Portal 2 > 일반 토론 > 제목 정보
fqhwhgads 2012년 12월 2일 오후 12시 58분
Portal 2 theory
I have a theory about Portal/Portal 2.

I think that as Cave Johnson and Caroline were close and worked together, Chell could have been the daughter of the two, however was adopted by Doug Rattman as the two did not want Chell to become an obstacle in the workplace.

I think this as GLaDOS makes fun of Chell throughout the story, saying that she is adopted, and this links to the above. It also makes sense as in Portal 2: Lab Rat Doug follows Chell throughout the entire facility, which ties in as he might want to protect her. Chell might not talk as Cave Johnson, her supposed dad, dies in the events before the GLaDOS takeover.

And another thing finally, the thing I forgot to mention about the story is the other meaning to the ending. In Greek Mythology, heaven is a cornfield. When you die, you hear singing and you're accompanied by your best friend (the Companion Cube). The turrets shot her, and she heard singing.
GLaDOS may not of spared her after all.


What do you think? Comment saying what!


And to anyone who says "YOUR TAKIN THIS WAY TO FAR!", I love Portal and know near enough everything about the Half Life/ Portal series.
fqhwhgads님이 마지막으로 수정; 2012년 12월 2일 오후 11시 05분
21개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
Major Havoc 2012년 12월 2일 오후 1시 10분 
I thought Cave was Caroline's Husband. As far as Chell being their daughter goes, I have formed the same theory myself.
As far as the name calling goes, I guessed you missed the sarcasm script reference that is referred to throughout the game, which also affects Wheatly when he takes over.
Soulestia 2012년 12월 2일 오후 2시 19분 
This is actually a common theory.
Mr. Smiles 2012년 12월 2일 오후 6시 43분 
I doubt Chell is their daughter; mostly because her face is modeled off a Brazilian-Japanese actress, and while Caroline is potentially Brazilian (it's hard to tell from a stylized portrait, but she's not NOT Brazilian), Cave is definitely not Japanese.

If it wasn't for Doug Rattmann's very European name, I'd say he's potentially Japanese (again, hard to tell in the comic due to stylization, but he's not NOT Japanese). Somehow I doubt there was a Caroline/Rattmann pairing, however. I have some pretty wild theories about the nature of Chell, but none of them really require Rattmann to be her father, and considering the European name... yeah, seems unlikely.

It's also really hard to pinpoint when Chell was born. If she's as old as her model, she was possibly born in a timespan where Caroline, Rattmann, and Cave were all in the facility at the same time. However, in 200- (the year of the resonance cascade/GLaDOS' takeover), she had the handwriting of somewhere between a brilliant 5-year-old or an average 10-year-old. Her body might've been artificially grown faster than her brain, however, which means she could've been born in the 90s or 2000s--which would place her conception after Cave's death.

So yeah. I seriously doubt on any number of theory-tracks that she's related to Cave even remotely. Caroline, potentially, Doug, distantly potentially.
fqhwhgads 2012년 12월 2일 오후 11시 05분 
Its very possible that Doug was her adopted father as to anyone else in Aperture she would just be another little girl running round the facility, but Doug shows high amounts of interest in her.
Major Havoc 2012년 12월 3일 오전 10시 18분 
Mr. Smiles님이 먼저 게시:
I doubt Chell is their daughter; mostly because her face is modeled off a Brazilian-Japanese actress, and while Caroline is potentially Brazilian (it's hard to tell from a stylized portrait, but she's not NOT Brazilian), Cave is definitely not Japanese.

If it wasn't for Doug Rattmann's very European name, I'd say he's potentially Japanese (again, hard to tell in the comic due to stylization, but he's not NOT Japanese). Somehow I doubt there was a Caroline/Rattmann pairing, however. I have some pretty wild theories about the nature of Chell, but none of them really require Rattmann to be her father, and considering the European name... yeah, seems unlikely.

It's also really hard to pinpoint when Chell was born. If she's as old as her model, she was possibly born in a timespan where Caroline, Rattmann, and Cave were all in the facility at the same time. However, in 200- (the year of the resonance cascade/GLaDOS' takeover), she had the handwriting of somewhere between a brilliant 5-year-old or an average 10-year-old. Her body might've been artificially grown faster than her brain, however, which means she could've been born in the 90s or 2000s--which would place her conception after Cave's death.

So yeah. I seriously doubt on any number of theory-tracks that she's related to Cave even remotely. Caroline, potentially, Doug, distantly potentially.
You have to remember that the Portal series takes place in the Half-Life universe, but the exact time both Portals takes place is rather nebulous. I think it might be safe to say that Portal took place not long after the events at Black Mesa, and Portal 2 might be taking place during Hl2.
But the exact times probably will not be known till HL2 Episode 3 is released, if we ever get to know at all.
Onika 2012년 12월 3일 오후 9시 56분 
if you look closely at one of the bring your daughter to work day presentations it says "by chell"

just putting that out there
fqhwhgads 2012년 12월 5일 오후 11시 39분 
Mok님이 먼저 게시:
You have to remember that the Portal series takes place in the Half-Life universe, but the exact time both Portals takes place is rather nebulous. I think it might be safe to say that Portal took place not long after the events at Black Mesa, and Portal 2 might be taking place during Hl2.
But the exact times probably will not be known till HL2 Episode 3 is released, if we ever get to know at all.



No, Portal takes place during the Combine Invasion of Earth, as Aperture is in lockdown, probably because of the Combine. The end events of Portal take place during the 7 Hour War. I think though that Portal 2 takes place 20 years after the Combine Invasion, during this period Gordon Freeman is revived from statis and he destroys the citadel. It is unknown if the Combine are still on Earth. If not, that might hint that either:

We play Portal 3 BEFORE GLaDOS awakens.

We play Portal 3 as Doug Rattman ( That would be cool but how would we do the first person? )

We play Portal 3 as Chell attempting to survive the Combine Invasion

But then again, VALVe can't count to 3...


zamozer 2012년 12월 6일 오전 12시 34분 
Please add me sil
Kh1326 2012년 12월 6일 오전 11시 12분 
well the most simple explaination is GLaDOS just let chell go!!!
Ciirulean 2012년 12월 7일 오후 4시 31분 
ChaoticPaper님이 먼저 게시:
Mok님이 먼저 게시:
We play Portal 3 as Chell attempting to survive the Combine Invasion
In the Final Hours of Portal 2, Valve wanted to separate the games Half-Life and Portal. To do this, they sent Portal 2 at least 50,000 years in the future.
Ciirulean님이 마지막으로 수정; 2012년 12월 7일 오후 4시 36분
Ciirulean 2012년 12월 7일 오후 4시 51분 
Gaia님이 먼저 게시:
if you look closely at one of the bring your daughter to work day presentations it says "by chell"

just putting that out there
And if you look even closer it says on the right side: Energy of the Future!
PROBLEM
My dad said somebody at the cafeteria ordered too many potatoes so everybody has to do a science project on potatoes now for Take Your Daughter to Work Day and lunch will be french fries. Mr. Johnson said we could use as many potatoes as we liked for our projects but I’m only going to use one. I asked my dad if I could do a different project because I already did a potato battery project in class last year and he said no, Mr. Johnson would get mad.
HYPOTHESIS
Probably the potato will do the same thing it did last year for my class project, except maybe not because I had a new potato last time and this one is pretty old. My dad says his hypothesis is that whoever ordered all the potatoes will probably get fired.
CONCLUSIONS
Last time my potato battery produced 1.5 volts. This time it got 1.6, so I guess it doesn’t matter how old the potato is. The current from the potato battery did not produce enough volts to power anything important. If I used more potatoes maybe I could have gotten more volts, but the one dad brought home smelled and I didn’t want more.
by CHELL

Want proof? Look here: http://forums.thinkingwithportals.com/portal-two/official-proof-that-cave-is-not-chell-s-father-t7182.html
Ciirulean님이 마지막으로 수정; 2012년 12월 7일 오후 4시 52분
Ciirulean 2012년 12월 7일 오후 4시 55분 
ChaoticPaper님이 먼저 게시:
Its very possible that Doug was her adopted father as to anyone else in Aperture she would just be another little girl running round the facility, but Doug shows high amounts of interest in her.
If Doug was her father then wouldn't he recognize her name when looking at the list of test subjects and seeing that REDACTED sign by it? He said that he chose her because of a "hunch". And he's talking to himself just then so he probably wouldn't lie.
Ciirulean님이 마지막으로 수정; 2012년 12월 7일 오후 4시 56분
Digoxin 2012년 12월 7일 오후 10시 00분 
Cave can't be Caroline's husband, because she's married to science.
Now, seriously, the greek mythology thing made me start thinking and stuff... WTF Valve.
fqhwhgads 2012년 12월 11일 오전 10시 56분 
Cube: Why her?
Rat: I don't know
Cube: Did she have the highest IQ score?
Rat: No.
Cube: The highest agility?
Rat: No.
Cube: Then why her?
Rat: Just a hunch.

Thats what is said in the link. Completely links my theory about Doug
Vagrant 2012년 12월 11일 오전 11시 52분 
Digoxin님이 먼저 게시:
Cave can't be Caroline's husband, because she's married to science.
Now, seriously, the greek mythology thing made me start thinking and stuff... WTF Valve.

The Prometheus reference was a metaphor for Glados becoming a potato.
21개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
페이지당: 15 30 50
게시된 날짜: 2012년 12월 2일 오후 12시 58분
게시글: 21