13,711 people found this review helpful
343 people found this review funny
2
942
303
136
117
92
78
39
38
31
31
23
20
17
13
12
8
7
6
4
3
3
3
2
1,928
Not Recommended
0.0 hrs last two weeks / 13.5 hrs on record (13.1 hrs at review time)
Posted: Sep 11, 2025 @ 9:08am
Updated: Sep 21, 2025 @ 3:29am
Product received for free

Stutterlands 4 Review: An Unholy Trio of Pricing, UE5 and Denuvo

I’ve been a Borderlands fan for years. The chaos, the humor, the endless loot grind... it’s always been about fun first, never too serious. But Borderlands 4? It feels like Gearbox got dazzled by Unreal Engine 5, slapped on a $70 price tag, and forgot the part where the game is supposed to actually run..

Randy Pitchford said fans should have “realistic expectations.” But if “realistic expectations” means paying $70 for a stutter ridden mess that crashes every few minutes and wrapped in Denuvo DRM that tanks performance even further, then no thanks. That’s not realism, that’s laziness dressed up as ambition.

The stutters are constant, the crashes are brutal, and it feels like the game fights you harder than the bosses do. Every firefight turns into a slideshow, every new area feels like a gamble whether the game will hold together or not. For a series built on fast, frantic chaos, it’s painful when the biggest challenge is just keeping the game from breaking...

Unreal Engine 5 Looks Pretty, But Plays Ugly

On paper, Borderlands 4 looks gorgeous. Unreal Engine 5’s lighting, reflections, and seamless world transitions give it a scale and detail the franchise never had before. But the moment you actually play, the shine fades. Stutters, frame drops, and bizarre loading hiccups pop up constantly. Even top-tier GPUs like the RTX 4080 and 5080 are struggling to keep 60FPS in 4K with DLSS on, and if the cutting edge hardware can’t do it, what chance do the average players have?

Gamers on Twitter couldn’t even crack 60fps at 1080p with an RTX 3070, a card that’s miles above the so called minimum requirements. That’s not just a hiccup, that’s proof the system requirements are complete nonsense. And Gearbox basically shrugged, warning that if you don’t meet their next-gen minimums, the game might be unplayable.

Imagine being told that before you even buy it. It’s not honesty, it’s them admitting they knew it was broken, but also knew people would still pay anyway.

Pricing Feels Like a Joke We’re Not In On

And then there’s the price. $70 for the base game is steep already, but $100 for Deluxe and $130 for Super Deluxe? Come on. For a game this unstable, it feels like paying premium for early access to a beta test. Randy Pitchford’s comment about real fans supporting the price was honestly insulting. Fans aren’t ATMs. We want to support the game, not bankroll optimization patches. It’s insane how devs keep shipping games with game-breaking bugs like it’s normal. These aren’t tiny glitches/bugs, they’re constant crashes and stutters, and they want full price for this mess?

What’s Still Great

I won’t pretend Borderlands 4 is all bad. In fact, underneath the mess, it might be the best Borderlands since 2. The humor lands, the gunplay is as addictive as ever, and the new mechanics have real potential to take the series forward. The tragedy is that none of it matters when the game can’t stay stable long enough for you to enjoy it. Every stutter, every crash, every performance hiccup turns what could have been the return of peak Borderlands into an expensive tech demo. And that’s what stings the most, there’s a damn good game here, maybe even a great one, but it’s buried under technical failures and a price tag that feels like a cruel joke.

Final Thoughts

Borderlands 4 should’ve been a victory lap. The full power of Unreal Engine 5, a fanbase that stuck around through every spin-off and cash grab and this is what we get? A broken, stutter-filled mess hidden behind Denuvo and a $70 paywall. Gearbox didn’t just drop the ball, they spiked it into the dirt and told us to clap anyway.

The cruel part? This is actually the best Borderlands since 2. The writing hits, the gunplay is fire, and the world begs to be explored. But none of that matters when you can’t play for more than ten minutes without a hitch, a crash, or your frames falling off a cliff. It’s like locking a gourmet meal behind a glass case and handing us a plastic fork.

Randy Pitchford told us to have realistic expectations...
Fine. Here’s mine: I expect a $70 game not to run like a beta test. I expect a studio with Gearbox’s legacy not to let DRM strangle its own players. I expect respect. Instead, we got excuses.

Unless Gearbox pulls its head out of its own hype machine, Borderlands 4 could kill the franchise. First the garbage and total joke of a movie, now this broken mess, they’re turning a legacy into a joke.

Don't Buy until they Fix the Performance Issues

🎅Would Appreciate If You Follow My Curator Page🎅

Would mean a lot if you supported me there, would help me create more quality and honest reviews.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
Developer response:
2KLynx  [developer] Posted: Sep 11, 2025 @ 4:20pm
We're sorry you're experiencing issues playing Borderlands 4.

If your PC has an NVIDIA card, we have an article covering how to optimize your Graphics Settings here: https://borderlands.2k.com/borderlands-4/news/nvidia-optimization/

If you're operating on a different graphics card, please check our PC Troubleshooting Guide here: https://steamcommunity.com/app/1285190/discussions/2/596285654384682506/

If your issues persist, please submit a request into 2K Support here: https://support.borderlands.com/hc/en-us/categories/39763360813843

We appreciate your help and patience as we work with you to resolve this issue.
292 Comments
Jun 22 @ 10:33pm 
This game evenrually got boring. The more i saw compiling shaders.
Thats it.
May 29 @ 5:36pm 
uhhh no the world does not beg to be explored. There's literally nothing interesting in it. One of the most boring and flat open worlds I've ever seen. Honestly. Makes Far Cry 6 look like skyrim.
Feb 28 @ 6:39pm 
I've never played this game before, I have played 1, 2 and 3. But after reading that developer response I'm truly sorry for the people who have bought this, I've read many reviews for this game. But after seeing this, I'm not going to buy it. 2Klynx basically just told this guy to buy another graphics card.
Dec 18, 2025 @ 10:41pm 
randy needs to be pushed out of gearbox!
Nov 8, 2025 @ 4:19pm 
Very well written review. Eloquently honest and direct. Loved it!:steamthumbsup:
Nov 4, 2025 @ 11:17am 
has there been any recent updates improving performance?
As an enjoyer of the fps bodycam, theere track record for fixing the performance for an unreal title is starting to hold up.
Nov 4, 2025 @ 7:10am 
Well said, couldnt have said it better myself.

Wonderlands DLC alienated me luckily from buying into this piece of crap. 20 mins worth of content for £30? nah im good ty. Movie that was total crap? then a borderlands 4 trailer straight after, its almost like they were trying to recoup losses by releasing it early. seems to be the case with the performance issues.

i think this will kill the franchise sadly. this is too many blunders in a row, Randy owns majority share afaik, so they cant get rid of him as CEO. thus the company is doomed.

Best thing they could do at this stage, is make a whole new IP. it would be sad for the borderlands universe, but if they cant make a good game after making some awesome games, then naturally time has ran its course.
Oct 15, 2025 @ 6:57am 
IT is sad that it runs like garbage but it isn't UE5s fault
Sep 23, 2025 @ 5:24am 
Legitimately sad... Here I was hoping to actually get a BL game for PC after finally getting a rig.. but after seeing all the negative reviews on poor optimization on top of the various benchmark videos, as well as streamers I follow struggling to even load the game past the title screen, yeah, absolute hard pass.
Sep 21, 2025 @ 1:02am 
Yep I left neg review too. Glad you wrote what you did cause it's on point.