from others people opinion which is better and why and maybe some answer can help me to decide to romance one of them

Romance them both! Marry one, divorce then marry the other one. ;)