Holdfast: Nations At War

Holdfast: Nations At War

View Stats:
Does this game just not run well?
I've a 2080s and a i7 9700k, a few years old but nothing terrible. Even on the lowest settings, which looks like I'm playing Operation Flashpoint from 2001, can't even maintain 60 fps most of the time. I don't understand why this game just runs so badly. Does anyone else have problems with their performance? It's clearly a CPU issue... but other games of a similar genre run WAY better and also look better.
Last edited by Imperial Patriot; Apr 25, 2022 @ 11:23am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 23 comments
AnatidaephobiacDK Apr 25, 2022 @ 12:58pm 
Try the upscaling setting on balanced or performance.
Imperial Patriot Apr 25, 2022 @ 2:19pm 
Originally posted by mb79dk:
Try the upscaling setting on balanced or performance.

Upscaling won't do anything with what appear to be a massive CPU bottleneck. Even if it wasn't a CPU bottleneck, I shouldn't have to use upscaling on this game with a 2080s. Game only uses 60% of my GPU.
Last edited by Imperial Patriot; Apr 25, 2022 @ 2:20pm
nuc1eaR Apr 25, 2022 @ 5:41pm 
Funny thing is I also have a 2080S and a 9700k and I can barely hit 60 fps. On Extreme I maintain around 50fps in heavy areas. I don't think there is much you can do and changing upscaling doesn't increase anything either since the bottleneck seems to be pretty bad in this game.

What I did was I tried to reduce the CPU bottleneck by essentially keeping my textures and everything on high/extreme and then turning down stuff that is more "CPU intensive" like environmental clutter and destruction debris. I also found turning this game on borderless for some reason instead of fullscreen gives me a tad bit better framerate which is strange (try this to see if it works). I don't really notice the latency with borderless. These settings sorta helped reaching 60fps. What is even more annoying is that I switched from my 1080p monitor to my 4k one and the framerate is the exact same.

You get used to the awful framerate though, not really much you can do, I seen on reddit and the discord that getting 40-60fps is the norm in this game.
Imperial Patriot Apr 26, 2022 @ 3:06pm 
Originally posted by nuc1eaR:
Funny thing is I also have a 2080S and a 9700k and I can barely hit 60 fps. On Extreme I maintain around 50fps in heavy areas. I don't think there is much you can do and changing upscaling doesn't increase anything either since the bottleneck seems to be pretty bad in this game.

What I did was I tried to reduce the CPU bottleneck by essentially keeping my textures and everything on high/extreme and then turning down stuff that is more "CPU intensive" like environmental clutter and destruction debris. I also found turning this game on borderless for some reason instead of fullscreen gives me a tad bit better framerate which is strange (try this to see if it works). I don't really notice the latency with borderless. These settings sorta helped reaching 60fps. What is even more annoying is that I switched from my 1080p monitor to my 4k one and the framerate is the exact same.

You get used to the awful framerate though, not really much you can do, I seen on reddit and the discord that getting 40-60fps is the norm in this game.

That's kind of.. unacceptable for a game with this graphical fidelity. I guess it is what it is.
Last edited by Imperial Patriot; Apr 26, 2022 @ 3:07pm
nuc1eaR Apr 26, 2022 @ 10:34pm 
Originally posted by Imperial Patriot:
Originally posted by nuc1eaR:
Funny thing is I also have a 2080S and a 9700k and I can barely hit 60 fps. On Extreme I maintain around 50fps in heavy areas. I don't think there is much you can do and changing upscaling doesn't increase anything either since the bottleneck seems to be pretty bad in this game.

What I did was I tried to reduce the CPU bottleneck by essentially keeping my textures and everything on high/extreme and then turning down stuff that is more "CPU intensive" like environmental clutter and destruction debris. I also found turning this game on borderless for some reason instead of fullscreen gives me a tad bit better framerate which is strange (try this to see if it works). I don't really notice the latency with borderless. These settings sorta helped reaching 60fps. What is even more annoying is that I switched from my 1080p monitor to my 4k one and the framerate is the exact same.

You get used to the awful framerate though, not really much you can do, I seen on reddit and the discord that getting 40-60fps is the norm in this game.

That's kind of.. unacceptable for a game with this graphical fidelity. I guess it is what it is.

Yeah I know its really annoying. This game is a prime example of having a good singlethreaded CPU regardless of what GPU you buy. For a 2018 CPU, I noticed the 9700k is still holding strong in most games. I run BF2042 surprisingly better than this game and the bottleneck isn't as severe. I wish this game was more optimized for hardware but 150 players does take a huge toll. The more you play this game, the more you get used to the bad performance.
Xenu Apr 28, 2022 @ 5:13am 
when you start the game go in your task manager and put the game in high priority makes it a bit better for me.
Xenu Apr 28, 2022 @ 5:14am 
i have a 3080ti and 10700, game lags a lot expected this cpu to hold on but nope.
Imperial Patriot Apr 28, 2022 @ 5:09pm 
Originally posted by Xenu:
i have a 3080ti and 10700, game lags a lot expected this cpu to hold on but nope.

I suppose it's the engine they picked to create the game on. I guess Unity, which I typically think terrible of anyways, can't really do these large-scale multiplayer style games. Most Unity games run like garbage...

At least the trend of never releasing Unity engine early access survival games of 2012-2018 is over.
Last edited by Imperial Patriot; Apr 28, 2022 @ 5:12pm
Mother's Best Boy Apr 29, 2022 @ 8:15am 
lol i get between 40-90fps with a 3700x @ 4.3 ghz and an Asus ROG STRIX 3080 game has performance isues bad
xBCxRangers Apr 29, 2022 @ 8:49am 
Well, i played this game on a last gen Xbox One, on GE Force Now thru Steam thru the browser, and got 1080p at 30fps out of it. And so if i could do that there, i suppose it would run well on a decent computer.
Rock&StoneTorture Apr 29, 2022 @ 10:16am 
game has issues hence I refund it.
nuc1eaR Apr 29, 2022 @ 11:01am 
Originally posted by xBCxRangers:
Well, i played this game on a last gen Xbox One, on GE Force Now thru Steam thru the browser, and got 1080p at 30fps out of it. And so if i could do that there, i suppose it would run well on a decent computer.

You realize that when you play on GeForce Now you are playing off someone elses computer right?
xBCxRangers Apr 29, 2022 @ 12:26pm 
Originally posted by nuc1eaR:
Originally posted by xBCxRangers:
Well, i played this game on a last gen Xbox One, on GE Force Now thru Steam thru the browser, and got 1080p at 30fps out of it. And so if i could do that there, i suppose it would run well on a decent computer.

You realize that when you play on GeForce Now you are playing off someone elses computer right?

Yes. But i would have thought on an og Xbox One....on their browser, and thru Steam, and then thru Ge Froce Now i'd be playing a slide show at 480p and 10fps. But that's not the case.

And so my view is, if i'm able to get the result i did playing on old machine, and browser, and running thru all those hoops, someone on a decent PC would fare better. But i guess not. Try it on GE Force Now and see how you fare out maybe. You can get it free.
Last edited by xBCxRangers; Apr 29, 2022 @ 12:27pm
Stan May 1, 2022 @ 8:59am 
Originally posted by Imperial Patriot:
Originally posted by nuc1eaR:
Funny thing is I also have a 2080S and a 9700k and I can barely hit 60 fps. On Extreme I maintain around 50fps in heavy areas. I don't think there is much you can do and changing upscaling doesn't increase anything either since the bottleneck seems to be pretty bad in this game.

What I did was I tried to reduce the CPU bottleneck by essentially keeping my textures and everything on high/extreme and then turning down stuff that is more "CPU intensive" like environmental clutter and destruction debris. I also found turning this game on borderless for some reason instead of fullscreen gives me a tad bit better framerate which is strange (try this to see if it works). I don't really notice the latency with borderless. These settings sorta helped reaching 60fps. What is even more annoying is that I switched from my 1080p monitor to my 4k one and the framerate is the exact same.

You get used to the awful framerate though, not really much you can do, I seen on reddit and the discord that getting 40-60fps is the norm in this game.

That's kind of.. unacceptable for a game with this graphical fidelity. I guess it is what it is.
Most settings you should be able to turn up without an FPS impact. The game started development somewhere in 2013/2014, so there is plenty of old code that can't easily be changed to optimise. Your FPS on a high end system will be how good your CPU single thread performance is. As on full servers the thread has to process all of the player data sent to you by the server.

Regardless of how bad you can make the game look, on high end systems the bottleneck will always be CPU, which is why I encourage people to bump their graphical settings up.

There are only a few CPU based options that you can look into changing. The main one will be ragdoll corpses, which is located at the bottom of game settings, possibly some shadows. Turning off environmental clutter may help you on some maps, as we usually put environmental particle effects in this setting for people to turn off, though this setting will also turn off other small 3d object based objects that have no collision which can make some maps look more empty.

Myself I run on a 3080 and 10700k and 60FPS for me on full frontlines maps is a blessing, nations at war on the other hand can easily run between 60-90 fps depending on the map in full servers just simply because there is way less going on in the game due to the slower paced nature of NaW
Lansolot May 1, 2022 @ 9:25am 
I run maxed out with a 2060 (not S). Maybe it's a CPU bottleneck? Im running Ryzen 7 2700 3.2ghz. Nothing special but I know people get in the habit of upgrading GPU's to have a 3080 and an I5 lol.

edit: just to add not in 4k. RES is: 1920X1080. I'm sure If I tried to go higher I'd have to turn settings down. I also shoot for 60 FPS, not 90. With those parameters the game runs flawless for me.
Last edited by Lansolot; May 1, 2022 @ 9:31am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 23 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Apr 25, 2022 @ 11:17am
Posts: 23