Ergebnisse für "" :: barter.vg

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Solomon:
I lost the key and the one who received it could use it all this time, so why is this fact not taken into account?

It was, and that was why LRiPPER asked to see BlackyM's recent licenses, which did not show Pandemic. The investigation was complicated by the fact that the key was visible in the screenshots you posted to the offer.

LRiPPER continued to search until the beta key was revoked. At this point, it was clear that the item offered was not as described. If you had completed the trade, BlackyM would have disputed the offer since it was a limited-time beta rather than a key from Fanatical.

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Solomon:
That is, now everyone who received a beta key that was recalled can open a dispute upon the loss.

Yes, this is possible. Revocation is a reason to dispute a completed offer.

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Solomon:
What then to do when developers revoke keys purchased at Humble for example?

Dispute is an option, and the mediator will examine the situation. This has been more common occurrence for Go Go Bundles and traders have come to expect this from Go Go.

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Solomon:
I’m not asking for compensation. I just ask you to leave a reminder for BlackyM so that it is more attentive and other users as well.

This is why LRiPPER set the offer to Abandoned. It counts as a failed offer. This seems to be the appropriate reason given what happened. BlackyM claimed not to have used the key and LRiPPER found no evidence to contradict this. If you're curious about when it was activated, you can contact Steam support, but there is little else to be done with the dispute.

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Solomon:
I am sure that this will not affect his transactions in the future, but I am also sure that such large traders need to leave such reminders so that they do not use their reputation to put pressure on small traders.

BlackyM did make a mistake by proposing this offer and contacting you without canceling it. However, it appears to be a mistake and not an attempt to defraud you.

I've read the offer comments and messaged LRiPPER, but I was not the mediator so please tell me if this description is accurate.

Two weeks ago, you sent this offer https://barter.vg/u/4b44/o/3316700/ and BlackyM countered with this offer https://barter.vg/u/4b44/o/3316998/ that you accepted. However, BlackyM left the offer as 2:1 instead of changing it to 2:2. BlackyM contacted you on Steam and you send the key for Pandemic: The Board Game, after which, BlackyM wrote `no sorry I cannot do that I thought 2 for 2` and the conversation continued without any agreement. Afterwards, BlackyM failed the offer and requested to cancel. You failed the offer and disputed with sent item, received nothing. You then posted the screenshots of the Steam chat, including the visible key, in the offer comments.

LRiPPER volunteered to mediate the dispute and spent several days messaging with both sides including asking a receiving a screenshot of BlackyM's recent licenses. In addition, researched the key that appeared in the public screenshot. The key produced Status: Fail/DuplicateActivationCode error and at the time, the thought was that someone may have seen the screenshot and activated the key. However, key was for 167501, Pandemic for Beta Testing. After searching, LRiPPER discovered that there was an ongoing free beta test on asmodee.net and was able to obtain a key and verify that it also activated 167501. Keys from bundles were for 167502.

On April 1, the beta key that LRiPPER received was revoked. Based on this information, it seemed likely that the beta key that you offered was not from Fanatical and either did not work at the time or would be revoked in the days following the offer. Therefore, BlackyM had no obligation to complete the exchange because the key was a revoked beta key and not purchased from a bundle. The most appropriate resolution was to set the offer to Failed: not as described / abandoned.

The screenshots are no longer visible in the offer due to changes I made to avoid the accidental posting of keys and gift links. Please remove or obscure keys and other private information before uploading them.

9. Feb. 2020 um 5:13