Idea for an NPC.

[Earth]

Someone who sells potions and ingidients. Things like bottles, herbs, fish, and potions themselves. But aside from bottles all the other items would rotate based on something like moonphase or time of day.

[Coleyohley!]

this already exists, even if it's not all the same NPC. The Druid from the Thorium mod sells Alchemy Plants, while the entire purpose of the Alchemist NPC mod is to, well, add an Alchemist NPC who does exactly what is requested above.

And yes, it's as overpowered as it sounds

[Earth]

引用自 Coleyohley：

this already exists, even if it's not all the same NPC. The Druid from the Thorium mod sells Alchemy Plants, while the entire purpose of the Alchemist NPC mod is to, well, add an Alchemist NPC who does exactly what is requested above.

And yes, it's as overpowered as it sounds

Again I am saying outside of mods.

[Coleyohley!]

引用自 Earth：

引用自 Coleyohley：

this already exists, even if it's not all the same NPC. The Druid from the Thorium mod sells Alchemy Plants, while the entire purpose of the Alchemist NPC mod is to, well, add an Alchemist NPC who does exactly what is requested above.

And yes, it's as overpowered as it sounds

Again I am saying outside of mods.

It doesn't need to be added though. Not only because it already exists, but because it would be incredibly overpowered.

[Earth]

引用自 Coleyohley：

引用自 Earth：

Again I am saying outside of mods.

It doesn't need to be added though. Not only because it already exists, but because it would be incredibly overpowered.

That's why I added the moonphase thing. Like this day he sells obsidian skin potions,
wrath potions, shiverthron, and fireblossom seeds. The next day it's ironskin, swiftness, daybloom, and waterleaf seeds.

[Coleyohley!]

引用自 Earth：

引用自 Coleyohley：

It doesn't need to be added though. Not only because it already exists, but because it would be incredibly overpowered.

That's why I added the moonphase thing. Like this day he sells obsidian skin potions,
wrath potions, shiverthron, and fireblossom seeds. The next day it's ironskin, swiftness, daybloom, and waterleaf seeds.

then one could simply wait a while to get these materials, and for the same amount of effort as getting them all at once. If you don't want to complete the actions necessary to obtain a certain potion, then in my view, you simply don't deserve said potion. An Alchemy plant farm isn't all that difficult to create, anyway.

[MonkeyButt]

引用自 Earth：

引用自 Coleyohley：

It doesn't need to be added though. Not only because it already exists, but because it would be incredibly overpowered.

That's why I added the moonphase thing. Like this day he sells obsidian skin potions,
wrath potions, shiverthron, and fireblossom seeds. The next day it's ironskin, swiftness, daybloom, and waterleaf seeds.

But still, that would take away from the whole farm materials so that you can craft potions process. It would basically eliminate that part of the game. To get the potions you want, all you would need to do would be to create a money farm, and buy the potions from this NPC.

[Coleyohley!]

引用自 MonkeyButt：

引用自 Earth：

That's why I added the moonphase thing. Like this day he sells obsidian skin potions,
wrath potions, shiverthron, and fireblossom seeds. The next day it's ironskin, swiftness, daybloom, and waterleaf seeds.

But still, that would take away from the whole farm materials so that you can craft potions process. It would basically eliminate that part of the game. To get the potions you want, all you would need to do would be to create a money farm, and buy the potions from this NPC.

But farming materials to craft potions is a major part of what makes potions such a powerful and worthwhile tool. This would be a slap in the face to every item and mechanic in the game that has anything relating to crafting potions.

Some things are logical as to the reason that you can buy them. Potions and their respective ingredients are not one of them.

[MonkeyButt]

引用自 Coleyohley：

引用自 MonkeyButt：

But still, that would take away from the whole farm materials so that you can craft potions process. It would basically eliminate that part of the game. To get the potions you want, all you would need to do would be to create a money farm, and buy the potions from this NPC.

But farming materials to craft potions is a major part of what makes potions such a powerful and worthwhile tool. This would be a slap in the face to every item and mechanic in the game that has anything relating to crafting potions.

Some things do not need to be bought. Potions and their respective ingredients are not one of them.

Yeah, I worded that poorly. I was trying to mount an argument against this NPC being added.

Farming and working for materials IS a big part of this game! And I want it to stay that way.

[Earth]

引用自 MonkeyButt：

引用自 Earth：

That's why I added the moonphase thing. Like this day he sells obsidian skin potions,
wrath potions, shiverthron, and fireblossom seeds. The next day it's ironskin, swiftness, daybloom, and waterleaf seeds.

But still, that would take away from the whole farm materials so that you can craft potions process. It would basically eliminate that part of the game. To get the potions you want, all you would need to do would be to create a money farm, and buy the potions from this NPC.

It would give people like me who aren't really into that aspect more fun because I could fight harder bosses without needing to farm for potions.

[Coleyohley!]

引用自 MonkeyButt：

引用自 Coleyohley：

But farming materials to craft potions is a major part of what makes potions such a powerful and worthwhile tool. This would be a slap in the face to every item and mechanic in the game that has anything relating to crafting potions.

Some things do not need to be bought. Potions and their respective ingredients are not one of them.

Yeah, I worded that poorly. I was trying to mount an argument against this NPC being added.

Farming and working for materials IS a big part of this game! And I want it to stay that way.

Oh! I should have seen that your profile picture and name is completely different from OP's. Somehow I thought you two were the same person and that I was only in a 2-person discussion.

[MonkeyButt]

引用自 Coleyohley：

引用自 MonkeyButt：

Yeah, I worded that poorly. I was trying to mount an argument against this NPC being added.

Farming and working for materials IS a big part of this game! And I want it to stay that way.

Oh! I should have seen that your profile picture and name is completely different from OP's. Somehow I thought you two were the same person and that I was only in a 2-person discussion.

Hah! No worries. It's a human mistake, we all make them.

[Pepperoni in Rest]

引用自 Earth：

Someone who sells potions and ingidients. Things like bottles, herbs, fish, and potions themselves. But aside from bottles all the other items would rotate based on something like moonphase or time of day.

there is a mod for it, but yeah making potions is so annoying

[MonkeyButt]

引用自 Pepperoni：

引用自 Earth：

Someone who sells potions and ingidients. Things like bottles, herbs, fish, and potions themselves. But aside from bottles all the other items would rotate based on something like moonphase or time of day.

there is a mod for it, but yeah making potions is so annoying

But it's still part of the game, is it not? A lot of us enjoy making farms to gather materials to make potions on our own. It's a part of the game that a lot of us enjoy.

It may be "annoying" for YOU to have to work for these potions.. but a lot of us enjoy the work. It's no fun when everything is given to us with little to no work being required.

[Pepperoni in Rest]

引用自 MonkeyButt：

引用自 Pepperoni：

there is a mod for it, but yeah making potions is so annoying

But it's still part of the game, is it not? A lot of us enjoy making farms to gather materials to make potions on our own. It's a part of the game that a lot of us enjoy.

It may be "annoying" for YOU to have to work for these potions.. but a lot of us enjoy the work. It's no fun when everything is given to us with little to no work being required.

yeah, it should keep being just a mod for that reason, people who dislikes it installs it, but you don't HAVE to use it

[Coleyohley!]

引用自 Pepperoni：

引用自 MonkeyButt：

But it's still part of the game, is it not? A lot of us enjoy making farms to gather materials to make potions on our own. It's a part of the game that a lot of us enjoy.

It may be "annoying" for YOU to have to work for these potions.. but a lot of us enjoy the work. It's no fun when everything is given to us with little to no work being required.

yeah, it should keep being just a mod for that reason, people who dislikes it installs it, but you don't HAVE to use it

And to use it, you'd have to download it in the first place. This prevents the slap in the face to everyone who has previously created and used these farms. They still have their relevance because they are the only way to reliably and easily obtain potions.