Abonneren om te downloaden
Swashplate Mk3

Ok well, I'm just trying to see where the forces and torques are located and how it combines in order to get an understanding on what's going on

Every effect is quite well documented on google & wiki, there is no need to be an expert imo!

I am by no means an expert in physics. I have worked a little in the past with physics software but even Besiege has more capabilities. I have noticed though that a balanced (as close as possible), four-prop machine will begin rotating while travelling upward. That included half of the motors rotating opposite the others.

I'm still sceptical about besiege's physics but I need to build experiments to show things. especially about the 3rd law of newton on inertial wheels and on spinning systems that actually are decelerating way too fast in my opinion.

And because of that I can't build a proper wirligig that is spinning long enough at a fast enough speed to show interesting results about gyroscopic precession in besiege. Systems with contrarotating parts are actually messing the results

Man, this clip is really cool, I didn't know that serie, thanks! About building it into a vehicle, my issue is the number of blocks (and my computer).

I feel really idiot because I try to address things one by one and we actually can't do that because thoses forces have too much interactions and we can't insulate them.

So if I understand well, if we think using angular momentum and mix everything in it, this should be like this :
-The vertical component is function to spinning speed and inertial momentum (which remains constant if we consider there is no drag angle)
-Any dissymmetry of lift force (arround the spinning axis) will induce 2 horizontal components : the 1st one is the one we actually apply, and the 2nd one is the gyroscopic precession effect, and is at a perfect 90° angle with the 1st one.

And the lift force is applied with phase lag from the input because of inertia and elasticity of parts & joints.

The beauty of building it into a vehicle is that the control stick can be arranged so that the steering is intuitive. ;) One of my favorite clips: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTjGTxSevHE
Keep up the good work.

My bad... Of course they have.
books.google.fr/books?id=Q27ho2szWCoC&pg=PA140&lpg=PA140&dq=phase+shift+swashplate&source=bl&ots=Nsp7LF6SpJ&sig=6rnRF8c0HOhMQIM1keW3ebfy21E&hl=fr&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiGk-298uvOAhXJIJoKHf45DpUQ6AEIHjAA#v=onepage&q=phase%20shift%20swashplate&f=false

Then I'll need to go on with advance angle (but I find that ugly), and also transverse flow effect is messing around as well... This is like a really big challenge to resolve all this in besiege

I mean, real helicopters doesn't seem to have this phase shift between the direction of the swashplate and the direction of the resulting applied force

Thanks! Do you mean that this phase shift is observable in reality? (And is related to physics and not a limitation due to simulation?) I'm pretty sure that the physics in besiege is correct, but only up to a certain degree of accuracy (due to calculation cost)

Nice design. I was surprised how stable it was. That phase shift is inherent to spinning objects (the same reason a gyroscope can be supported on one side of its axle but rotate horizontally). I guess the Besiege devs know their physics.