Detective Sherlock: Shadow Stalker

Detective Sherlock: Shadow Stalker

View Stats:
Opinion and suggestions
Freely conversing with NPC is very exciting, it brings videogames towards new creative frontiers. Thanks for the free demo. However you have to better set the AI. I asked Henry and James to follow me and check the house or to take a bottle of champagne to drink together. Well, they described the scene where they were exploring the house together with me, or where they were drinking with me. It was like reading the novel, but me, James and Henry, we all were still in the same place, just talking. You should teach the AI that characters can't go anywhere, NPC must know that they are talking to Sherlock and cannot go anywhere or doing anything else.

I asked Henry to open the gates. He told me he had just opened the gates! But the gates were still closed!

I cannot complete the task Unlock Henry's Heart. I can't go further into the demo, I'm stuck to this task.

When I walk into Henry, near the stairs, there is a flaw, the game world disappears, it's like I fall through the polygons or go elsewhere; then I spawn into the garden! Weird!

I was talking to Henry in his room during daytime. I was talking about his father and his dirty past. Suddenly I got GAME OVER! What?! I clicked on "continue" and the game started again, but it was night, I had a flashlight, Henry was close to the stairs! What's happened?

Even at night, Lestrade and the doctor were still talking in the same place as before. Even James was still reading the same book in his room.

Everytime I start a conversation, NPC tell me always the same welcome, always the same words, just as it's the first time we meet.

EDIT: I added further considerations and analysis in the comments below. At the moment, after the first enthusiasm for the implementation of smart NPCs, the game suffers from heavy flaws and debatable choices of gameplay; in particular challenges that destroy the immersion in story and characters psychologies, such to make the AI system not very useful and even worse than usual system based on preordered dialogue choices.
< >
Showing 1-6 of 6 comments
Oct 15, 2025 @ 5:48pm 
Thank you very much for your suggestion. Your suggestion to let NPCs know they can't go anywhere else is a very good one, and we'll strengthen training in this area. As for the sudden "game over" , it's because of a time limit. The task will fail when the timer reaches 6:00 PM on the 21st. Sorry, this time limit is only stated in the task description. We'll also indicate the time limit when the task fails. The issue after clicking "Continue" is a bug, and we'll fix it as soon as possible.
Please, get rid of time limits, they are flawed. I completed Henry interrogation, but while interviewing mr Berrymore, I got GAME OVER; I repeated the quest many times, everytime the image of Henry appears, with weird writings in Chinese or Korean language. What's the sense of time limits when the enjoyment is conversing with intelligent NPCs? Anyway I completed any task before the time limit, so, the time system is flawed.
I noticed that now characters are refusing to move and follow Sherlock, thanks for the patch and update!
I managed to complete every task in a hurry, Barrymore interrogation included, and the dinner cut scene started. However I must say that the time limits destroy the fun of conversing with intelligent characters. If i'm meant to write down just the questions suggested in a hurry, implementation of AI system makes sense no more. The fun was conversing, asking further details and so on. But time limits force me to ask few preordered questions and make preordered actions like accusing and showing items. It's the same as using preordered multiple dialogue choices in ordinary and traditional games; even worse, because you need to be very fast and you cannot enjoy the story and the atmosphere properly.
Moreover, after the dinner sequence, Watson started very silly games: guess the object or write down the sequence of claps! It destroys completely the story, the atmosphere, the characters psychology.
After that, Henry was reluctant to go outside. I was meant to convince him to go out with me and Watson. That's ok, it's in tune with Henry psychology, he is scared by the curse. I convinced him to go outside, he agreed to follow me; nevertheless the game was still expecting me to give the right answer to convince him! Again i had a limited number of chances to convince him, five chances. Luckily if I close the dialogue box, the count starts from zero again. However it's very hard to guess the exact answer he is waiting for in order to proceed to the next scene.

In conclusion, I appreciate the attempt to introduce intelligent NPCs; it offers a glimpse of the infinite possibilities of making interactions with NPCs more and more complex and interesting, such to immerse players more and more into the shoes of the protagonist and into the story. However implementations of AI system is still not satisfying, too many flaws, frictions and distractions. I suggest developers to focus on story, characters, psychologies, conversations, investigations, avoiding further challenges that destroy atmosphere and narrative and make the use of AI even more complex and difficult.
Oct 19, 2025 @ 4:46am 
Thank you for your valuable feedback! We agree that Watson’s riddle mini-games somewhat break the narrative immersion. In future updates, we’ll make his puzzles more in line with the story and his personality, rather than simple childlike riddles. The difficulty of Henry’s part is indeed a bit too high, and we’ll adjust it accordingly.

As for the time system, we plan to slow down the in-game time progression to ensure players don’t feel too rushed. However, since all missions and day-night transitions depend on the in-game time, this system will remain in place.

If you have any other suggestions, we’d be very happy to hear them!
Such an awesome concept! I agree the timeline is far too limiting though. Also a brief tutorial at the start would be helpful. I don’t understand Sherlock’s clue page or confronting characters with evidence. There’s also evidence available when you start the game with no explanation (wallet, violin, etc).
Thank you for the suggestions! We really appreciate the feedback. In future updates, we’ll consider adding more guidance and explanations to help players better understand the clue system, evidence interactions, and other gameplay mechanics.
< >
Showing 1-6 of 6 comments
Per page: 1530 50