Unable to fish for Junk

[JoeBidenGaming]

I'm playing modded Terraria, and for some reason I am unable to obtain any junk items while fishing. An item i'm trying to create requires 5 Old Shoes and i can't get any. :(

[Saver Sigonith]

Which mods?
In vanilla, the best way to fish up junk is to fish in a tiny pond (75 tiles min) with crappy bait, the wooden fishing pole and no "bonus to fishing" items. So unless the mod changes anything, I guess I'd try that.

[JoeBidenGaming]

Originally posted by Saver Sigonith:

Which mods?
In vanilla, the best way to fish up junk is to fish in a tiny pond (75 tiles min) with crappy bait, the wooden fishing pole and no "bonus to fishing" items. So unless the mod changes anything, I guess I'd try that.

-Both Fargo Mods
-Thorium
-WeaponOut
-Calamity
-Calamity Addon
-Mod of Redemption
-AlchemistNPC
-Enigma
-Fishing2.0
-EvenMoreModifiers
-Accessories+
-Lootbags
-Luiafk
-Joostmod
-MaxStackPlus
-Crystilium
-Universe of Swords
-The Antiaris
-Elements Awoken
-Which mod is this from?
-VeinMiner
-Wings Slot

I've tried doing that also but to no avail

[TrashCataclysm]

You need exactly more than or equal to 75 tiles of water to fish anything, they must also have their surface exposed to count. Any water tiles that if you went upwards from them reached a solid block before surface level are not counted as suitable tiles.

If you haven't already try fishing in the ocean. It needs 1,000 tiles but there should be enough.

[JoeBidenGaming]

The strange thing is, whenever I fish in a tiny pond and/or with low fishing power, I end up getting obsidian for some reason.

[Saver Sigonith]

Oh. That sounds like one of your mods is messing up another mod's progression. I never play modded so I can't look at that list and tell you, but I'd try disabling them one at a time and figure out which.
In vanilla (and presumably that mod that needs 5 shoes) there's no way to get obsidian from fishing.

[oMaaath]

I unabled The Enigma Mod and i got the 5 old shoes for fargo's mod.