How to get married with Logan?

[DarkFox]

How to propose to Logan, when I want to make him an offer, he writes that your other half has other plans

[[OTG] Aelirenn]

You can marry Logan and have the ceremony. To start the ceremony, there is a book on Miguel's desk to click on. I suggested in another thread, and no idea if this will work or not, but try buying a branch from Arvio and going to everybody in town (except Logan) and seeing if you can gift it. It sounds to me like the game thinks you are already in a relationship and maybe you can gift that person the branch which will clear the way for Logan. If you aren't in a relationship with someone you won't be able to give them the branch.

[Acneman]

There's another player who reported a similar issue, it might be a bug or we may have made the requirements too challenging.

I would suggest to send over the save file along with detailed issue description to [e-mail] so we can double check on that.

File location: https://steamcommunity.com/app/1084600/discussions/1/3110268136050274059/

[syzara]

Is this figured out yet, why it won't work? As I am running into the same issue at Soulmate level. I wouldn't call this 'challenging' as much as it's a bug. I've done all his related quests, so I don't see what I could possibly be missing here.

I've a different save file where I wasn't friendship level enough to have him ask to date him, and gave him a Heart Knot at BFF level and then got married later.

I wonder if it's broken bc no Heart Knot used? The only other reason I can think of is that they are already at Soulmate level and that might be too late? Edit to add: nope, won't work on Lover level either. Then I have no clue and I'm very sad about it.

[Paula]

same error here... sad

[II Selphius II]

Originally posted by チビタン:

My proposal is just plain rejected. I got him on Soulmate, 5 star workshop, Level 8 Workshop area and when I propose he just says that he has to think about it. I tried multiple times, always the same. Either I'm extremely unlucky (which wouldn't be a surprise honestly) or he's bugged for me too...

I'm having the same exact issue - there's no reason why he should be rejecting me every day for two seasons and on each date, I've done EVERYTHING required for marriage.

[Endora]

Originally posted by II Selphius II:

Originally posted by チビタン:

My proposal is just plain rejected. I got him on Soulmate, 5 star workshop, Level 8 Workshop area and when I propose he just says that he has to think about it. I tried multiple times, always the same. Either I'm extremely unlucky (which wouldn't be a surprise honestly) or he's bugged for me too...

I'm having the same exact issue - there's no reason why he should be rejecting me every day for two seasons and on each date, I've done EVERYTHING required for marriage. :fomtsad:

Same to me, I'm proposing to him since HE confessed when I was treating his wounds. The history line is concluded now, so I'm not sure if I will tolerate him anymore.

[Frieren]

Originally posted by Endora:

Originally posted by II Selphius II:

I'm having the same exact issue - there's no reason why he should be rejecting me every day for two seasons and on each date, I've done EVERYTHING required for marriage. :fomtsad:

Same to me, I'm proposing to him since HE confessed when I was treating his wounds. The history line is concluded now, so I'm not sure if I will tolerate him anymore.

so if you can't marry him you will dump him? ...
wait until November release and see if that is still the case (that he keeps refusing), otherwise it may be a bug.

[Endora]

Nah, I was thinking on reload a very old save (I tryed to have one for each main point of the story) and try again, since some players managed to marry him, I assume it is a bug.

[CandyPeach]

yes, apparently it's a known bug that some players simply can't propose to Logan, even if they did everything required to do so, i think it is the whole save file that has that bug

[syzara]

Originally posted by CandyPeach:

yes, apparently it's a known bug that some players simply can't propose to Logan, even if they did everything required to do so, i think it is the whole save file that has that bug

I agree this is a dubious release like this, but also consider:

I think there are requirements that aren't met, when you pick this route, that simply aren't implemented yet, related to the kid. That would/should be fixed with release.

Let this save wait till release sounds like a good suggestion to me.

[Zeesha]

Originally posted by syzara:

Is this figured out yet, why it won't work? As I am running into the same issue at Soulmate level. I wouldn't call this 'challenging' as much as it's a bug. I've done all his related quests, so I don't see what I could possibly be missing here.

I've a different save file where I wasn't friendship level enough to have him ask to date him, and gave him a Heart Knot at BFF level and then got married later.

I wonder if it's broken bc no Heart Knot used? The only other reason I can think of is that they are already at Soulmate level and that might be too late? Edit to add: nope, won't work on Lover level either. Then I have no clue and I'm very sad about it.

I got interested on this so I ran the romance thing with Logan on my main. Couple of things.

Previously;
--Owen. I did all his heart replies (regarding his friend early on).
--Unsuur. I didn't do any heart replies with him.
--Arvio. I turned down Arvio when he did his big thing and was "just friends". So you have do 1 heart reply with him, I think, to get to the turn down friend bit.

--Haven't given anyone a heart knot. Didn't need to use the stick on anyone.

So that you guys know, Andy is BFF full max. Logan asked to be my boy friend, etc. so still no heart knot. I was part way through last heart and I took him to the wedding tent to propose. Bought the dress outfit the day before proposal.

We married the next day.

If giving people the stick isn't working I'm wondering if there's a relationship issue with Andy in that maybe your rep isn't high enough? Can't think of anything else to try to maybe help out :/

[Endora]

You maybe be onto something there, because although I never used the heart knot too, actually Andy is still my good friend. I'll try to lvl up to BFF and hope it works. Thanks.

[[OTG] Aelirenn]

Originally posted by Zeesha:

I got interested on this so I ran the romance thing with Logan on my main. Couple of things.

Previously;
--Owen. I did all his heart replies (regarding his friend early on).
--Unsuur. I didn't do any heart replies with him.
--Arvio. I turned down Arvio when he did his big thing and was "just friends". So you have do 1 heart reply with him, I think, to get to the turn down friend bit.

--Haven't given anyone a heart knot. Didn't need to use the stick on anyone.

So that you guys know, Andy is BFF full max. Logan asked to be my boy friend, etc. so still no heart knot. I was part way through last heart and I took him to the wedding tent to propose. Bought the dress outfit the day before proposal.

We married the next day.

If giving people the stick isn't working I'm wondering if there's a relationship issue with Andy in that maybe your rep isn't high enough? Can't think of anything else to try to maybe help out :/

You know that's an excellent point. I made it a point to talk to Andy and give him something every day to get the relationship up as soon as he joined the town. Even the first day immediately after I grabbed his wig and he was standing with Miguel and Trudy near the tracks. I started it because he's a cute kid and I was hoping the game would let me adopt him eventually. Plus I didn't like the way Miguel was talking to him. If the game had given me the option I'd have said, "He's living with me!" But since Logan and Andy are apparently going to be a package deal in November, as they should be, the lack of relationship with him may be affecting the relationship with Logan.

On a side note, hopefully, once we can move Andy in, we'll also be able to move Rambo into the stable and at least make friends with him.

[syzara]

Originally posted by Zeesha:

I got interested on this so I ran the romance thing with Logan on my main. Couple of things.

Previously;
--Owen. I did all his heart replies (regarding his friend early on).
--Unsuur. I didn't do any heart replies with him.
--Arvio. I turned down Arvio when he did his big thing and was "just friends". So you have do 1 heart reply with him, I think, to get to the turn down friend bit.

--Haven't given anyone a heart knot. Didn't need to use the stick on anyone.

So that you guys know, Andy is BFF full max. Logan asked to be my boy friend, etc. so still no heart knot. I was part way through last heart and I took him to the wedding tent to propose. Bought the dress outfit the day before proposal.

We married the next day.

If giving people the stick isn't working I'm wondering if there's a relationship issue with Andy in that maybe your rep isn't high enough? Can't think of anything else to try to maybe help out :/

Thank you so much for these data points! This makes me hopeful I can make it work! I was getting Andy's friendship up, but I'm definitely not BFF yet, so that's very good to know.

If this always works, it's not a bug after all either.

[Frieren]

Because Logan does all the work ... you can't give him a heart knot .. i know i've tried. I'm not even that great friends with Andy and my builder married him .. (many builders ago) ...