Portal 2 > 일반 토론 > 제목 정보
Party Spock Anthem 2012년 10월 4일 오전 4시 18분
Who do you think is more awesome? Wheatley or GLaDOS?
Who'd you pick?
Party Spock Anthem님이 마지막으로 수정; 2012년 10월 4일 오전 4시 20분
17개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
Zyroxeon 2012년 10월 4일 오전 8시 42분 
SO HARD

wheatley
Party Spock Anthem 2012년 10월 4일 오후 9시 46분 
Wheatley is really funny (in my opinion)
MCA 2012년 10월 5일 오후 6시 14분 
Totaly GLaDOS.
Hell Diguner 2012년 10월 8일 오후 12시 55분 
GLaDOS. Wheatley's role/acting/character really grated against me in the last few chapters.

I still wish GLaDOS acted a bit more like she did in Portal 1 though, more random, and more subtle undercurrent of evil.
Party Spock Anthem 2012년 10월 11일 오후 10시 55분 
Good point, Hell Diguner. Wish GLaDOS creeped me out more in Portal 2 just like she did in the factory area in Portal 1.
~ D e a t h N o t e ~ 2012년 10월 12일 오후 5시 37분 
wheatle is funny
Miles High Flying Prower 2012년 12월 29일 오전 10시 16분 
Wheatley forever!
rochendil 2012년 12월 29일 오전 10시 45분 
GLaDOS definetly, GLaDOS all the way. No one is better at that kind of humor. Definetly GLaDOS
Lil' Gideon 2012년 12월 29일 오후 3시 01분 
I'm not sure. Wheatley's a lovable ♥♥♥♥♥, but GlaDOS's character has more complexity.
I'd say GlaDOS. Wheatley wasn't annoying to me or anything, but I enjoy GLaDOS's sense of humor better.
ihaveathumb 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 12분 
Hell Diguner님이 먼저 게시:
GLaDOS. Wheatley's role/acting/character really grated against me in the last few chapters.

I still wish GLaDOS acted a bit more like she did in Portal 1 though, more random, and more subtle undercurrent of evil.

I think she was less subtle in Portal 1 because she was hiding the fact that she was going to kill you. In Portal 2, you already knew she wanted you dead, so she didn't have to be subtle. At least that's what I think.
Bellomy 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 12분 
GLaDOS. I adored Wheatley, and I thought he was hysterical. But GLaDOS was also wickedly funny, in a more subtle way. Her brand of humor comes in the form of mind games-passive aggressiveness and sarcasm. It's creative and awesome, my type of humor all the way. Plus the voice acting of McLain is just insanely brilliant, she portrays GLaDOS's character arc so perfectly.

Wheatley was awesome and Stephen Merchant did a truly terrific job, I loved him and I'm really splitting hairs here-but GLaDOS. I could pick GLaDOS for Portal 1 alone, let alone McLain's brilliant performance in Portal 2.

Wheatley actually had a really interesting developmental arc himself, and Merchant nailed it, but GLaDOS basically had to deal with having her entire worldview rocked in the span of a single day.

Here's the REAL question: GLaDOS, Wheatley, or Cave Johnson?

Gun to my head, my favorites in order of favorite to least favorite (relatively) are GLaDOS, Wheatley, then Cave. But man, all three of these are just splitting hairs. I LOVE both Cave and Wheatley, both of them have some truly awesome lines, but I just gotta give Wheatley the edge. I just grew too attached to him at the beginning, I love his character. Cave is amazing though.
Bellomy 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 14분 
"I think she was less subtle in Portal 1 because she was hiding the fact that she was going to kill you. In Portal 2, you already knew she wanted you dead, so she didn't have to be subtle. At least that's what I think."

I think you're right. In Portal 2 she's basically toying with you and torturing you before she kills you.

The morality core also has a lot to do with it. When the morality core is destroyed Portal 1 GLaDOS sounds an awful lot like Portal 2 GLaDOS.
ihaveathumb 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 21분 
marchettaanthony님이 먼저 게시:
"I think she was less subtle in Portal 1 because she was hiding the fact that she was going to kill you. In Portal 2, you already knew she wanted you dead, so she didn't have to be subtle. At least that's what I think."

I think you're right. In Portal 2 she's basically toying with you and torturing you before she kills you.

The morality core also has a lot to do with it. When the morality core is destroyed Portal 1 GLaDOS sounds an awful lot like Portal 2 GLaDOS.

I didn't even think of the personality cores. That is a good point. Perhaps they stopped her from vocalizing her true intentions.
Bellomy 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 44분 
ihaveathumb님이 먼저 게시:
I didn't even think of the personality cores. That is a good point. Perhaps they stopped her from vocalizing her true intentions.

I've read some interviews by the creators, and I've read some reviews of the game by average gamers (I'm obsessed, I love the Portal games to an unhealthy extent). One of them noticed that Portal 2 GLaDOS's dialogue didn't sound like either her dialogue in the test chambers or her dialogue "backstage", but it DID sound like a less crazy version of her dialogue after the morality core was destroyed.

I think you can really see the evolution. In the test chambers, she's playing the part of the "simple computer" helping you along. Then when you get backstage she starts panicking and her real personality starts slipping through-but it's still not REALLY her personality since she's still trying to fool you and she's still stifled by the morality core.

Then after the morality core is destroyed all of the layers are peeled back. GLaDOS no longer has anything to hide, and she has nothing stopping her from acting how she really wants to. So she just insults you through these mind games ("it actually made shoes for orphans..."Shall not be mourned. Very official." "Your best friend the companion cube couldn't come because YOU killed him") while she tries to kill you.

In Portal 2 her voice has become slightly more mechanized again, as she has regained some mastery of herself. She's had a LONG time to think, and she knows exactly what she wants: Not just to kill you, but to make you her permanent play thing, her lab rat. She's completely in control of herself. At the end of Portal 1 she could act freely but considering the circumstances around her she had basically gone insane by the end. The Portal 2 GLaDOS is much more prepared, and that's one of the big differences.
ihaveathumb 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 55분 
marchettaanthony님이 먼저 게시:
She's had a LONG time to think, and she knows exactly what she wants: Not just to kill you, but to make you her permanent play thing, her lab rat. She's completely in control of herself. At the end of Portal 1 she could act freely but considering the circumstances around her she had basically gone insane by the end. The Portal 2 GLaDOS is much more prepared, and that's one of the big differences.

Did she have time to time though? She stated that she had to relive her death over and over again. Was she able to consciously think while that was happening? I mean, maybe, but I always thought she couldn't.
17개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
페이지당: 15 30 50
게시된 날짜: 2012년 10월 4일 오전 4시 18분
게시글: 17