ArcaniA – Gothic 4 > Discussioni generali > Dettagli della discussione
{RP}Shea 10 ott 2012, ore 10:51
Arcania: Gold or Risen 1
Hi all i just need a input on which game should i buy,Arcania: Gold or Risen 1 any info would be great
Visualizzazione di 1-13 commenti su 13
< >
Murder Bunny The Battle Rabbit 10 ott 2012, ore 11:22 
both have demos,
risen - http://www.gamershell.com/download_51644.shtml

arcania - http://uk.gamespot.com/arcania-gothic-4/downloads/6278826/platform/pc/

if you can spare the bandwidth try both :)
Shane 10 ott 2012, ore 11:23 
This of course depends on what games you like.
If you liked the gameplay of Gothic 1/2 and maybe 3, you should definately chose Risen 1, because even though there is no story-relation to those games it has much more "gothic-feeling" than its actual sequel.
If you like hack and slay games and do not need an open world to have fun, Arcania is pretty much "okay", but there might even be better games than that.

For a Gothic-fan it's definately Risen imo. For a casual-gamer, who wants to try a RPG, Arcania is better, because of playability.
a.k.a. Dead 10 ott 2012, ore 18:31 
Risen is a much, much - much, deeper RPG. And it is not for the easily frustrated, it can be very tough from beginning to end, even on the easiest difficulty. But I absolutely adored it, one of the finest RPG's ever made.

Arcania Gothic 4 is more of an action game (a very good one at that if you crank up the difficulty), but a very simple (too simple) RPG. I loved Arcania as well once I played it for what it was, it really sucked me into the story and gameworld - and the combat is seriously kick-a*s.

I would get both if you can afford it, and then scratch your deep RPG itch as well as your action game itch. You really can't lose either way.
Ultima modifica da a.k.a. Dead; 10 ott 2012, ore 18:37
Impish 1 nov 2012, ore 21:51 
Risen one of the finest RPG's ever made? Ya right, more like one of the clunkiest RPG's ever made.
boborpacku 3 nov 2012, ore 22:49 
Risen 1 definitely. I played it and Risen 2 too. Arcania is very shallow and dumbed up.
Cygnus 3 nov 2012, ore 23:15 
I need dumbed up, its going to take me 2 years to finish oblivion.
Tried Risen 2 demo liked it , probably catch that later on.
Ultima modifica da Cygnus; 3 nov 2012, ore 23:16
Revelator 1 gen 2013, ore 8:34 
I have all risen, all gothic, arcania all. each has strengths and weaknesses.
but all of them deserve a round.
a.k.a. Dead 24 gen 2013, ore 22:10 
Messaggio originale di Impish:
Risen one of the finest RPG's ever made? Ya right, more like one of the clunkiest RPG's ever made.

Just an opinion. Every bit as valid as yours. And I was commenting on Risen 1 by the way, as Risen 2 has some serious issues with player movement and perpetual stun locks.
Ultima modifica da a.k.a. Dead; 24 gen 2013, ore 22:12
Fuzzy 11 mar 2013, ore 14:38 
Agree with Shane and 19delta3.. if you liked Gothic 1 or 2, you'll definitely want to play Risen 1 (haven't tried 2 yet).
dblade 12 mar 2013, ore 9:31 
Would it be better to get only the base Arcania game and save a couple of bucks? The first review I read was not very fond of the expansion.
D# 13 mar 2013, ore 13:36 
I bought the gold pack just in case I do like the game, you can import your character into the expansion. If you dont get it now it will cost you more than 2.50 to get it later if you end up wanting it.
dblade 13 mar 2013, ore 15:03 
Thanks for the response. I actually ended up buying gold a few hours ago :)
Sethmac 3 apr 2013, ore 12:09 
If you like the gothic 1 & 2 you should still consider risen uses the same type of engine and made by the same people =)
Visualizzazione di 1-13 commenti su 13
< >
Per pagina: 15 30 50