The Secret Liquid (spoiler)

[viirinsoftworks]

On Skelletraz, when you're put in The Hole, there's one tile that's 1/4 filled with a green liquid that causes 1 point of damage. Poison is purple.

I kept getting annoyed at the skeleton guards so I didn't mine through the island to get back to it- and I didn't remember what direction to go. After leaving via the sewer but while still on the island, I did some fishing- piranhas are found in the waterfall part of the muddy water while you're on the beach.

But what about that other liquid? I might start a new game just to get back there since you can't get back even with the Buggy Buggy after you beat the game.

[lilisaur]

I believe its the same liquid found at the Yellow Cay of the Bodkins at Furrowfield, which I've seen people call "Drowning Water". It looks like Muddy Water, can't be scooped up, and does damage to you.

Piranhas are found anywhere in Muddy Water, even islands where Muddy Water doesn't normally exist if you bring it yourself in the Bottomless Pot or pour out some Pure Water onto a type of Spoiled Soil. Skelkatraz has no fish that can't already have been found at the other islands. Furrowfield, Krhumbul-dun, Moonbrooke, and Gurgling Lagoon (maybe Angler's Isle, too) have some unique fish, but all the islands have a generic set supplied depending on the water type (and in the case of seawater, depth)

[viirinsoftworks]

When I was in Malroth's, my pot was full of poison so I couldn't try to fish. I wonder if anything was there.

Also thanks!

[lilisaur]

More than likely it has the generic set of whatever water type you brought. Plasma is the only natural occurring liquid there and you can't fish it (nor Poison, Lava, or the drowning water). Though I guess it would give another food choice for purists who don't want to eat tentacle vines and rotten meats.

In any case, it will almost certainly provide no fish you couldn't have already encountered elsewhere, as only the Nautilus is outstanding at this point and its known to only exist at Gurgling Lagoon. The other 39 can all be encountered before Malhalla.