Triss or Yennefer, hardest choice in video game history

[leafs43]

I was dead set on Triss, then I met Yennefer and it's making me second guess that choice.


Why you do this CDR?!?!

[Sif]

it would be the same that state that yen have a case with leto's companions while she was with then

[Abist Thuringiensis]

İlk olarak Sipehi " tarafından gönderildi:

İlk olarak Festina Lente tarafından gönderildi:

No, really. It is confirmed that Triss cucked Geralt somewhere between the events of TW2 and TW3 with lambert. Confirmed by CD Projekt Red. If you dig a bit on Twitter or Youtube you'll find the original sources.

not betwen the events of TW1 and TW2, the lambert theory is about the footprints in triss house in the TW1, outside that is just a plot hole, in TW3 there are no evidence of any kind about the two, it doent make any sence since triss was hiding from the witch hunters and lambert was hunting karadin. again just another fan hole theory

I don't really remember the details about the Lambert theory, but i know for a fact that CD project red themselves confirmed it. I mean, if the guys who made the game left clues about it and then confirmed it later on social media it has to mean something, doesn't it?

[Sif]

İlk olarak Festina Lente tarafından gönderildi:

İlk olarak Sipehi " tarafından gönderildi:

not betwen the events of TW1 and TW2, the lambert theory is about the footprints in triss house in the TW1, outside that is just a plot hole, in TW3 there are no evidence of any kind about the two, it doent make any sence since triss was hiding from the witch hunters and lambert was hunting karadin. again just another fan hole theory

I don't really remember the details about the Lambert theory, but i know for a fact that CD project red themselves confirmed it. I mean, if the guys who made the game left clues about it and then confirmed it later on social media it has to mean something, doesn't it?

there are no confirmation by the company, only the fan theory plus the plot holes

[Sif]

And again, if you pay atention to the TW1 plot you wuld understand that the "clues" appear way before Geralt comit to Triss in the first game(if you comit) and the theory itself has several plot holes. so no case of Cucking like Yen

[zanzibar_007]

İlk olarak Sipehi " tarafından gönderildi:

And again, if you pay atention to the TW1 plot you wuld understand that the "clues" appear way before Geralt comit to Triss in the first game(if you comit) and the theory itself has several plot holes. so no case of Cucking like Yen

unless she was cucking Ciri, aka the chosen one, her little sister to King Estheran Thyssen of Kovir, something Ciri hates like hell.

[Sif]

İlk olarak zanzibar_007 tarafından gönderildi:

İlk olarak Sipehi " tarafından gönderildi:

And again, if you pay atention to the TW1 plot you wuld understand that the "clues" appear way before Geralt comit to Triss in the first game(if you comit) and the theory itself has several plot holes. so no case of Cucking like Yen

unless she was cucking Ciri, aka the chosen one, her little sister to King Estheran Thyssen of Kovir, something Ciri hates like hell.

she was fine with that in the games

[zanzibar_007]

İlk olarak Sipehi " tarafından gönderildi:

İlk olarak zanzibar_007 tarafından gönderildi:

unless she was cucking Ciri, aka the chosen one, her little sister to King Estheran Thyssen of Kovir, something Ciri hates like hell.

she was fine with that in the games

yeah and Geralt slept with Shani who was 17, LOL, don't take the game for the truth baby Boi !

[Sif]

But we are in the game discussion topic, lol

[Shgon Dunstan]

After having read a lot of this thread... Honestly, either Triss or neither seem to be the way to go. Oh, book Geralt would likely pick Yennefer... But the fact that they're poison for each other seems to of been a large part of the point of their relationship.

Having not read all the books yet, I was conflicted about breaking up the family, but... Honestly, post memory lost Geralt isn't the exact same person he was before, and hiss love for Yen... "real" or not, WAS forced... Also, the summaries of said relationship just sounds majorly messed up.

Triss on the other hand... She ain't perfect, but... Neither or either Geralt or Yennefer, and honestly, her "betrayals" and "deceptions"... Are pretty freaking minor. "oh, but she slept with him when he didn't remember her". Yeah, her, and half the females in the land. Hell, in W1 she practically tells you to go and sleep with the princess to get information... Aside from thinking Yen is dead, you aren't exactly in any kind of "exclusive" relationship with her for most of that game... If you even call their relationship truly "exclusive" to begin with.

Whatever she was in the books, game Triss just comes off as having her head on straighter then either Geralt or Yennefer... Which all in all, almost makes her too good for Geralt. Which in turn is what makes her the attractive choice, as she symbolizes him trying to move past all the ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ with Yennefer. Quitting while he was ahead as it were.

...Hell, the real problem here is simply that this "choice" basically amounts to the question of "with whom does James Bond settle down happily ever after?"... Naturally, the answer is "he doesn't. He is psychologically incapable of such a thing, and attracts people much the same as him."

So... I guess that makes the "they both tie him up to a bed and leave him" the "good" ending all around.

[Bruce Wayne]

Yen

[Jimmy]

Yen was such an ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ the whole time that for me it was no brainer to pick Triss.
To be honest there were moments where i couldnt believe the way she was reacting. Like i thought realistically noone would be such an idiot and so ungrateful or arrogant given the circumstances.

But maybe thats what made the choice so meaningful i dont know. But that particular dilema for me was super easy. Yen never had a chance.

[Alejandro Monteagudo]

İlk olarak Thor tarafından gönderildi:

İlk olarak Shelledfade tarafından gönderildi:

triss for sure. Like redheads better, she was in game 1 and 2. No brainer.

You're right. If you have no brain, you haven't read the books and will say nonsense like this. (SCNR)

Dude your buthurt is showing, this is a game forum, people are discusing the game, not the books, try to chill.

[Alejandro Monteagudo]

İlk olarak Shgon Dunstan tarafından gönderildi:

After having read a lot of this thread... Honestly, either Triss or neither seem to be the way to go. Oh, book Geralt would likely pick Yennefer... But the fact that they're poison for each other seems to of been a large part of the point of their relationship.

Having not read all the books yet, I was conflicted about breaking up the family, but... Honestly, post memory lost Geralt isn't the exact same person he was before, and hiss love for Yen... "real" or not, WAS forced... Also, the summaries of said relationship just sounds majorly messed up.

Triss on the other hand... She ain't perfect, but... Neither or either Geralt or Yennefer, and honestly, her "betrayals" and "deceptions"... Are pretty freaking minor. "oh, but she slept with him when he didn't remember her". Yeah, her, and half the females in the land. Hell, in W1 she practically tells you to go and sleep with the princess to get information... Aside from thinking Yen is dead, you aren't exactly in any kind of "exclusive" relationship with her for most of that game... If you even call their relationship truly "exclusive" to begin with.

Whatever she was in the books, game Triss just comes off as having her head on straighter then either Geralt or Yennefer... Which all in all, almost makes her too good for Geralt. Which in turn is what makes her the attractive choice, as she symbolizes him trying to move past all the ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ with Yennefer. Quitting while he was ahead as it were.

...Hell, the real problem here is simply that this "choice" basically amounts to the question of "with whom does James Bond settle down happily ever after?"... Naturally, the answer is "he doesn't. He is psychologically incapable of such a thing, and attracts people much the same as him."

So... I guess that makes the "they both tie him up to a bed and leave him" the "good" ending all around.

Actually, I agree, I am going to choose one of them, but yeah, Geralt wouldn´t settle down...BUT IN DA BOOK... yeah, I am playing the game and choosing from what I see here and I agree he´d try to have them both and get nothing then spen the rest of his life as a roaming witcher, banging everyone and ocassionally killing werefolves.

[Treknor]

it is not.. read the books and you know why

[MaximumEffort]

İlk olarak Treknor tarafından gönderildi:

it is not.. read the books and you know why

Nothing to do with the games.