[Spoilers] Final Ending

[JarHead]

Is Billy still alive? He didn't get dusted and was likely in the the basement when the lighting struck. What do you guys think?

[NecroMaster]

The secret endings definitely aren’t canon.

Though it seems the new kid and nugget are the only ones who remember all timelines based on the second games secret ending.

[DortSnort]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Wilson the Gentleman Scientist.:

The secret endings definitely aren’t canon.

Though it seems the new kid and nugget are the only ones who remember all timelines based on the second games secret ending.

that's not what heasked. He asked if billy is still alive in that ending

[DortSnort]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Aids艾滋病:

Is Billy still alive? He didn't get dusted and was likely in the the basement when the lighting struck. What do you guys think?

Billy is Nugget's first friend. Highly doubt he'd be killed as he didn't get killed in the first game either (well, nugget didn't even know where he is but that's the second part)

[Adipose379]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Niff:

Oprindeligt skrevet af Aids艾滋病:

Is Billy still alive? He didn't get dusted and was likely in the the basement when the lighting struck. What do you guys think?

Billy is Nugget's first friend. Highly doubt he'd be killed as he didn't get killed in the first game either (well, nugget didn't even know where he is but that's the second part)

Right. And Nugget definitely cared when he killed the Pretty Lily. It was everyone, Billy was just inside and as such not struck by lightning. I don't know why it excluded people in buildings (at least the lightning), but if the initial dusting didn't kill Billy, we would have seen lightning hit the school or something. Point is, Nugget wanted them all. Including Billy and the Pretty Lily. But Billy didn't seem to die.

[DortSnort]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Adipose379:

Oprindeligt skrevet af Niff:

Billy is Nugget's first friend. Highly doubt he'd be killed as he didn't get killed in the first game either (well, nugget didn't even know where he is but that's the second part)

Right. And Nugget definitely cared when he killed the Pretty Lily. It was everyone, Billy was just inside and as such not struck by lightning. I don't know why it excluded people in buildings (at least the lightning), but if the initial dusting didn't kill Billy, we would have seen lightning hit the school or something. Point is, Nugget wanted them all. Including Billy and the Pretty Lily. But Billy didn't seem to die.

The monstermon ending isn’t canon anyway. I mean, it’s only canon between each other but they’re like separated from the rest of the game

[Adipose379]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Niff:

Oprindeligt skrevet af Adipose379:

Right. And Nugget definitely cared when he killed the Pretty Lily. It was everyone, Billy was just inside and as such not struck by lightning. I don't know why it excluded people in buildings (at least the lightning), but if the initial dusting didn't kill Billy, we would have seen lightning hit the school or something. Point is, Nugget wanted them all. Including Billy and the Pretty Lily. But Billy didn't seem to die.

The monstermon ending isn’t canon anyway. I mean, it’s only canon between each other but they’re like separated from the rest of the game

This invalidates both of your earlier comments. Firstly, telling someone else that they answered the question badly with that answer (and then using it again), and secondly, Nugget can;t have chosen not to kill Billy because Billy was his friend if he let Lily die.