Install Steam
login
|
language
简体中文 (Simplified Chinese)
繁體中文 (Traditional Chinese)
日本語 (Japanese)
한국어 (Korean)
ไทย (Thai)
Български (Bulgarian)
Čeština (Czech)
Dansk (Danish)
Deutsch (German)
Español - España (Spanish - Spain)
Español - Latinoamérica (Spanish - Latin America)
Ελληνικά (Greek)
Français (French)
Italiano (Italian)
Bahasa Indonesia (Indonesian)
Magyar (Hungarian)
Nederlands (Dutch)
Norsk (Norwegian)
Polski (Polish)
Português (Portuguese - Portugal)
Português - Brasil (Portuguese - Brazil)
Română (Romanian)
Русский (Russian)
Suomi (Finnish)
Svenska (Swedish)
Türkçe (Turkish)
Tiếng Việt (Vietnamese)
Українська (Ukrainian)
Report a translation problem
Not quite. They're untrustworthy of insane individuals, they're suspicious of people who may be psykers, and just paranoid in general. While most are equal on the level, it doesn't mean it's a high bar. Sure, it's fine to be gay or trans. Who cares, get back into the 18 hour shift at the arm crushing factory. Or go die in the sewers as they install a new sewer grate only to be killed by a rat of unknown size the city doesn't really care about. Because it's only killing unimportant people. Or be randomly killed after an judge settled a 13 generation long case and deemed your great great great great great great great grandpa a criminal and now you need to die for his crimes. Or just be sentenced to death for adding flavor flakes to your corpse starch rations.
Just because there's a form of equality, doesn't mean life is going to actually be good or pleasant to live in.
Except they don't defeat the evil aspects? They've ground up species formerly allied with them for medicine. They kill xenos who have aided them. They create horrid living conditions, and refuse to try to improve quality of life. It isn't even a matter of good governors, as even when everything was lined up for the Imperium conditions still weren't great.
The Imperium actively treats its citizens like ♥♥♥♥, they don't just kill hostile xenos, they kill any xenos. With rare exceptions being when they're A) harmless and B) don't have special resources. An example of this was a race of xenos that was harmless, but then they found out something in them is useful for anti-aging tech. So then they killed every single one, and if memory serves right it wasn't even that good. They have active prejudice against anyone different on a physical level, unless they're useful such as Ogryns/Ratlings. Which feeds into their hypocritical nature. The Imperium is a genuinely ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up place to live within. I mean ♥♥♥♥, just take a look at Gambol the toy clown.
You can dislike Black Library as much as you like, but they launched with 3rd edition. Which is when GW started settling down a bit more with lore
The Imperium likewise sees its citizens as food, toys to torture, and slaves. The "occasional" death is downplayed to being a frequent occurrence, alongside frequent mutilation.
The Imperium's god actively eats thousands of citizens a day (the psykers), with the Imperium actively turning citizens into their own form of possessed, servitors. Which is even their own form of being turned into an eternal puppet. The reason people even turn to chaos in the first place is solely because of how ♥♥♥♥♥♥ it is to even live in the Imperium. The Imperium directly supplies its greatest foe with forces by just being such a ♥♥♥♥♥♥ faction to be a part of.
Modern 40k is mostly something know as Grimmdark, a term inspired by the intro for warhammer 40k. It has become a little bit more serious.
But 40k is an extreme universe. Extreme religious persecution, extreme masculinity, extreme violence, extreme paranoia, extreme epic battles, extreme daemons.
Warhammer isn't about representation. It's post apocalyptic wargaming in a grimmdark world, it's escapism, and politics and representation are not the point of a grimm post apoc universe. Nor is enlightenment or sense, it doesn't have to make sense, if you want a utopia, watch star trek.
A core part of the world building an power balancing is "so much has been lost, never to be recovered" The emperor figured out how to make space marines, but the gene pool is narrow, not only do you need to be compatible, you must survive it.
So you have narrow recruitment, which adds to the world building, chapters normally recruit hardcore gangers or tribal death world inhabitants, and even of those many perish before and during trials.
To water down 40k fundamentally misunderstands it. 40k isn't a fair universe, and the emperor is a flawed ruler. it is most comparable to Greek myth, the idea of insane gods, of tragedy and metaphysical stories.
To demand female space marines ignores the narrow recruitment gene pool of space marines, it also ignores real life science, which is the top % of women athletes are not even close to the middle 50% of male athletes, and astartes are recruited from the top 0.1% and many of those perish from the trials or latent gene incompatibility. It balanced the universe, it makes it more harsh. The tech of 40k is not perfect and the fact so many healthy aspirants perish is proof of that.
There are badass female factions, and the separation adds to the themes of a dark age, a catholic hellhole.
Pre-imperial golden age humanity would have successfully done it, and they would have make super genetic warriors who could be recruited from anywhere, and they'd cure every mental instability with super science and make allies out of aliens.
But 40k is post apocalyptic, the fall of the human empire thanks to the abominable intelligences, machines that consumed entire systems.
it's heavily inspired by the butlerian jihad from dune, and the paranoia around thinking machines.
All that to say, it is never implied only straight white super men defend humanity, in fact the imperial guard is stated to hold the line, the men and women of. That most of humanities walls have been held against accursed traitors, including the damnable chaos space marines, by the men and women of the imperial guard.
To clean up and fix the imperium, have girl space marines, and openly gay characters and have it be all rainbowy just breaks the setting. It's a time where the inquisition exists
The emperors own son has to contend with the high lords of terra, he can't dismantle the religion that his father inadvertently spawned. It's a regressive time of fear, paranoia, constant war, standing out risks censure and worst.
When golden age humans time travelled and tried to warn humanity of the end, the planet they landed on called them heretics and burned them alive at the stake.
Keep your politics out of my fandom. People like you have ruined escapism into fiction enough, you killed star wars, you killed marvel, you killed star trek, and so many games. 40k communites don't care if you're a women or gay, but if you try to change our tabletop game, to push any sort of politics, you're the bully, go away. Make your own game if that's what you want, more power to you. But there is nothing wrong with this setting, and it doesn't need to change, it is perfectly imperfect, just the way it is.
If you change it, you will lose your long time fans, by making the setting lame and broken. Just like rings of power.
Well exactly, and it's no big secret that's the case either. I do wonder if some people are just stuck in the mindset of needing a binary choice; either cheer for the good "guys", or side up with the bad "guys". After all, the concept of everyone actually being bad is quite a novel concept in media and entertainment. Perhaps the appeal of, and option of picking, the faction that is subjectively less bad than the others is something people just struggle with for whatever reason.
This actual quote from GW should make it pretty clear:
"There are no goodies in the Warhammer 40,000 universe.
None.
Especially not the Imperium of Man.
Its numberless legions of soldiers and zealots bludgeon their way across the galaxy, delivering death to anyone and anything that doesn’t adhere to their blinkered view of purity. Almost every man and woman toils in misery either on the battlefield – where survival is measured in hours – or in the countless manufactorums and hive slums that fuel the Imperial war machine. All of this in slavish servitude to the living corpse of a God-Emperor whose commandments are at best only half-remembered, twisted by time and the fallibility of Humanity.
Warhammer 40,000 isn’t just grimdark. It’s the grimmest, darkest.
The Imperium of Man stands as a cautionary tale of what could happen should the very worst of Humanity’s lust for power and extreme, unyielding xenophobia set in. Like so many aspects of Warhammer 40,000, the Imperium of Man is satirical."
Oh my, this did make me chuckle, but so true. But then especially on here, there's a culture of picking on one small thing and then attempting to elevate it beyond the stature and focus of the bigger picture.
People see things the way they want to I guess, even though it contradicts the reality of the setting.
Before Chaos was even an active foe, they weren't in a utopia. The Imperium is always a self defeating machine that grinds its citizens apart on a massive scale to the point where a servitorized human isn't a shocking thing, but a day to day thing. Hence why nobody gives two ♥♥♥♥♥ why say, the door control is a human skull.
They're so ♥♥♥♥♥♥ they actively make people go to Chaos. As you've said, Chaos sucks ass. Imagine how ♥♥♥♥♥♥ something has to be that people want to jump ship in order to try to have a better life with something that sucks as much as Chaos does
EDIT: Fixed typo
They suck ass in comparison to say, the Tau. They suck ass compared to the Interex, they suck ass compared to the Golden Apostlex, they suck ass compared to the Diasporex. Hell, someone even just provided an example of that ship of Golden Age humans who tried warning the Imperium only to be called heretics and killed.
And yes, those all suck ass. Now multiply that by a thousand and spread it across the galaxy. There's the casual ♥♥♥♥ the Imperium gets up to on a day to day basis
If you're asking how the Imperium is grimdark, please. Just take a gander. Look at the ambience in Darktide, look at servitors, look at the countless examples of how it treats its people.
Humanity is not well fed, well protected, or well equipped. They have to grind up people to use as rations for many, many planets. They can't produce most of their most powerful tech, it's falling apart, and they're unable to defend planets that aren't of key importance.
The Imperium is so ♥♥♥♥♥♥ that even the Tau empire seems like a utopia compared to them, even though they'd be the villains in any other franchise. Sure, humans would be second rate citizens. But it'd be better than being whatever class they're on. Fifty or something.
The Imperium, is absolute ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ to live in. Nobody cares about things like sexuality or gender due to more pressing matters like the ones I've already mentioned. On top of starving and being overworked. They're just like everyone else, AKA. Not the good guys
You are ruining our games with your iclusivity
Thought this was about Space Marines specifically. Can't deny the women stuff. I don't know about the gay stuff though. Not something I've really come across only until recently, with you lot. This "long history of gaydom" with the 40K franchise simply does not exist on this end of the reality scale. So don't know if that's just wishful thinking on your part or Internet hear say. Plus who is rubbing their junk on who is not something I really care to think about when it comes to 40K. I'm not even sure why people even want this. Like it matters. My money shots tend to be in the form of Bolt rounds. What game are you actually wanting to play here ? Either way, it's not something that I would consider valid. You do you, by all means. Just don't expect it to fit me and don't rub my face in it just because you get a kick out of being unpleasant towards the people who disagree with you. In case you are not paying attention. It is basically this strategy that has all but destroyed the fan bases of most of the major ips, this last 12 years. And now like locusts, you're here for Warhammer.
Ah well. Was good while it lasted. Sub 2000's rule sets were best anyway
First off, I am going to assume this is a good faith post and not just rage bait because their is tons of lore on why gay, trans, and even straight space marines don't exist.
Let me start by saying. There are no "good guys" in Warhammer. You pick your favorite faction, Aldari is probably best for you judging by the question, and that's it.
Space Marine's are completely mind wiped and don't have sexual feelings towards anything. It's a concept to them but not something they feel or can feel. They are brainwashed essentially. Also they have a black carapace sen into their skin and to remove it would be fatal. So even if they wanted to act on any urges, they can't.
Second the Sisters of Battle are my favorite army and consist of badass Woman Space Marine's. To create "female space marine's" is redundant and would ruin the whole point of the Sisters of Battle.
Also, why do we need a trans spacemarine? They are genetically modified to be perfect, so wouldn't it go to show that they would be born in the right body? Also to reiterate, Space Marine's don't have any sexual desires. You can look towards Slaneesh for pleasures of the flesh. And to the Slaneesh Worshippers, they are the good guys.
HOW MUCH CLOWNS YOU GAVE HIM?!
I wouldn't mind having some Sisters of battle, but imagining a superhuman female with giant biceps and square jaw, or male space marines kissing and holding hands makes me puke.