Most underrated and overrated FNAF song

[Jesse]

Not nessecarily the best/worst, just ones the get too litte or too much praise

Underrated: Our Little Horror Story
I really dont see too many people talking about this one, but it is really good, and easily the best FNAF 3 song

Overrated: Every TLT song besides I Cant Fix You
They are good, but massively overplayed in my opinion. The only one that really is great is ICFU, because it has a good beat, and actually has good lyrics and a good beat, which some of his other songs kind of dont have.

[Glorious M e l o n]

Originally posted by Smear:

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

In the games at least.

No, In the TFC leaks, it was confirmed that Charlie is a robot

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Originally posted by Smear:

Well she kind of is, atleast the one we know

In the games she wasn't at least.

[Sp4rt4n1295]

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Originally posted by Elite#1295:

Just because it doesn’t directly reference FFPS doesn’t mean it isn’t about FFPS. In fact, the song is most likely supposed to be from Michael’s perspective. Just listen to the lyrics and tell me that doesn’t sound like Michael.

It doesn't at all. You could take away everything that advertises it as a FNaF song and you wouldn't find anything FNaF about it.

Whatever, dude.

[Jesse]

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Originally posted by Smear:

No, In the TFC leaks, it was confirmed that Charlie is a robot

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

In the games she wasn't at least.

Oh I misread that.

[Jesse]

"Purple" by Mandopony is also really good. I adore the song. I am not really a fan of his music, but Purple and Nothing Remains are amazing

[Glorious M e l o n]

Originally posted by Smear:

"Purple" by Mandopony is also really good. I adore the song. I am not really a fan of his music, but Purple and Nothing Remains are amazing

Some of his FNaF songs are really good, others are....are...gulp...

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Originally posted by Smear:

"Purple" by Mandopony is also really good. I adore the song. I am not really a fan of his music, but Purple and Nothing Remains are amazing

Some of his FNaF songs are really good, others are....are...gulp...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4on5MXHrY_E

[JMaster]

Originally posted by Smear:

"Purple" by Mandopony is also really good. I adore the song. I am not really a fan of his music, but Purple and Nothing Remains are amazing

Yeah, all the versions of Purple are amazing in my opinion. He has some other good ones too.

[jupiter]

Originally posted by Jun:

Originally posted by Smear:

I'd rank them best to worst:

ICFU (It's catchy and I like the lyrics)
FNAF 1 Song (It's pretty good but sometimes the lyrics don't really go to the beat)
Its Been So Long (Good song and story ruined by people who think it is canon)
Die in A Fire (Really generic and has nothing to do with FNAF besides a few lines)
I Got No Time (It's short and generic, I hate the singer's voice)

Eh your opinion is wrong

I agree.
List of mine:
FNaF 1 Song.
It's been so long.
I hope you die in a fire.
I got no time.
ICFU.

[jupiter]

Underrated: Painted Faces.

Overrated: ICFU.

[Jesse]

If anyone here has seen the video, what do you think of the FNAF Musical? (Random Encounters)

[Glorious M e l o n]

Originally posted by Jentrap ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°):

Originally posted by Melonbear the Pacifist Pyro:

Some of his FNaF songs are really good, others are....are...gulp...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4on5MXHrY_E

https://youtu.be/5FjWe31S_0g

[JMaster]

Originally posted by Smear:

If anyone here has seen the video, what do you think of the FNAF Musical? (Random Encounters)

I thought it was amazing. I remember patiently waiting for night 5 to come out, and then patiently waiting again for the full version to be released.

[Jesse]

Originally posted by Nightmarionne:

Originally posted by Smear:

If anyone here has seen the video, what do you think of the FNAF Musical? (Random Encounters)

I thought it was amazing. I remember patiently waiting for night 5 to come out, and then patiently waiting again for the full version to be released.

I think it's pretty good. I actually somewhat like the idea of the animatronics being actual good guys, despite how stupid the idea sounds on paper

[JMaster]

Originally posted by Smear:

Originally posted by Nightmarionne:

I thought it was amazing. I remember patiently waiting for night 5 to come out, and then patiently waiting again for the full version to be released.

I think it's pretty good. I actually somewhat like the idea of the animatronics being actual good guys, despite how stupid the idea sounds on paper

Yeah. I also like MatPat as the killer. I don't like him as the Phone Guy, but it works for the story the series was trying to tell. Personally, my favorite parts were nights 2 and 5. And the ending, but I was talking more about the songs then overall.

[Jesse]

Originally posted by Nightmarionne:

Originally posted by Smear:

I think it's pretty good. I actually somewhat like the idea of the animatronics being actual good guys, despite how stupid the idea sounds on paper

Yeah. I also like MatPat as the killer. I don't like him as the Phone Guy, but it works for the story the series was trying to tell. Personally, my favorite parts were nights 2 and 5.

I honestly didn't expect the entire Matpat thing. Even the "Purple Guy" was a somewhat good guy, and the entire thing was a lot more lighthearted than the real FNAF.... then Matpat comes