Portal 2 > 일반 토론 > 제목 정보
spyknife 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 54분
Did Chell die at the end of the game? What do you think
I read somthing online about that Chell could have possibly died at the end of Portal 2. At the end of the game you are going up the elavator just before GLaDOS called you a lunatic then you meet the turets that dont fire at you but sing. And when you get out of aperture you are in a wheat field when in the first game you you're in the aperture science parking lot in some forest and it also said that in greek mythology you go to a wheat field when you die. So i think the first row of turrets shot Chell and killed her.
168개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
Bellomy 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 58분 
I read that, and first of all the ending is NOTHING like Greek mythology. But it still sounded like a cool theory.

But here's the real answer: No. A couple of reasons for this:

1) You can see Rattman running in the backround among the turrets in the turret opera, for one thing. Why he'd be present in the background of a chorus sending you into the afterlife is a bit odd.

2) The creators confirmed that she's alive and she's escaped.
ihaveathumb 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 58분 
I would think no. My reasoning is the fact that GLaDOS send up the companion cube. She did this as a final thank you for helping her. Chell didn't really care about the companion cube the way rat man did (proof is in his wall drawings) so why would this happen? If it was heaven, then only stuff she loved would be there. Just a guess.
[CLASSY] Fancy Dog 2012년 12월 29일 오후 8시 08분 
i would also think no but that is a great observation. And who is this rattman guy?
Bellomy 2012년 12월 29일 오후 8시 20분 
If you own Portal 2 on Steam, the Rattman comic should be included in the game. If not, just look it up online, you'll find it easily (google "Rat Man comic"). He's the guy scrawling cryptic messages on the walls-the "the cake is a lie" guy.
magician.144 2012년 12월 29일 오후 10시 25분 
She didn't die, Carolyn couldn't kill her child. IMO.
James Eddings, Aper. Sci. Ph.D. 2012년 12월 29일 오후 11시 29분 
One, it's Caroline. I know it's not traditionally pronounced, but that's how it's spelled. Also, we don't know for sure if Caroline (or if GLaDOS is still her) is the mother of Chell and there are evidence to disprove that.

Two, that's not Rattman. It was a Frankenturret that was hobbling across the stage while the turrets were singing. I suggest replaying the video before trying to say otherwise.

Three, it's highly likely that Chell did not die, because GLaDOS felt sympathy and has admitted to it in the Coop campaign. In the Peer Review, GLaDOS has also mentioned Chell briefly later in the story, and refers to her as still living.
James Eddings, Aper. Sci. Ph.D.님이 마지막으로 수정; 2012년 12월 29일 오후 11시 30분
Party Spock Ant(j)hem 2012년 12월 29일 오후 11시 44분 
i dont think she died because she was LOOKING around the wheat field and saw the companion cube appear from the elevator.
Joseph 2012년 12월 30일 오전 9시 18분 
I think that while she didn't die at the end of the game... she will probably die, she has not been a part of society for how many years now? She most likely won't fit in and will become some mute hobo that dies of starvation on the corner of some street IF she even finds civilization at all. If she doesn't find civilization well, she's in this massive wheat field ( with absolutley nothing on the horizon from what I remember) with nothing at all to help her survive, I wouldn't be surprised if she starved or something.

Sorry for such a nagative post, it's just realistically how I think things would play out for her.
Bellomy 2012년 12월 30일 오전 9시 49분 
James Eddings, Aper. Sci. Ph.D.님이 먼저 게시:
Two, that's not Rattman. It was a Frankenturret that was hobbling across the stage while the turrets were singing. I suggest replaying the video before trying to say otherwise.

No, it's Rattman. I've seen it msny, many times, both in game and on youtube. It's a hunched figure holding a companion cube on his back.
Lil' Gideon 2012년 12월 30일 오전 9시 51분 
While the Greek mythology idea ties in well with other parts of the game (the Oracle Turret refers to the story of Prometheus in Chapter 5), it seems unlikely that GLaDOS would kill Chell at the end of the game. GLaDOS herself admitted to hearing her conscience after discovering that she was Caroline.

To sum up, I think Chell didn't die, because GLaDOS's human half (Caroline) was awoken during the game.
[LPD] Huskyfan 2012년 12월 30일 오전 10시 35분 
marchettaanthony님이 먼저 게시:
James Eddings, Aper. Sci. Ph.D.님이 먼저 게시:
Two, that's not Rattman. It was a Frankenturret that was hobbling across the stage while the turrets were singing. I suggest replaying the video before trying to say otherwise.

No, it's Rattman. I've seen it msny, many times, both in game and on youtube. It's a hunched figure holding a companion cube on his back.

It is really a Frankenturret. I had seen it on YouTube, Ratman was never seen in Portal and Portal 2. Why would Valve put Ratman at the end of the game and only in the background where he is hardly seen? Also, if it is Ratman, why would he "walk" so awkward? He is doing little jumps just like a Frankenturret. That's why I think it is a Frankenturret.
Jimbob 2012년 12월 30일 오전 10시 58분 
chell did not die and there is a wheat field cuz GLaDOS is in a different spot and portal and portal 2 are 20 yrs apart and chell can find civillization cuz portal and portal 2 take place during the events of hl, hl2, hl2 ep 1 and ep 2. it is a frankenturret cuz rattman doesent carry the compainion cube like dat.
spyknife 2012년 12월 30일 오전 11시 36분 
It actully is a Frankenturret if you look closley you can see that its kind of hobbling and you can see the shape of a turret.
rbances 2012년 12월 30일 오후 12시 05분 
no becuse thar making a portal 3 so if shes dead how are you going to play
[LPD] Huskyfan 2012년 12월 30일 오후 12시 50분 
rbances님이 먼저 게시:
no becuse thar making a portal 3 so if shes dead how are you going to play
When did Valve said that?
168개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
페이지당: 15 30 50
게시된 날짜: 2012년 12월 29일 오후 7시 54분
게시글: 168