[Heal/Hurt]: The Big Balance Survey

[Chairforce]

Since nothing constructive is going on 'round here at the moment, let's make an attempt to determine which weapons the community considers fine, and which need changing, sorted by urgence.

We'll play a round of Heal/Hurt over the course of the next few days.

Here's how it works:

• Once every 24 hours you can heal one item of your choice, indicating that you think is fine, and hurt one that you consider in need of changes.
  
  
• Hurt the one weapon that you consider the most broken [Over-or underpowered, doesn't matter].
  
  
• Heal a weapon you consider perfectly fine as-is, or at least better balanced than its competitors in this survey.
  
  
• Every 24 hours the item that was considered the most in need of tweaking will be moved to the 'bad list'.
  
  
• Votes targeting an item that's already out will not be considered.
  
  
• Eventually the result will be a priority-list on where work has to be done.

Let me give you an example:

Escrito originalmente por ROYAL_CHAIRFORCE:

Heal Degreaser.
Hurt Enforcer.

I'll try to keep this updated as frequently as possible.
Oh and if possble, keep discussion, be it on or off-topic out of this, as this is supposed to be a survey thread.

Thanks for partcipating.

The Bad List

#1 The Liberty Launcher (-3)

#2 Phlogistinator
and Chargin' Targe (-2 each)

#3 The Gunslinger (-3)

Current Score:[/b]

Black Box +3
Short Circuit +3
Powerjack +2
Sandvich +2
Degreaser +2
Kritzkrieg +1
Reserve Shooter +1
(Stock) Rocketlauncher +1
Concheror +1
Direct Hit +1
Dalokohs Bar +1
Market Gardener +1
Vaccinator +1
Neon Annihilator +1
Force-a-Nature +1

Soda Popper -1
Huntsman -1
Wrangler -1
Winger -1
Big Earner -1
Third Degree -1
Claudemh Môr -1
Enforcer -1
Pomson -2
Machina -2[/quote]

[Hareymon]

no

[Joshua Kurayami]

Heal Degreaser
Hurt Vaccinator

[Tealtyr]

But, you're the creator, your opinions don't count on the board ;_;

Well, I'm an avid lover of spy, so that's what I'll go for.

Heal Axtinguisher
Hurt Big Earner

[Chairforce]

Escrito originalmente por Tylerlego623 #SpheePower:

But, you're the creator, your opinions don't count on the board ;_;

I'm also a member of the tf2 playerbase and as such I happen to have an opinion like everybody else does.

Also, my survey, my rules :P

[DriedMilk]

Heal Sandvich
Hurt Third Degree

[I am lying]

heal enforcer
hurt mini-sentry

[Tealtyr]

Escrito originalmente por aL! ROYAL_CHAIRFORCE:

Escrito originalmente por Tylerlego623 #SpheePower:

But, you're the creator, your opinions don't count on the board ;_;

I'm also a member of the tf2 playerbase and as such I happen to have an opinion like everybody else does.

Also, my survey, my rules :P

;-;

[Pizza hut in the garage]

When you say hurt, I'm assuming that means both nerfing or buffing a weapon?

[Chairforce]

Escrito originalmente por {λ³} System 32:

When you say hurt, I'm assuming that means both nerfing or buffing a weapon?

Yes. Name the one weapon that you consider the most broken.

[Pizza hut in the garage]

Alright then
Heal enforcer
Hurt liberty launcher

Also, inb4 hurt frying pan, its gonna happen sometime.

[Crashman]

Heal Enforcer
Hurt Neon Anihalator (Also my spelling of this)

[Markava]

Heal Loose Cannon
Hurt Axtinguisher

[Mr.Mann]

Heal Mr.Mann
Hurt al! ROYAL_CHAIRFORCE.
Iz very genius idea guise.

[N/A]

*Shrugs*

Heal Kritzkrieg
Hurt Axtinguisher

[Mr.Mann]

Escrito originalmente por aL!Good_HAIRFORCE:

Since nothing constructive is going on 'round here at the moment, let's make an attempt todetermine which weapons the cmmunity considers fine, and which need changing, sorted by urgence.

We'll play a round of Heal/Hurt over the course of the next few days.

Here's how it works:

• Once every 24 hours you can heal one item of your choice, indicating that you think is fine, and hurt one that you consider in need of changes.
  
  
• Hurt the one weapon that you consider the most broken [Over-or underpowered, doesn't matter].
  
  
• Heal a weapon you consider perfectly fine as-is, or at least better balanced than its competitors in this survey.
  
  
• Every 24 hours the item that was considered the most in need of tweaking will be moved to the 'bad list'.
  
  
• Eventually the result will be a priority-list on where work has to be done.

Let me give you an example:

Escrito originalmente por ROYAL_CHAIRFORCE:

Heal Degreaser.
Hurt Enforcer.
Mr.Mann +1
aIROYAL_CHAIR FORCE! -1

I'll try to keep this updated as frequently as possible.
Oh and if possble, keep discussion, be it on or off-topic ou of this, as this is supposed to be a survey thread.

Thanks for partcipating.

Current Score:[/b]

Enforcer +2
Degreaser +2
Reserve Shooter +1
Sandvich +1

Vaccinator -1
Neon Annihilator -1
Liberty Launcher -1
Third Degree -1
Enforcer -1
Gunslinger -1[/quote] [/quote]