Sven Co-op

Sven Co-op

you know what would be cool
having any ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ clue what to do, any kind of objective or status as to what the ♥♥♥♥ is going on
< >
Showing 1-15 of 15 comments
depends on the map and server really, whenever you play with friends and take your time you can usually understand what the hell is going on. It doesnt help that amateur mappers could also make a bad layout which makes following players even harder. You could try reading the missiong briefing (the two panels that you can usually skip by pressing spacebar) but joining an on-going map playthrough can be really hard to follow naturally. Not much you can do!
Originally posted by SV BOY:
depends on the map and server really, whenever you play with friends and take your time you can usually understand what the hell is going on. It doesnt help that amateur mappers could also make a bad layout which makes following players even harder. You could try reading the missiong briefing (the two panels that you can usually skip by pressing spacebar) but joining an on-going map playthrough can be really hard to follow naturally. Not much you can do!

So it's mostly rando mappers, that's cool, I can understand that, but maybe the core game should have it built in objective mechanics? Maybe it already does and they don't use them?
Not sure why this is necessary for half life and it's expansions but mods? Maybe some but this is unnecessary for the most part
Originally posted by DIOGENES:
Originally posted by SV BOY:
depends on the map and server really, whenever you play with friends and take your time you can usually understand what the hell is going on. It doesnt help that amateur mappers could also make a bad layout which makes following players even harder. You could try reading the missiong briefing (the two panels that you can usually skip by pressing spacebar) but joining an on-going map playthrough can be really hard to follow naturally. Not much you can do!

So it's mostly rando mappers, that's cool, I can understand that, but maybe the core game should have it built in objective mechanics? Maybe it already does and they don't use them?
well, the core game's objectives are... get to the end of the map. in half-life 1 maps that means progressing forward, if you need to do something specific a NPC might tell you what to do, you just keep going forward until you reach the final boss, then defeat it. random maps can have any objective you can think of.
Originally posted by mimizukari:
Originally posted by DIOGENES:

So it's mostly rando mappers, that's cool, I can understand that, but maybe the core game should have it built in objective mechanics? Maybe it already does and they don't use them?
well, the core game's objectives are... get to the end of the map. in half-life 1 maps that means progressing forward, if you need to do something specific a NPC might tell you what to do, you just keep going forward until you reach the final boss, then defeat it. random maps can have any objective you can think of.

Right but that kind of thing is all about frameworking... if the base mod provides the framework for objectives then mods can use that and players can actually understand what the hell is going on.

I would go so far as to say that maps which lack any kind of objective information are dated at best, idiotic at worst.
Originally posted by DIOGENES:
having any ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ clue what to do, any kind of objective or status as to what the ♥♥♥♥ is going on
:steamlaughcry: good one

Yeah, adding to the full converstation:
Even the official Sven maps (built by original devs or by others and later packed into the game files as official) didn't quite set a good example.

See, the entire game's idealogy is basically "Half-Life x10". This means that enemies are made to spam attacks without respite, levels just keep spawning wave after waves of enemies, spongey enemies, Players are expected to die until they can finish the map and many maps are designed for public servers expecting there to be 10 players playing together and many other things along these lines.
This approach has set an example to everyone else and so, many maps that would normally be considered terrible even in Half-Life is actually considered normal here, like guidance issues, spongey enemies and outright forcing the players to die their way through. And so, the cost is that the bar is so low that level design never really grew in the community.

It's RARE AF to find a map that leaves you happy after the end rather than frustrated. Also, considering the game is now +27 years old, anyone who had actually grew their skills has moved on to other games/projects.

Anyway, if you're downloading from SCMAPDB make sure to either sort by Ratings or check a map's score and reviews before downloading. Also keep in mind that many people are too friendly or have low standards (due to the above) and may give great scores to something that deserves a 5/10.
I guess Chimz forget sometimes that his opinion is just his opinion.
he can downvote the something very cool like bts_rc, but it's objectively a good map
also, don't forget that scmapdb rating sucks for a truly more judicious valuation since you can easily downove any map to 1-2 rate via creating endless accounts just because you don't like the map for some reason (not because the map is bad, different reasons imo)/you hate mapper/you're just an arsehole which hate sven or devs team or whoever you hate
This is very much mapper opinion.

What you're overlooking is that this game along with many of the people that have made maps for it come from 90s era gaming. The vast majority of games back then did not have objective pointers or guidance, the players were expected to use their intelligence to keep notes (sometimes mental, sometimes written) of what's going on and where. The most we got was a minimap if lucky. There was no hand-holding of any sort. It was very much "Missed a clue? Go f yourself, pay better attention next time."

Obviously times have changed, and without sounding too much like a broken record, so have the expectations of today's youth player base. There's currently no plan for a built-in objective system, but mappers are welcome to adopt an existing one from another map, or implement their own.
Originally posted by Four-Nines:
I guess Chimz forget sometimes that his opinion is just his opinion.
he can downvote the something very cool like bts_rc, but it's objectively a good map
Funny how the creator reached out for feedback with such polite behavior and attitude, allowing us to have such a mature talk that we both enjoyed while everyone else has been the opposite and acting like children. Food for thought I guess.
Originally posted by Chimz:
Originally posted by Four-Nines:
I guess Chimz forget sometimes that his opinion is just his opinion.
he can downvote the something very cool like bts_rc, but it's objectively a good map
Funny how the creator reached out for feedback with such polite behavior and attitude, allowing us to have such a mature talk that we both enjoyed while everyone else has been the opposite and acting like children. Food for thought I guess.

don't get me wrong, I don't wanna to get into conflict or something like this with anyone.

I just wanted to make it clear that all of this is a subjective judgement that based on personal views and taste in mapping stuff. mb you don't like the half of what me or someone else consider to be at least playable. but what you said that the majority has low standards is at least disrespectful to both mappers and players.

Sven Co-op (and Half-Life itself) is hardly a professional platform for level designers when viewed from the perspective of content creation. many factors here: limitations, a lack of knowledge, old engine stuff, etc. and most of these works (especially from the 200X) are the result of hobbies after studying or work.

and no one stopping you from criticizing something or rate it. absolutely not. but the fact remains: most complaints are quite subjective.
You did poorly then
Didn't read the thread yet but
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ I agree
Thanks to the mappers for their maps but ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ most of them have ZERO level design skill it's insane
Like the AVGN says : " Where the ♥♥♥♥ do I go kind of game "
replace game with map ;)

Also most mappers really HATES the light entity for some reason.
This is why on most server you have plugins that enables nightvision and such
Official maps are all AMAZING maps

I just wanted to rant and that thread was perfect
imagine thisguy on secretcity
Originally posted by DIOGENES:
having any ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ clue what to do, any kind of objective or status as to what the ♥♥♥♥ is going on
aint the sven coop devs fault, its the fault of whoever made the maps
< >
Showing 1-15 of 15 comments
Per page: 1530 50