*Gen*. Rocko Dec 8, 2013 @ 6:42pm
This game is not all that good
I dont give reviews that often but this game for me SUXOR! the story line was lame the game play lame I really wish i could find a positive on this game the ending was bad, the game play was ok, ending very bad. Buy this game on hard discount sale does not even come close to the first game. I found this game really lackluster nothing to special worth the 14$ I paid for it not so much.Just a very boring lackluster game not worth what i paid for it wish their was more i am not a troll just a bad game no replay value for me. Just not that good of a game, the hours put it mean nothing..Just not that good of a game..
Showing 1-15 of 25 comments
< >
ineseri Dec 9, 2013 @ 12:12am 
Alright, thanks for your opinion. Here's mine: I enjoyed it. It's not the Dark Descent, but I did not expect it to be that either.
illgib Dec 9, 2013 @ 9:59am 
What did you expected from it?
93Chowo Dec 9, 2013 @ 1:15pm 
I didn´t really have high expectation when I bought this game. I was curious about this whole "pig" theme and how it would turn out. Surprisingly I enjoyed it very much because, in my opinion, the story was well made. If you really couldn´t find something positive in this game that´s bad for you.
ineseri Dec 9, 2013 @ 1:26pm 
I expected it to have a weird, but yet fun story. I got that. It's hard to put into words really lol. I agree with the above poster.
illgib Dec 9, 2013 @ 2:28pm 
I asked to Op, what did he expected from it.
ineseri Dec 9, 2013 @ 2:47pm 
And I replied anyway, because my ego is too big. Lol. Sorry.
 The Law  Dec 9, 2013 @ 8:23pm 
It was an Amnesia game stripped of puzzles and the ability to interact with everything. If you needed to use an object for a puzzle it was immediately obvious because it is the only thing you are able to even click on.

I didn't enjoy the story and the pigs weren't dangerous nor were they scary.

The game would have been ok if it didn't have the name of Amnesia, it made our expectations too high because we loved the first one so much.
93Chowo Dec 10, 2013 @ 4:18am 
Originally posted by Fegelein:
It was an Amnesia game stripped of puzzles and the ability to interact with everything. If you needed to use an object for a puzzle it was immediately obvious because it is the only thing you are able to even click on.

I didn't enjoy the story and the pigs weren't dangerous nor were they scary.

The game would have been ok if it didn't have the name of Amnesia, it made our expectations too high because we loved the first one so much.
I heard that Fricitonal Games will make an update so that models from AMFP can be used for custom stories in TDD. If you´re able to make CS you can show the people how you wanted it to be. :)
illgib Dec 10, 2013 @ 9:39am 
Originally posted by Fegelein:
It was an Amnesia game stripped of puzzles and the ability to interact with everything. If you needed to use an object for a puzzle it was immediately obvious because it is the only thing you are able to even click on.

I didn't enjoy the story and the pigs weren't dangerous nor were they scary.

The game would have been ok if it didn't have the name of Amnesia, it made our expectations too high because we loved the first one so much.
Hey tell me, how difficult where the Dark Descent's puzzles?
Took an object here and place it there. Pull a lever. Took a jar here, go there fill it and use it on that door.
There are 3 major puzzles at all, the remains are just objects moved from here to there. Go play it again and prove me wrong.
I don't say The Dark Descent was bad, but don't overrate it too much, it's all about nostalgia and false expectation build up by yourself.
You prefer the same exact game again for a full price?
Governor Dec 10, 2013 @ 12:51pm 
Game was absoulutely fantastic.
 The Law  Dec 10, 2013 @ 1:36pm 
Originally posted by illgib:
Hey tell me, how difficult where the Dark Descent's puzzles?
Took an object here and place it there. Pull a lever. Took a jar here, go there fill it and use it on that door.
There are 3 major puzzles at all, the remains are just objects moved from here to there. Go play it again and prove me wrong.
I don't say The Dark Descent was bad, but don't overrate it too much, it's all about nostalgia and false expectation build up by yourself.
You prefer the same exact game again for a full price?

The puzzles weren't overly complex but they were much more interesting than 'carry this object and place it in the machine' over and over (seriously you had to do that half a dozen times??) and with the inventory missing there was NO reason to explore areas once you have the objective. Hunting for tinderboxes and oil was fun.

No I don't want exactly the same game but I DID expect an improvement, not worse story/gameplay/scares just.. everything.

I enjoyed TDD custom stories more than I did this trash.

Even the Music was worse.

Sorry but I was extremely disappointed, though you are entitled to your own opinion.
illgib Dec 10, 2013 @ 4:47pm 
You too, but i think you're a bit exagerate. Exploration to find notes that tell you what happened and why, i can't see the difference from tinderboxes and oil. No interest at all in the story? And so why you play story driven games?
 The Law  Dec 10, 2013 @ 4:52pm 
Originally posted by illgib:
You too, but i think you're a bit exagerate. Exploration to find notes that tell you what happened and why, i can't see the difference from tinderboxes and oil. No interest at all in the story? And so why you play story driven games?

You are right about the notes I forgot about that.

The story wasn't very enjoyable to me, mostly just seeing annoying ghost children throughout the whole game. The voiceover was missing from the notes as well, a small touch but it was cool.
SassyLemon Dec 13, 2013 @ 10:06pm 
This was purely story driven and focused. The gameplay mechanics of Dark Decent were far better than A Machine for Pigs', however Dark Decent's story was not up to par with A Machine for Pigs'.
Odin Dec 14, 2013 @ 4:02am 
i have to admit this game is not good at all in my op dont find it scary and still very buggy i know its early access but i feel like a hobbit walking round have removed form my libary
Showing 1-15 of 25 comments
< >
Per page: 15 30 50